Dual Citizenship and Travel to Canada

Imagine this scenario. You approach a Canadian POE. The CIC officer has had a real bad day. You present your US passport and request entry. He uses his discretionary powers and denies you entry. You iterate that you are a Canadian citizen and show him your place of birth as Canada on your US passport. He asks you to first prove that you were not born there when your parents held diplomatic immunity. What will you do?

In my opinion you should carry your Canadian passport. At the end of the day, it is your call.


I don't know, I'll research more, but thanks for the inputs. I just was curious if anyone has just used the US passport and how their experience was. And no not renouncing the citizenship, I can still be one and not own a passport from them in their eyes...
 
Yummyk, current rules for Canadians living outside of Canada allow a relative with a Canadian passport to be a guarantor, even if living in the same premises as the applicant.

Your guarantor must:

Hold a five-year Canadian passport that is valid* or has been expired for no more than one year, on the day you submit your application;
Have known you personally for at least two (2) years.
In the case of a child, have known you (parent or legal guardian) personally for at least two (2) years and have knowledge of the child;
Be a Canadian citizen 18 years of age or older;
Have been 16 years of age or older when he or she applied for his or her own passport.
In the case of a child, in cases where provincial family services have placed a child for adoption with a family, until the adoption is final (probationary adoption), the Provincial Director of Family Services, the Director of the Family Services Agency or the Director of the Incorporated Institution (in Québec) may also sign as guarantor.

Family members and those residing at the same address as yourself may be your guarantor provided he or she meets the specified requirements.Please note however that if you are the parent or legal guardian applying for a passport for your child, you cannot act as guarantor.

Why is it in human nature that we seem to get along well until we cost some token money to a country and then everyone jumps up and down to remove privileges. It happens everywhere, not only in Canada, it happens here with immigrants receiving benefits. I think it is rather selfish and it is exploited by unscrupulous politicians. How can we know how Canadian those expatriates felt? Even that, how can one differentiate which Canadian deserves consular help and which not?
Thanks for the info. That's good to know, and it does make it somewhat easier than it used to be. I agree that it used to be a major PITA, and of course the passports are only valid for 5 years. I also had problems finding a photographer in the US who could take pictures according to Cdn. passport requirements. They accept the dimensions of the US passport photos, but I had mine rejected because of the quality of the photo. Anyway, eventually I found a photo shop here in Orange County, CA that can handle the job!

I agree with you that everything works fine until a situation arises like the one in Lebanon a few years back. However, if Canadians are upset by this they have nobody but themselves to blame. One can only assume that those people had come to Canada, followed the rules and applied for naturalization just as they were encouraged to do. They are citizens with all the rights and privileges that that entails. Rather than outlawing dual citizenship, or increasing fees for passports for expats, perhaps what people and governments in Canada need to be asking is how they can encourage newcomers (and their children) to stick around once they are naturalized. In a global economy, countries compete for the best and brightest people. Once naturalization is conferred, such people have many more options.
 
Imagine this scenario. You approach a Canadian POE. The CIC officer has had a real bad day. You present your US passport and request entry. He uses his discretionary powers and denies you entry. You iterate that you are a Canadian citizen and show him your place of birth as Canada on your US passport. He asks you to first prove that you were not born there when your parents held diplomatic immunity. What will you do?

In my opinion you should carry your Canadian passport. At the end of the day, it is your call.

I can't imagine ever seeing a Canadian Immigrations Officer ever have a bad day and just deny someone. US yes, Canadian, no. Especially driving through.

I'll bring both this time and just try the US passport and see what happens, but if some rare chance they question I'll just show my Canadian one and just say I wasn't aware of what I should do and just play dumb. At least I'll get to know first hand how they deal with the issue...
 
I-94 for family

Hi,
I am Canadian citizen. I recently received my H1B approval and my I-94 effective from 10/01/08. I am on E1 right now. Can anyone suggest the best way to get I-94 for my family. Should I apply being in the country or can I get it done at the border?
Thanks, mzkfar.
 
I don't know if I'm stateless. I'm still a citizen of my country as far as my country is concerned. I can, if I want, get a passport. I just would rather not.
 
warload, please let us know how your experience is when entering Canada with a US passport. I am in exactly the same situation.

Family members and those residing at the same address as yourself may be your guarantor provided he or she meets the specified requirements.

Can my wife and I be the guarantor to each other? Our Canadian passports expire on the same date and we likely need to renew at the same time.

In the past when we need to renew Canadian passport but could not find a guarantor, we will get two friends to sign affidavit and then get a notary public to notarize it. It is a hussle indeed. Somebody mentioned that the Canadian passport photo is not easy to take. How true!
 
warload, please let us know how your experience is when entering Canada with a US passport. I am in exactly the same situation.



Can my wife and I be the guarantor to each other? Our Canadian passports expire on the same date and we likely need to renew at the same time.
!

Yes, you can be guarantor of each other provided you have known eachother for more than 2 years.
 
Doesn't one need to belong to a licensed profession to be a guarantor? My US citizen wife is a PharmD and she was able to sign my Canadian passport application.

Yes, you can be guarantor of each other provided you have known eachother for more than 2 years.
 
Doesn't one need to belong to a licensed profession to be a guarantor? My US citizen wife is a PharmD and she was able to sign my Canadian passport application.

The old guarantor rules allow only relatives (either Canadian or US citizen) of certain professions to be guarantors. That stipulation is no longer required if your relative is Canadian and holds a valid passport, or one that has been expired less than 1 year.

http://www.ppt.gc.ca/form/pdfs/pptc153.pdf

A guarantor is a person other than yourself who confirms your identity.
Your guarantor:
must be a Canadian citizen 18 years of age or over;
must hold a five-year Canadian passport that is valid or has been expired for no more than one year on the day you submit your application;
must have been 16 years of age or older when he or she applied for the passport identified in section 2 of this application form;
must have known you personally for at least TWO (2) years*;
*
To know an applicant personally means that the guarantor is able to confirm aspects of the applicant's personal attributes such as name, approximate age, place of birth, physical description and some personal history such as occupation and place of residence.
must provide the requested information contained in his or her passport;
must be accessible to Passport Canada for verification.
A family member or person residing at the same address as you may be your guarantor, provided that he or she meets the specified requirements
 
Perhpas the qn the OP should answer is -- Can a Cdn citizen enter CN with an expired Cdn passport along with a valid US PP ?
 
Top