update
I think you should redo fingerprints even if ASC tells you that they are in. ASC does not know what was the result that FBI sent back to USCIS from your first biometrics. I read online that there are cases where fingerprints are unreadable or there is some other problem. In this case USCIS would issue a second biometrics. I am really sorry that this is happening. As I said before I think there was a major mess up with our cases in the beginning and that's why things are not going smoothly.
Ok. so I called USCIS customer service and they were useless. I asked if I could speak to some one who knew about this and they said no. Then I insisted and the supervisor knew less than the person below. She kept telling me that the fingerprinting office is the one who issues the notice and that they are the only ones who know. So I asked if I could call them- she said no.
So I did a little investigating on the internet and after twenty mins I found a phone number and I called the fingerprint office here in NY.
Miracle of all miracles, a supervisor answered the phone. I explained my story to him and he knew what I was talking about and he asked intelligent questions!!! I could not believe it!
This is pretty much what happened:
(explanation history and three notices)
Q: what is the date of the third notice?
A: 1/30/09
Q: When did you come see us for the second time?
A: 2/2/09
Q: When you were here the second time, did a supervisor scan your appointment letter and check your fingerprints in the system?
A: Yes.
Q: Did they take a test fingerprint to confirm who you were?
A: Yes.
Q: Did they take another biometric picture of you?
A: Yes.
Q: And did they stamp your second notice?
A: Yes.
Q: What is the code in the upper right hand corner for the notices?
A: The first is 1. The second is 2 and the third is 2.
At which point he asked me for my A# and my name and checked in the computer.
He then said: I have confirmed that we have your fingerprints and they are ok. Any Immigration officer who looks at your file will know you did them and that they are ok. I can confidently say that you do NOT need to come to see us again and I say that because you were here after the date of issuance of the third notice and we confirmed your fingerprints were here and retook your biometric. Sometimes the system generates multiple notices and I apologize for that.
He then said: however, if you had received a second or third notice with a code 1 on it, I would have told you to come in again (because code 1 means fingerprints). Code 2 is biometrics. The officer whom you saw on monday knew what she was doing because she retook your biometric.
He then told me that contrary to what it says on the paper, they will not abandon your case if you miss the appointment IF the thing they are looking for has been done. He said that when he punched the A# into the system it does not state this person came out of order for the fingerprints, or came twice, or three times- all it says is whether they are in the system or not. Since mine are definitely in the system (it was confirmed on monday and by him) I should not worry.
He gave me his name and said to write it down if it made me feel more at ease but that if I were to show the third time, they would confirm what he said on the phone.
I thanked him profusely and hung up.
Now (just to be on the safe side) I intend to write a letter to them, attach the notices and say I spoke to the Supervisor today and am therefore ignoring the third notice.
Thanks for the advice all!