Hi all,
Today I attended my interview for AoS based on being a 2019 DV Lottery selectee.
Everything was perfect until the very end. I had every document ready, I answered every yes/no question with a NO, I had all the originals, copies, certified translations, all...
Then, after passing all the interview -I would have said at that moment, like PERFECT-, the officer told me she would deny my case because of the early filing date.
My cut-off number was announced on the October 2018 Visa Bulletin (published on September 2018), and my number was in announced in that bulletin as an advance number for the November 2018 bulletin. I had already everything prepared and submitted everything as soon as the bulletin announced my advanced number for November 2018 (again, the October bulletin was published on September, as usual), and USCIS received my package in September 20.
The officer told me it should have been submitted on or after October 1st.
When I mailed everything, I acted according to this memo:
August 9, 2013
Policy Memorandum
Acceptance of Diversity Visa-Related I-485 Applications During the Advance Notification Period Reflected in the Visa Bulletin
(I can't copy the URL, you can find the memo in google by typing "USCIS policy memo august 9 2013.)
That memorandum states:
"The “Receive Date” of the adjustment application (the date the application is received at the Lockbox) will dictate whether the application has been timely filed. As soon as a Visa Bulletin is published with advance notification of DV visa availability, then an individual with a rank cut-off number that is lower than that specified in the advance notification section may file for adjustment and the application will be considered as timely filed."
"For example, in the November 2012 Visa Bulletin, the advance notification DV rank cut-off number for Europe in December 2012 is listed as being 9,250. Therefore, immediately upon release of the November 2012 Visa Bulletin (i.e., on or about October 9, 2012), any person who could be charged to Europe who had a rank cut-off number below 9,250 was eligible to file an application for adjustment of status, even though the adjustment application could not be adjudicated to completion prior to December 1, 2012."
"In addition, an ISO must review the current month’s Visa Bulletin at the time of final adjudication to confirm that the applicant’s DV visa rank cut-off number is lower than that specified in that month’s Visa Bulletin (not the advance notification section), and if so, will request allocation of a visa number through IVAMSWEB."
I tried to explain this to the officer, and confirmed her that my number was lower than the specified in the actual November bulletin, not in the advance section of the October's one, but she invited me to review the filing procedure again. She handed me a notice that my case would be "held", and advanced me not to be surprise when I will receive the final decision as "denied" in my mail box.
What happened here? Did I do something wrong? Is that memo out of effect? I think I did the appropiate filing, on time, "immediately upon release of the October 2018 Visa Bulletin" (which was published in September 2018).
What are my options now? There are only 2 months left... will I have enough time to get my GC before September 30? Some people is telling me to apeal (which cost around $675? and may took years...), other people is telling me to restart all the process, and submit everything again (including payment checks, biometrics, do a new medical check...).
I am very surprised and lost.
Thanks in advance. Any help is more than welcome.