Q1 (JAN-MAR) 2009 N400 Filers Tracker

hello everyone,

Has anyone ever received "a decision can not yet be made about your application" after the interview? I am very worried!


Yes, a lot of people have. You need to post the particulars of your case so that people can comment.


Thank you so much for such a prompt response.
The problem is that I have no particulars. My guess is that, since during the interview I initiated information on how I received my green card -- through asylum -- he got suspicious and told me that he needed to review my file.
any similar stories, and if so, please tell me how they end.

TIA
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The problem is that I have no particulars. My guess is that, since during the interview I initiated information on how I received my green card -- through asylum -- he got suspicious and told me that he needed to review my file.
any similar stories, and if so, please tell me how they end.

TIA

If you have met all the naturalization requirements and do not have any run-ins with the law or immigration, you should be fine. He probably needs more time to double-check everything.

I will let others with a similar experience comment.
 
If you have met all the naturalization requirements and do not have any run-ins with the law or immigration, you should be fine. He probably needs more time to double-check everything.

I will let others with a similar experience comment.
what kind of run-ins with immigration do you mean? I had to go to the court to argue my case, although I believe there was no deportation process initiated.
so does the immigration court count?
 
what kind of run-ins with immigration do you mean? I had to go to the court to argue my case, although I believe there was no deportation process initiated.
so does the immigration court count?

What case? Why did you have to go to court? Why do you "believe there was no deportation process initiated"?

I apologize for being blunt, but if you give sketchy details of your case, and that too over multiple posts, chances are that you will get wildly irrelevant answers, or more questions. If you give all the relevant details of your situation in one place, including your conversation with the Interview Officer, then other people may be able to throw some light. Remember this is a laymans forum and there are no lawyers here.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
What case? Why did you have to go to court? Why do you "believe there was no deportation process initiated"?

I apologize for being blunt, but if you give sketchy details of your case, and that too over multiple posts, chances are that you will get wildly irrelevant answers, or more questions. If you give all the relevant details of your situation in one place, including your conversation with the Interview Officer, then other people may be able to throw some light. Remember this is a laymans forum and there are no lawyers here.
you are absolutely right -- I should have given more details.
I applied for an asylum, and after an initial interview, my case was sent directly to the immigration court, as the immigration officer could not make a decision.
the judge ruled in my favor, and as a result I got a green card.

as for the deportation process -- presumably you get a letter informing you that a deportation process has been initiated, and I have never gotten that letter. Neither any of the relevant officials -- the judge, my attorney, any immigration officer I have ever spoken to -- in any way suggested that such a process has been initiated.
I hope this answers your question. please do not hesitate to let me know if you have any others.

Regards
mng
 
you are absolutely right -- I should have given more details.
I applied for an asylum, and after an initial interview, my case was sent directly to the immigration court, as the immigration officer could not make a decision.
the judge ruled in my favor, and as a result I got a green card.

as for the deportation process -- presumably you get a letter informing you that a deportation process has been initiated, and I have never gotten that letter. Neither any of the relevant officials -- the judge, my attorney, any immigration officer I have ever spoken to -- in any way suggested that such a process has been initiated.
I hope this answers your question. please do not hesitate to let me know if you have any others.

Regards
mng

Considering the above, I do not think you need to worry, as you have legitmately got your green card. The Interview Officer probably just needed more time to double check the facts, since you mentioned that you got your GC through asylum.

A lesson learned is probably that you should not have ventured to give more information than asked for during the interview. In my opinion the citizenship interview should be strictly "dont ask, dont tell". If you had ventured this information, you should have produced the past court documents immediately to counter his suspicions, for which you should have made better preparations.

But I think that after checking the facts the IO is likely to approve your case, and you should be getting an Oath Letter (provided you passed your civics test) or at least a second interview letter. If you get denied for any reason, or get called to a second interview, I would strongly recommend that you take the services of the same attorney that you used earlier, and dig through your past court documents to prove your legitimate green card. Good luck with your case, and let us know the happy result when it comes.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Considering the above, I do not think you need to worry, as you have legitmately got your green card. The Interview Officer probably just needed more time to double check the facts, since you mentioned that you got your GC through asylum.

A lesson learned is probably that you should not have ventured to give more information than asked for during the interview. In my opinion the citizenship interview should be strictly "dont ask, dont tell". If you had ventured this information, you should have produced the past court documents immediately to counter his suspicions, for which you should have made better preparations.

But I think that after checking the facts the IO is likely to approve your case, and you should be getting an Oath Letter (provided you passed your civics test) or at least a second interview letter. If you get denied for any reason, or get called to a second interview, I would strongly recommend that you take the services of the same attorney that you used earlier, and dig through your past court documents to prove your legitimate green card. Good luck with your case, and let us know the happy result when it comes.
Thank you so much for the reply.
Again, you are absolutely right -- if i had not volunteered the information, I probably would have avoided all this mess. I did pass my civics test, and sincerely hope that he is not going to make too much of this. I got my GC fair and square, and have a court decision to prove it. I have had enough grief from INS over the years, and not willing to take any more. i contacted my district congressman about the unjust treatment i repeatedly received from them in the past, and thanks to him, I am pretty sure the person who did me wrong was punished. As of today, there was no reason for neither his attitude throughout the interview, nor the conclusion that he came up with. He just said that he needed to review my application. well, if it is denied, I will definitely fight back in any way possible.

