Help, PLEASE. VAWA appeal, EAD about to expire. URGENT

pbc

Registered Users (C)
Hi, my vawa was denied back in July and I am in the process of appealing it. I applied as a battery child, along with my mother. Hers was approved. The appeal was sent to the Administrative Offices of Appeal in DC in Nov... Because my I360 was denied, my i485 was also denied.. My EAD expires in January, and I do not want to lose my job. I am 24 years old, have been here for 14 years, college graduate, and have now a great job. I am lost, I havent slept in days, can someone please give me an advice? I would be extremely thankful.
 
What was the reason for denial? Is it because you're too old?

Did you file a Motion to Reopen before sending an appeal to the AAO?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It was denied because I was too old, however, it stated that I had up to 25 to file if the abuse was a delay... And also because I did not provide a background clearance, since mine was from 07.. So I resent a new one done by the state. My step dad was finally jailed last year, so that is why I took a while. My mother married him when I was 18, but lived with him before. My mothers was approved and she received her green card already...

I did not file a motion to reopen for the i485. Just appealed the i360...
 
SEE: http://www.uscis.gov/err/B9 - Batte...ecisions_Issued_in_2006/Jun292006_01B9204.pdf

You were too old to create the required step relationship to the abuser. You said you were 18 when mom married him. The marriage had to take place BEFORE you reached 18. That is from the statute at:

INA 101

(b) As used in subchapters I and II of this chapter--

(1) The term ``child'' means an unmarried person under twenty-one
years of age who is--
*****
(B) a stepchild, whether or not born out of wedlock, provided
the child had not reached the age of eighteen years at the time the
marriage creating the status of stepchild occurred
;
*****************************************************

Mom can file an I-130 for you since she is an LPR and can upgrade it when she naturalizes. To benefit from that you will have to overcome the unlawful presence bar by going abroad for 10 years OR

if you have been in a lawful nonimmigrant status since you were a child or at least since you were 18 1/2 years old. [That is not likely.]

If they don't renew 245(i), you will not be able to adjust unless some day you marry a USC or an LPR who eventually naturalizes AND you initially had a lawful entry AND you don't get deported. Things do not look promising.

******************************************************************************
8 CFR § 204.2 Petitions for relatives, widows and widowers, and abused spouses and children.

(e) Self-petition by child of abusive citizen or lawful permanent resident —

(1) Eligibility.

(i) A child may file a self-petition under section 204(a)(1)(A)(iv) or 204(a)(1)(B)(iii) of the Act if he or she:

(A) Is the child of a citizen or lawful permanent resident of the United States;

(B) Is eligible for immigrant classification under section 201(b)(2)(A)(i) or 203(a)(2)(A) of the Act based on that relationship;

(C) Is residing in the United States;

(D) Has resided in the United States with the citizen or lawful permanent resident parent;

(E) Has been battered by, or has been the subject of extreme cruelty perpetrated by, the citizen or lawful permanent resident parent while residing with that parent;

(F) Is a person of good moral character; and

(G) Is a person whose deportation would result in extreme hardship to himself or herself.


(ii) Parent-child relationship to the abuser. The self-petitioning child must be unmarried, less than 21 years of age, and otherwise qualify as the abuser's child under the definition of child contained in section 101(b)(1) of the Act when the petition is filed and when it is approved. Termination of the abuser's parental rights or a change in legal custody does not alter the self-petitioning relationship provided the child meets the requirements of section 101(b)(1) of the Act.\

(iii) Citizenship or immigration status of the abuser. The abusive parent must be a citizen of the United States or a lawful permanent resident of the United States when the petition is filed and when it is approved. Changes in the abuser's citizenship or lawful permanent resident status after the approval will have no effect on the self-petition. A self-petition approved on the basis of a relationship to an abusive lawful permanent resident will not be automatically upgraded to immediate relative status. The self-petitioning child would not be precluded, however, from filing a new self-petition for immediate relative classification after the abuser's naturalization, provided the self-petitioning child continues to meet the self-petitioning requirements.


(iv) Eligibility for immigrant classification. A self-petitioner is required to comply with the provisions of section 204(c) of the Act, section 204(g) of the Act, and section 204(a)(2) of the Act.


(v) Residence. A self-petition will not be approved if the self-petitioner is not residing in the United States when the self-petition is filed. The self-petitioner is not required to be living with the abuser when the petition is filed, but he or she must have resided with the abuser in the United States in the past.


