Sony
As we all know that sometimes some people strongly believe that they are right in their causes/beliefs even though in reality they are not. I know that you don’t want to admit that you were wrong when you continued to stay here on a student visa without attending school even for one day. That’s why no wonder why you are kept saying over and over that you did not do anything wrong. I think that deep in your heart you know well that you did wrong when you continued to stay here, rather than going back to your home country after knowing that you would not be able to attend the school. If not, then we all would love to know how you were not wrong. Can't you see any wrong when you continued to stay here on F-1 visa without attending school even for one day regardless of why you were unable to attend the school? Can't you see that you had to go back to your home country when you realized that your sponsor and co-sponsor could not support you for your studies in USA? Can't you see that it is wrong and illegal to live here illegally? Don't tell me that you were not legal. Even though you had valid F-1 visa, you were not supposed to use it for the purpose of living here without going to school. But if you still think that you did nothing wrong then prove to us. But stay focused on legality of the issue than emotional/sympathetic and any other irrelevant reasoning.
I don’t want to hurt your feelings at all. I’m just trying to let you know that what you think about all this drama is completely wrong. And, whatever you are thinking/saying to justify your previous acts is completely irrelevant here, because none of these arguments cut off the fact which shows in your case about having pre-intent when you obtained student visa and when you sat foot on US soil; otherwise INS had not denied your N-400. Pay attention: I'm not saying that you had no intention to go to school when you obtained student visa. I believe you wholly that you really had intention to go to school when you arrived here on F-1 visa. Instead, all I'm saying that when someone doesn't attend school after being admitted on F-1 visa then it's seemed that such person had pre-intent to use nonimmigrant visa for immigrant purpose. That's why INS thinks the same. Let me tell you where you were wrong. You were wrong when you continued to stay here knowing well that you could not attend the school. That's what you did wrong. If you had left the country, INS had not even bothered you.
By the way, marrying with US citizen forgives overstaying and working without permission automatically, but not pre-intent of immigration fraud. And I also told you that just because you were granted green card previously, then doesn't mean that officer reviewed each information on you carefully last time. That's why many wrongdoings come to INS attention during citizenship time. You said that if justice won’t serve then it would be their loss. Who are they here? No body would loose anything here except you and your family.
I told you previously in very much details that you having obtained GPA later on or completed the study later on, doesn’t prove that you had no pre-intent of migrating to US for good when you obtained student visa and when you set your foots on US soil. Neither it has anything to do with sincerity and dedication. If you like to connect it with your sincerity and dedication, then INS could also say that-“Oh, yeah. You were sincere and dedicated to circumvent US immigration laws to live here permanently when you obtained US student visa, especially when you did not attend school even for one day.”
I also told you that a student visa was not issued to you to show your sincerity and dedication towards studies later on (a couple years down to the road). Instead, it was issued to you to show your sincerity and dedication about studying in the USA at the very first moment; otherwise US Embassy had no any other reason to issue you that visa. Do you think Consular officer would have still issued you a student visa if you would have informed to the officer at the time of obtaining student visa that you would be sincere and dedicated towards your plan of studying in the USA a couple years later? In my opinion, you better not talk about your sincerity and dedication to INS during your hearing because they know very well how sincere and dedicated you were when you DID NOT LEAVE the USA despite of not attending school over here on F-1 visa.
I also told you previously that no matter what your personal situations/circumstances were after setting foot on US soil, you had no LEGAL right whatsoever to continue stay in USA once you knew that you could not be able to attend school because your sponsor and co-sponsor failed to support you for your studies. You need to pay attention here that govt. has legal duty and responsibility to filter the fraud out. That’s what they are doing in your case. Besides, they are talking about legality of the issues and not the morality of them.
I personally don't think that Harish was trying to make you a liar person. He was just pointing out the inconsistences in your statements as you previously failed to mention about your uncle as a co-sponsor. So obviously, we were all wondering why you were now talking about your uncle as a sponsor when you previsously said about your brother as a sponsor. Now we know once you cleared all this up.
If you really want to live here, then you must need to have a reasonable and logical answer on this, other than talking about sincerity and dedication that you mentioned here. Earlier when I said that your application would be approved this time, then I thought that you would answer to them what I told you before and stick to your story.
Anyway, good luck.