Once again, thank you for your attention and help. I can use any encouragement i could get.

Regards

MNG
 
Guidence needed urgently

Hello
I am a newbe. My wife is a PR and has an interview scheduled in Aug at Newark. I am currently on F1 and we got married in India and have a marraige certificate of India (in English). Will that be accepted as valid marraige certificate or we have to get registered again here. WE are planning to file for my change of status after she gets her citizenship. Also do we need her US passport for applying for me or naturalization certificate is OK. Please guide
 
Hello
I am a newbe. My wife is a PR and has an interview scheduled in Aug at Newark. I am currently on F1 and we got married in India and have a marraige certificate of India (in English). Will that be accepted as valid marraige certificate or we have to get registered again here. WE are planning to file for my change of status after she gets her citizenship. Also do we need her US passport for applying for me or naturalization certificate is OK. Please guide

During my interview IO took Marriage Certificate (English) from India to keep it in the file.
 
Hello everyone,

I would like to share my interview details. It was scheduled at 2 PM, at NYC office. Got there at 1:30 PM. The officer, who collected my interview letter, warned me that the waiting time was at least an hour and a half. Sure enough, had to wait even longer.

The interviewing officer was a man, with clear signs of Germophobia. He did not attempt to shake my hand, but simply led me to his office. As soon as we set down, he pushed a pen, which was chained to the desk, with his finger towards me so only his fingernail touched it, and instructed me to use it if necessary. He did not smile even once during the interview, and a couple of times when I by mistake almost touched his pen, he got really annoyed, and did not try to hide it.
The test was laughably easy and went well. I answered all his questions, and wrote a simple sentence that he dictated.

I filled out the application back in november of 2008, but sent it in march. The problem was that, one of my projects that I anticipated to come through got cancelled, but since in November it was still very much viable, I put it in my application's work experience section. I sent out the application without correcting it, which was my mistake. After I explained circumstances, he made a comment to correct it, and made me to put my initials next to it.
I received my GC though asylum, and it somehow came up during the interview. He started drilling me about it, although several times he himself said that since it was an interview for citizenship, we had to concentrate on that. At the end he handed me a paper -- it turned out to be a N-652 form -- and told me that he had to take copies of my passport and GC. He offered no explanation, other than that he needed to review my file again.
Overall experience was AWFUL beyond believe. Several times when I tried to offer explanation on some matters, he cut me off, and complained that my answers were too extensive. He was curt to the point of being rude, and seemed extremely annoyed with everything I did or say. It was brutal.
I hope they videotape interviews, because if he gives me a negative answer for any reason, I am absolutely going to sue the agency.
In any case, is there an average wait time for this kind of situation, and if so, could you please let me know how much longer should I suffer?
TIA

Regards

MNG



03/09/2009 -- N-400 sent to Lewisville, TX
03/11/2009 -- N-400 received
03/19/2009 -- Notice/priority date
03/20/2009 -- Check cashed
03/21/2009 -- Notice received
04/07/2009 -- FP Notice received
04/08/2009 -- FP Done (Walk-in, FP Appointment was scheduled for 04/16/2009)
05/08/2008 -- CFR (Yellow letter) received
06/02/2009 -- Interview letter received
06/16/2009 -- Interview/ got N-652 with choice B checked -- a decision cannot be made about your application
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Another example of a NYC IO who loves his job. (sarcasm intended).

Don't worry, he probably just needed to get secondary approval or something since it was asylum based GC. You'll get your answer in several weeks.
 
Another example of a NYC IO who loves his job. (sarcasm intended).

Don't worry, he probably just needed to get secondary approval or something since it was asylum based GC. You'll get your answer in several weeks.
Thank you for the reply.
I cannot wait this to be over.

Regards

MNG
 
Received Oath Notice. I have refered this site every step of my H1B, Green Card and now citizenship. Sometimes I had to use this site to educate my Attorney all you folks are great and thanks. Please see my signature for details and Let me know if I can answer any of your questions.
 
MNG
same thing happened with me.for more elaboration you can check my postings in political asylum section.
lets prey to GOD...
 
Interview postponed

Hi Folks,

Hubby's interview was postponed today. The IO called him and since FBI name check got cleared so soon, his interview was scheduled by mistake before he completes 5 years after GC. She said that they will be mailing out a new interview letter for him soon. Bummer!
 
San Jose moving well!

D/O San Jose

02/18/2009: PD
03/06/2009: Notice received
03/13/2009 Received FP Notice (Appointment Date 3/26)
03/14/2009: FP Done - Walk-In.
04/13/2009: Received Interview letter(for June 3rd). Praise God!
06/03/2009: Completed Interview - Passed
06/18/2009: Received Oath Letter (for July 16th)
07/16/2009: Oath Date - Done
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Top