N 400 denied

No they don't revoke GC but denial can trigger deportation if the reason for denial is criminal conviction. Why did they deny your application for naturalization?
 
I never work for my sponsor employer after I received my GC. and I have not applied for N-400 yet. I'm just worried about this.
 
Tahachal said:
I never work for my sponsor employer after I received my GC. and I have not applied for N-400 yet. I'm just worried about this.
Click to expand...

Can you invoke AC-21?

When did you get your GC? on N400 you are required to list employment history for the past 5 years.
If you apply for citizenship, say 6 or even 7 years after, you got the GC, then the IO can not even see that you did not work for the sponsor. They can still ask but most likely tehy skip it
 
Did you commit fraud to get your greencard? If you did, then you should be afraid, never get arrested, never apply for naturalization, crawl under a rock and never come out.

OR are you making something out of nothing, like you had a long delayed adjustment application process and relied on AC 21 portability to make a lateral move to a new employer in the same or similar position?

We see all sorts of stories on this website. Usually, people are just misinformed or misstate information.......................
 
Tahachal said:
I never work for my sponsor employer after I received my GC. and I have not applied for N-400 yet. I'm just worried about this.
Click to expand...

In one of your post you said you received an email or text about your N400 local office transfer and you haven't applied for N400? I think you have a bigger issue in your hands. You have opened different threads about this but every time someone asks you a pertinent question that will help in giving you a correct answer, you don't reply but yet you open another thread. not sure what kind of answer you are looking for.
 
fairlakes said:
In one of your post you said you received an email or text about your N400 local office transfer and you haven't applied for N400? I think you have a bigger issue in your hands. You have opened different threads about this but every time someone asks you a pertinent question that will help in giving you a correct answer, you don't reply but yet you open another thread. not sure what kind of answer you are looking for.
Click to expand...

Here is OP case status..
Received email regarding file case transfer to local office.
PD 4/21/10
FP 5/20/10
Transfer to local office-07/16/2019
He had a transfer to local office since071310...and he is from Atlanta DO...meaning he had an interview around end of August..and the outcome was either decision can not be made or N400 was denied already and OP is now worrying about NTA and scare of the GC being revoke...
 
givepeoplehope said:
Here is OP case status..
Received email regarding file case transfer to local office.
PD 4/21/10
FP 5/20/10
Transfer to local office-07/16/2019
He had a transfer to local office since071310...and he is from Atlanta DO...meaning he had an interview around end of August..and the outcome was either decision can not be made or N400 was denied already and OP is now worrying about NTA and scare of the GC being revoke...
Click to expand...

Yeah for him to stay he is just worried about it and he hasn't applied for N400 when in fact he already applied (from a previous thread) will definitely get him incorrect answers instead of getting answers that will probably guide him on his next step.
 
givepeoplehope said:
Here is OP case status..
Received email regarding file case transfer to local office.
PD 4/21/10
FP 5/20/10
Transfer to local office-07/16/2019
He had a transfer to local office since071310...and he is from Atlanta DO...meaning he had an interview around end of August..and the outcome was either decision can not be made or N400 was denied already and OP is now worrying about NTA and scare of the GC being revoke...
Click to expand...

It appears that he hasn't applied, but his wife applied and her case is the one with the dates you quoted above. See http://forums.immigration.com/showthread.php?312107&p=2181373

Tahachal said:
My spouce received GC based on my I-485. My spouce applied N400 last month. She never had any ticket or any Problem with law inforcement. Will she be in trouble , because I did not work for my sponsoring company. please help.
Click to expand...

Then apparently they denied her N-400 because she was questioned about his employment and admitted he didn't work for the sponsor.
 
