EA premium processing, I got RFE, help please

sagn said:
Hi good_y

You have wonderful qualifications. I wonder whether these guys are really qualified to touch your application. But few guys I know who got approved (eb1-ea) recently with one fourth of your qualification.

sagn
Click to expand...

NSC just wants drag good_y's case futher so that they can reach 6 months limit. that is my guess. good_y is highly qualified and as you said whether these guys are really qualified or not. that is a good thought. I know good_y will get through this hurdle.
 
Thank you guys!

madgu-gc2005 said:
NSC just wants drag good_y's case futher so that they can reach 6 months limit. that is my guess. good_y is highly qualified and as you said whether these guys are really qualified or not. that is a good thought. I know good_y will get through this hurdle.
Click to expand...
Thanks Sagn, and madgu-gc,
thank for your nice words, now I feel may be my presentation was not impressive, or they want me to go through an attorney.
Any way I am collecting another 5 letters (headache is drafting them), and the copies of papers sighted my work, letter from another journal editor, and hope my attorney will write a good covering letter to make that fellows happy.
Thanks and hope you people get the approval soon. RFE is really a headache!
 
good_y said:
Thanks Sagn, and madgu-gc,
thank for your nice words, now I feel may be my presentation was not impressive, or they want me to go through an attorney.
Any way I am collecting another 5 letters (headache is drafting them), and the copies of papers sighted my work, letter from another journal editor, and hope my attorney will write a good covering letter to make that fellows happy.
Thanks and hope you people get the approval soon. RFE is really a headache!
Click to expand...

Good_y,

When you hire attorney do you have to write the reco letter? 5 letters is really more and it might take time. YOu went through him already and so he knows your stuff. Yes RFE is a headache!
 
not exactly

5 letter is the people confirmed today to give. one from Glaxo, one from EPA, and 3 from universities. Will it do?
My attorney charges me for the number of hours he work for me, so if I do most of the work I don't have to pay much and can save time too, I do the draft and he will correct them. I saw LUD11/16 too, I don't know what the hell they are doing?
 
good_y said:
5 letter is the people confirmed today to give. one from Glaxo, one from EPA, and 3 from universities. Will it do?
My attorney charges me for the number of hours he work for me, so if I do most of the work I don't have to pay much and can save time too, I do the draft and he will correct them. I saw LUD11/16 too, I don't know what the hell they are doing?
Click to expand...

5 letters are very good enough. Have your attorney to go through the reco letter you draft. How much he is changing? is it 100-200 $? It is worth if you just tell him to do everything and you pay him $1000 irrespective of hours he works.
 
that is what I too think now, his charges were $290/hr, he was working for a company, now he started independently, so possibly the rates go down.
hope the $1000 may work out, I have to talk to him.
 
good_y said:
that is what I too think now, his charges were $290/hr, he was working for a company, now he started independently, so possibly the rates go down.
hope the $1000 may work out, I have to talk to him.
Click to expand...

better to hire on contract not on hourly basis. U might end up paying more than $1000.
 
see some responses below. Hope these help. Good luck.

good_y said:
I submitted PP on 11/13, and today I got an RFE;
Most of the things are what I have submitted,
I will give the details
The record does not include evidence of a major internationally recognized award,
- This is a tough one. Scholarships/fellowships won't work. Although if you have any awards such as "Scientist of the Year", that might be useful.


2. The record does not establish that you are the recipient fo nationally or internationally recognized prizes or awards of excellence
- Same as above. Again scholarships etc don't work.


3. documentation of your membership in associations which require outstanding achievements for membership
- This one, you have to get letters from the associations to prove that you can't just get a membeship by paying.


4.Published material about you in professional or major trade publications or other major media relating to your work in the field for which classification are sought.
- If you have any of these, like an article on your work/yourself related to the work or your achievement - may it be in the trade journals or newspapers (may it be local) - that will help.

5.The record does not contain published accounts of your career achievements in qualifing media.
- I don't get this one. Probably this might fit in your area of something.

