EA premium processing, I got RFE, help please
- Thread starter good_y
- Start date
eb11-NSC-rfe
Registered Users (C)
thanks madgu-gc2005 for posting your status. I also got an RFE for my EB1A(PP) dates are exactly the same as yours. Can you post what your RFE is about when you come to know? I have already posted mine in a separate thread. It looks like NSC is issuing everyone RFE's.
jgimmigrant
New Member
Evaluations
For great service. You should check out Education Evaluators International. I worked with a guy named Jay and he really helped me out. 646-290-7658. Ask for him by name. I needed an expert opinion letter and a translation and everything came back timely and done to perfection.
For great service. You should check out Education Evaluators International. I worked with a guy named Jay and he really helped me out. 646-290-7658. Ask for him by name. I needed an expert opinion letter and a translation and everything came back timely and done to perfection.
GC_SEP2005
Registered Users (C)
No I don't think so
Hi good_y,
I don't think if student member would be not be enough. You should get full membership or atleast associate membership if thats allowed in your society. It also depends on how your society approve membership. The one I am a associate member requires to have atleast 2 papers, atleast 1-2 years of work in the field and has to be proposed by two full time members of the society. For student members they only need letter from the mentor. So it all depends on your society. I would say get the full time membership and you can put the money spend on membership into your taxes (thats what I am told). Best of Luck.
GC_SEP2005
Hi good_y,
I don't think if student member would be not be enough. You should get full membership or atleast associate membership if thats allowed in your society. It also depends on how your society approve membership. The one I am a associate member requires to have atleast 2 papers, atleast 1-2 years of work in the field and has to be proposed by two full time members of the society. For student members they only need letter from the mentor. So it all depends on your society. I would say get the full time membership and you can put the money spend on membership into your taxes (thats what I am told). Best of Luck.
GC_SEP2005
good_y said:
eb11-NSC-rfe
Registered Users (C)
GC Sep2005,
If you are responding to an RFE you CANNOT add membership NOW and include that in the RFE application process.All credentials/associations/publications must have been received before the date your original 140 application was received at NSC.
Thought I might chime in.
If you are responding to an RFE you CANNOT add membership NOW and include that in the RFE application process.All credentials/associations/publications must have been received before the date your original 140 application was received at NSC.
Thought I might chime in.
eb11-NSC-rfe said:
That is not true, most lawyers keep material just for the RFE, meaninig new publications etc. MOst people I know always send new stuff to the RFE. Like me, I have a review form the "Bangkok Times" I didnt send it in June because this happend in September, so its totally normal to send it with the RFE, is very standard.
eb11-NSC-rfe
Registered Users (C)
tipotodo,
What I mentioned as ORIGINAL (SCIENTIFIC) PUBLICATIONS is not the same you are referring to. These if appeared in the literature after your RD of your 140 petition is NOT permitted. What you are mentioning to is, review of an article that have been already published before, or somebody has written about you, in that case they can be used , only thing is the performance/original article published date (they are refering to in the material) HAS TO HAPPEN before the RD.
In my post I was referring to good_y idea of getting a promotion to his current membership and include that in his RFE. I believe that cannot be done. Evidence of Memberships, scientific publications for a case is determined by its RD, anything after that is not counted. Others may sure know better.
What I mentioned as ORIGINAL (SCIENTIFIC) PUBLICATIONS is not the same you are referring to. These if appeared in the literature after your RD of your 140 petition is NOT permitted. What you are mentioning to is, review of an article that have been already published before, or somebody has written about you, in that case they can be used , only thing is the performance/original article published date (they are refering to in the material) HAS TO HAPPEN before the RD.
In my post I was referring to good_y idea of getting a promotion to his current membership and include that in his RFE. I believe that cannot be done. Evidence of Memberships, scientific publications for a case is determined by its RD, anything after that is not counted. Others may sure know better.
I agree of the publications
hi Gc_sep_2005, tipotodo, and eb11- NSC_RFE,
when I applied for student membership, after reviewing the credentials they offered me an associate membership. so I can produce that letter.
Another association give membership for thsi year or next year, if you apply in sep to dec time.