I think he is going to have to prove that he intended in good faith to stay with the company but the company went out of business. If he shows that there are things that happen out of his control like company going out of business and he was forced to change jobs or career, he will be fine. How would someone stay with a cpmpany that has closed their doors it's impossible. He should appeal his wife's N400 outcome. Company going out of business and just leaving "in business" company after GC are 2 different things. If the wife answered that question without explaining or without proof that the company went out of business, MAY BE that's the reason it was denied. Either way, if i were him i will appeal USCIS decision
 
Last edited by a moderator:
There is too much speculation involved to know what the best course of action would be. If the poster ever provides an honest detailed narrative of the situation perhaps he could get some useful information. If he can't be honest in an anonymous post on a web blog, he will be crucufied by an Immigration Officer face-to-face.
 
fairlakes said:
If the wife answered that question without explaining or without proof that the company went out of business, MAY BE that's the reason it was denied.
Click to expand...
Maybe that is the case; his wife went into the interview not expecting to answer questions about his employment, and probably doesn't know about AC21, so she was unprepared to explain things properly to defend herself and his situation.

There have been a few other occasions reported on this forum where one spouse (the derivative for the GC process) was asked about the other spouse's historical employment situation.

Either way, if i were him i will appeal USCIS decision
Click to expand...
Appealing is worthwhile only if they're in the right. If he's in the wrong (never worked a day for the sponsor after GC approval, nor in another AC21-compliant job), he needs to forget about appealing, and hope they don't deport.
 
BigJoe5 said:
There is too much speculation involved to know what the best course of action would be. If the poster ever provides an honest detailed narrative of the situation perhaps he could get some useful information. If he can't be honest in an anonymous post on a web blog, he will be crucufied by an Immigration Officer face-to-face.
Click to expand...

That's really funny and to the point. It is a bit frustrating when people post cryptic messages and never care to come back to provide more details. I understand people being nervous about USCIS using this posts against them, but if he's so worried he shouldn't have even posted the cryptic message.
 
Thanks for the comments. Yes, my wife applied for N-400 which approved on August. They did not asked her anything regarding my job, her interview was very simple and she had owth on same day.
Actually, we applied for green card (labor certification) on 2001 with new law EB 245(i), and I'm pretty sure all of you know 245(i). I did not have to work with my sponsoring company while my case was pending, and only they will hire me after I recieved my green card. Also, I did not need Ac21.My green card approved on 2005, but my sponsoring company was having financial problem and after couple of months after my GC approved they were out of business. But I'm still working with same company since 2004, and I submitted my employment letter form this company on my I-485 interview.
 
Misinformation explains it.

245(i) solved it up front and you are worried over nothing. You paid the penalty and got grandfathered. To answer the original question, no.

You would have to be deportable for a real reason to lose your greencard.
 
BigJoe5,
Thanks for the reply. I'm going to submit my N-400 very soon. I just found antoher person who has similar situation like mine, he did not have any problem for N 400 approval.
 
I have submitted my N-400 on Jan 4, 2011. I hope everything will go smoothly.

Recived date- Jan 4, 2011.
Priroty date- Jan 6, 2011.
Finger print notice received- Jan 18, 2011.
Appontment date- Jan 31, 2011.
Finger Print done(walk in)- Jan 20, 2011.
 
Hi there,

I applied for n 400 (3 year rule) and got a denial letter saying that I falsely claimed to be a US Citizen.
I have applied for a special agent position with the FBI and I am not sure if whether I have check yes to that answer or no and even if I did it is an honest mistake...
I have the option to appeal the decision with N 336
The officer that I have spoken to told me that I am ineligible for ever filling the N400 because of this.
I don't have any tickets, register for the selective service, file my taxes on time ...the only thing I have on me is the darn check mark
this coming march would be my fifth anniversary for having the GC

my questions are:
-is scheduling a hearing an tell my side of the story waste of money (650)? really dont have an evidence to present
-if i did file for a hearing in Florida where i am @ right now and then moved to NY do i have to wait to meet the residency requirement before i get called in for an interview?

Thank you
 
MoeMan said:
my questions are:
-is scheduling a hearing an tell my side of the story waste of money (650)? really dont have an evidence to present
-if i did file for a hearing in Florida where i am @ right now and then moved to NY do i have to wait to meet the residency requirement before i get called in for an interview?

Thank you
Click to expand...
There's no point appealing because you did falsely claim to be a US citizen by signing the FBI employment form. Speak with an experienced lawyer to determine how to best defend yourself.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top