(vi) Battery or extreme cruelty. For the purpose of this chapter, the phrase “was battered by or was the subject of extreme cruelty” includes, but is not limited to, being the victim of any act or threatened act of violence, including any forceful detention, which results or threatens to result in physical or mental injury. Psychological or sexual abuse or exploitation, including rape, molestation, incest (if the victim is a minor), or forced prostitution shall be considered acts of violence. Other abusive actions may also be acts of violence under certain circumstances, including acts that, in and of themselves, may not initially appear violent but are a part of an overall pattern of violence. The qualifying abuse must have been committed by the citizen or lawful permanent resident parent, must have been perpetrated against the self-petitioner, and must have taken place while the self-petitioner was residing with the abuser.


(vii) Good moral character. A self-petitioner will be found to lack good moral character if he or she is a person described in section 101(f) of the Act. Extenuating circumstances may be taken into account if the person has not been convicted of an offense or offenses but admits to the commission of an act or acts that could show a lack of good moral character under section 101(f) of the Act. A person who was subjected to abuse in the form of forced prostitution or who can establish that he or she was forced to engage in other behavior that could render the person excludable under section 212(a) of the Act would not be precluded from being found to be a person of good moral character, provided the person has not been convicted for the commission of the offense or offenses in a court of law. A self-petitioner will also be found to lack good moral character, unless he or she establishes extenuating circumstances, if he or she willfully failed or refused to support dependents; or committed unlawful acts that adversely reflect upon his or her moral character, or was convicted or imprisoned for such acts, although the acts do not require an automatic finding of lack of good moral character. A self-petitioner's claim of good moral character will be evaluated on a case-by-case basis, taking into account the provisions of section 101(f) of the Act and the standards of the average citizen in the community. If the results of record checks conducted prior to the issuance of an immigrant visa or approval of an application for adjustment of status disclose that the self-petitioner is no longer a person of good moral character or that he or she has not been a person of good moral character in the past, a pending self-petition will be denied or the approval of a self-petition will be revoked.


(viii) Extreme hardship. The Service will consider all credible evidence of extreme hardship submitted with a self-petition, including evidence of hardship arising from circumstances surrounding the abuse. The extreme hardship claim will be evaluated on a case-by-case basis after a review of the evidence in the case. Self-petitioners are encouraged to cite and document all applicable factors, since there is no guarantee that a particular reason or reasons will result in a finding that deportation would cause extreme hardship. Hardship to persons other than the self-petitioner cannot be considered in determining whether a self-petitioning child's deportation would cause extreme hardship.


(2) Evidence for a child's self-petition —

(i) General. Self-petitioners are encouraged to submit primary evidence whenever possible. The Service will consider, however, any credible evidence relevant to the petition. The determination of what evidence is credible and the weight to be given that evidence shall be within the sole discretion of the Service.

(ii) Relationship. A self-petition filed by a child must be accompanied by evidence of citizenship of the United States citizen or proof of the immigration status of the lawful permanent resident abuser. It must also be accompanied by evidence of the relationship. Primary evidence of the relationship between:

(A) The self-petitioning child and an abusive biological mother is the self-petitioner's birth certificate issued by civil authorities;

(B) A self-petitioning child who was born in wedlock and an abusive biological father is the child's birth certificate issued by civil authorities, the marriage certificate of the child's parents, and evidence of legal termination of all prior marriages, if any;

(C) A legitimated self-petitioning child and an abusive biological father is the child's birth certificate issued by civil authorities, and evidence of the child's legitimation;

(D) A self-petitioning child who was born out of wedlock and an abusive biological father is the child's birth certificate issued by civil authorities showing the father's name, and evidence that a bona fide parent-child relationship has been established between the child and the parent;

(E) A self-petitioning stepchild and an abusive stepparent is the child's birth certificate issued by civil authorities, the marriage certificate of the child's parent and the stepparent showing marriage before the stepchild reached 18 years of age, and evidence of legal termination of all prior marriages of either parent, if any; and

(F) An adopted self-petitioning child and an abusive adoptive parent is an adoption decree showing that the adoption took place before the child reached 16 years of age, and evidence that the child has been residing with and in the legal custody of the abusive adoptive parent for at least 2 years.


(iii) Residence. One or more documents may be submitted showing that the self-petitioner and the abuser have resided together in the United States. One or more documents may also be submitted showing that the self-petitioner is residing in the United States when the self-petition is filed. Employment records, school records, hospital or medical records, rental records, insurance policies, affidavits or any other type of relevant credible evidence of residency may be submitted.