My attorney wants to stress the point that I am an outstanding researcher, as the associations are ready to upgrade my membership based on the credentials. I hope that may work out.
hi Gc_sep_2005, tipotodo, and eb11- NSC_RFE,
when I applied for student membership, after reviewing the credentials they offered me an associate membership. so I can produce that letter.
Another association give membership for thsi year or next year, if you apply in sep to dec time.
My attorney wants to stress the point that I am an outstanding researcher, as the associations are ready to upgrade my membership based on the credentials. I hope that may work out.
Last edited by a moderator:
GC_SEP2005
Registered Users (C)
Got RFE
Ok Guys I also join the bandwagon
. I got an RFE will let you all know what it is about once I hear from my Attorney. Nice way to start a week.....
Ok Guys I also join the bandwagon
. I got an RFE will let you all know what it is about once I hear from my Attorney. Nice way to start a week.....tipotodo said:Your totally right, I am sorry, I did'nt see you were refering to Original Scientific Publications!Sorry
GC_SEP2005 said:Ok Guys I also join the bandwagon
Hi GC_SEP2005:
Sorry to hear that. Pls. post the developments and details of RFE. I guess it must be the same as for others. I think, this is the first RFE from TSC in this forum. My case, I am still to hear something from NSC... No LUDs after first 2 in PP. Will update the developments.
BTW, did you see any changes in the case status online?
Subra
TSC to join the NSC
GC_sep2005, sorry to hear about the RFE, I think the disease spread from NSC to TSC. Hope the RFE will be simple to answer.GC_SEP2005 said:Ok Guys I also join the bandwagon
Sorry to hear about the RFE GC-2005
Hi GC-2005
Thought you would be the first one to tell the good news from TSC. Could you share the detail about the RFE you received.
-------------
I-140/I-485/I-765 RD at TSC 10/3, ND 10/4
I-140 LUD 10/5
I-285 LUD 10/5
FP code-3 11/2
I-765 LUD 10/27, AD 10/27. EAD received 10/28
Hi GC-2005
Thought you would be the first one to tell the good news from TSC. Could you share the detail about the RFE you received.
-------------
I-140/I-485/I-765 RD at TSC 10/3, ND 10/4
I-140 LUD 10/5
I-285 LUD 10/5
FP code-3 11/2
I-765 LUD 10/27, AD 10/27. EAD received 10/28
GC_SEP2005
Registered Users (C)
I think we burnt our finger
Yes I did see change in the online status. I think some people were asked to work after thanksgiving day and I had thought may be the officer would be in good mood after lovely turkey but it did not turn that way as I saw lud on saturday also so must be stressed out and sent a RFE. But I think I was exprecting it as I think we jumped in for PP when it was too hot and burnt our self. May be we should have waited for it to cool a bit, if I am right there were too many PP applications flooded in the center and they had less staff so they figured it out the best way is to send RFE so that they buy some time. I was also hoping of giving some good news but hey may be we all get good news after replying to the RFE. I checked with my attorney and she said she has not got anything yet and will let me know as soon as she gets it.
Good_y I think its ok to send some fresh information in RFE as it would put some more weight on the application and yes its not advisable to send all the information at once while submitting the application as then one would not have anything if a RFE is given.
Any way good luck to all and I will keep you updated.
Yes I did see change in the online status. I think some people were asked to work after thanksgiving day and I had thought may be the officer would be in good mood after lovely turkey but it did not turn that way as I saw lud on saturday also so must be stressed out and sent a RFE
. But I think I was exprecting it as I think we jumped in for PP when it was too hot and burnt our self. May be we should have waited for it to cool a bit, if I am right there were too many PP applications flooded in the center and they had less staff so they figured it out the best way is to send RFE so that they buy some time. I was also hoping of giving some good news but hey may be we all get good news after replying to the RFE. I checked with my attorney and she said she has not got anything yet and will let me know as soon as she gets it. Good_y I think its ok to send some fresh information in RFE as it would put some more weight on the application and yes its not advisable to send all the information at once while submitting the application as then one would not have anything if a RFE is given.
Any way good luck to all and I will keep you updated.