6.Evidence in the panel;
- If you were on committees of grad students. Then submit a copy of the passing certificate of that student which you would have signed, when on his/her committee.
- And if you have any communication letters/email etc, showing the requests sent to you and acceptance etc, for being on any publications panel, grant proposal evaluations panel etc - submit those.


7.Records lacks evidence that you serve on the editorial board of scientific journals
- If you have reviewed articles for different journals - submit all those communication between you and the editors/associate editors etc. They usually send you a thank you letter each time you review the article. Print all those email/mail communications.
- You should have reviewed enough articles to prove.

everything as from the criteria for EA category was listed.
I have submitted all the evidences but they want it again, I have to submit it before February 9, 2007
Please give me some suggestions for preparing the RFE.
Thanks to all.
Click to expand...
 
thanks

Hi EB1ORG,
Thanks for your helpful suggestions, I think I can collect all the documents again and it will be something like a resubmission. My work was sited in some industry publications and some seminars -industry oriented. I think I will grab all those things.
so when you submit citations-do you put the entire paper cited your reference or only the first page and the reference appearing page? your suggestions are precious. Thanks
 
Ea-pp - Lud 11/17

Hi All:

I see a LUD this morning.

EB-1A - Regular submission: 10/18;
PP RD-11/15; LUD-1: 11/16; LUD-2: 11/17

Will update the development.

Any others got LUD for the PP?

BTW, they have not yet cashed my $$$$!!!??

Thanks

Subra
 
Last edited by a moderator:
subra70 said:
Hi All:

I see a LUD this morning.

EB-1A - Regular submission: 10/18;
PP RD-11/15; LUD-1: 11/16; LUD-2: 11/17

Will update the development.

Any others got LUD for the PP?

BTW, they have not yet cashed my $$$$!!!??

Thanks

Subra
Click to expand...

Hi All:

I too saw a LUD this morning.

Will update the development.

Any others got LUD for the PP? Good_y got his RFE on the third day after NSC received his package. I am really tensed now. Because it is third day after NSC my package. Let us hope for the best.
 
Exactly!

Hi:

I am also very much tensed as good_y got RFQ on the third day. Hmm... Waiting....

Subra
 
subra70 adn madgu_gc,
hope things will work out for you. I too saw the LUD the same way, which I feel they are reading through the file now (3 rd LUD, no message change). so today u will get the decision from NSC, possibly before evening. I got my fax by noon the same day. You people will get the approval, Let us hope for the best.
 
subra70 said:
Hi:

I am also very much tensed as good_y got RFQ on the third day. Hmm... Waiting....

Subra
Click to expand...

Thanks good_y.

good_y (the ONLY reference we have in this forum) got his RFE by fax around noon on the third day. With reference to him if we do not get RFE by 1 pm today then may be we are through. YOu keep posting the development. I am really in tension. Oh! God! what a Day!!!!
 
Hi

I saw LUD yesterday and today 10 AM for my pp EB1-EA.

Sagn

madgu-gc2005 said:
Thanks good_y.

good_y (the ONLY reference we have in this forum) got his RFE by fax around noon on the third day. With reference to him if we do not get RFE by 1 pm today then may be we are through. YOu keep posting the development. I am really in tension. Oh! God! what a Day!!!!
Click to expand...
 
Hi

good_y

did you get email message along with fax message?

Sagn

good_y said:
subra70 adn madgu_gc,
hope things will work out for you. I too saw the LUD the same way, which I feel they are reading through the file now (3 rd LUD, no message change). so today u will get the decision from NSC, possibly before evening. I got my fax by noon the same day. You people will get the approval, Let us hope for the best.
Click to expand...
 
sagn said:
good_y

did you get email message along with fax message?

Sagn
Click to expand...
No, I just checked the fax machine, is far from my office room, after lunch and the hell was lying there. I got the messsage change in the evening, so if I have not checked the fax, I could have waited all the time. I think they sent you a copy by mail too.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top