(iv) Abuse. Evidence of abuse may include, but is not limited to, reports and affidavits from police, judges and other court officials, medical personnel, school officials, clergy, social workers, and other social service agency personnel. Persons who have obtained an order of protection against the abuser or taken other legal steps to end the abuse are strongly encouraged to submit copies of the relating legal documents. Evidence that the abuse victim sought safe-haven in a battered women's shelter or similar refuge may be relevant, as may a combination of documents such as a photograph of the visibly injured self-petitioner supported by affidavits. Other types of credible relevant evidence will also be considered. Documentary proof of non-qualifying abuse may only be used to establish a pattern of abuse and violence and to support a claim that qualifying abuse also occurred.


(v) Good moral character. Primary evidence of the self-petitioner's good moral character is the self-petitioner's affidavit. The affidavit should be accompanied by a local police clearance or a state-issued criminal background check from each locality or state in the United States in which the self-petitioner has resided for six or more months during the 3-year period immediately preceding the filing of the self-petition. Self-petitioners who lived outside the United States during this time should submit a police clearance, criminal background check, or similar report issued by the appropriate authority in the foreign country in which he or she resided for six or more months during the 3-year period immediately preceding the filing of the self-petition. If police clearances, criminal background checks, or similar reports are not available for some or all locations, the self-petitioner may include an explanation and submit other evidence with his or her affidavit. The Service will consider other credible evidence of good moral character, such as affidavits from responsible persons who can knowledgeably attest to the self-petitioner's good moral character. A child who is less than 14 years of age is presumed to be a person of good moral character and is not required to submit affidavits of good moral character, police clearances, criminal background checks, or other evidence of good moral character.


(vi) Extreme hardship. Evidence of extreme hardship may include affidavits, medical reports, protection orders and other court documents, police reports, and other relevant credible evidence.

(3) Decision on and disposition of the petition —

(i) Petition approved. If the self-petitioning child will apply for adjustment of status under section 245 of the Act, the approved petition will be retained by the Service. If the self-petitioner will apply for an immigrant visa abroad, the approved self-petition will be forwarded to the Department of State's National Visa Center.


(ii) Petition denied. If the self-petition is denied, the self-petitioner will be notified in writing of the reasons for the denial and of the right to appeal the decision.

(4) Derivative beneficiaries. A child of a self-petitioning child is not eligible for derivative classification and must have a petition filed on his or her behalf if seeking immigrant classification.

(5) Name change. If the self-petitioner's current name is different than the name shown on the documents, evidence of the name change (such as the petitioner's marriage certificate, legal document showing the name change, or other similar evidence) must accompany the self-petition.

(6) Prima facie determination.

(i) Upon receipt of a self-petition under paragraph (e)(1) of this section, the Service shall make a determination as to whether the petition and the supporting documentation establish a “prima facie case” for purposes of 8 U.S.C. 1641, as amended by section 501 of Public Law 104–208.

(ii) For purposes of paragraph (e)(6)(i) of this section, a prima facie case is established only if the petitioner submits a completed Form I–360 and other evidence supporting all of the elements required of a self-petitioner in paragraph (e)(1) of this section. A finding of prima facie eligibility does not relieve the petitioner of the burden of providing additional evidence in support of the petition and does not establish eligibility for the underlying petition.

(iii) If the Service determines that a petitioner has made a “prima facie case” the Service shall issue a Notice of Prima Facie Case to the petitioner. Such Notice shall be valid until the Service either grants or denies the petition.

(iv) For purposes of adjudicating the petition submitted under paragraph (e)(1) of this section, a prima facie determination:

(A) Shall not be considered evidence in support of the petition;

(B) Shall not be construed to make a determination of the credibility or probative value of any evidence submitted along with that petition; and,

(C) Shall not relieve the self-petitioner of his or her burden of complying with all of the evidentiary requirements of paragraph (e)(2) of this section.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
is there any other way I can request the EAD? I can wait, I just do not want to lose my job. What about Withholding of removal? I have been here for 14 years... Came when I was 10. My main concern is to have the valid EAD.. I can wait to legalize...I havent slept in days, my mind is going crazy..
thank you so much.
 
is there any other way I can request the EAD? I can wait, I just do not want to lose my job. What about Withholding of removal? I have been here for 14 years... Came when I was 10. My main concern is to have the valid EAD.. I can wait to legalize...I havent slept in days, my mind is going crazy..
thank you so much.


I would recommend a good night sleep, lack of sleeping in days won't produce any positive effects, except to destroy you. In the interim, I don't think your employer will be waiting for you on the day of EAD expiration to produce a new one, would they? I can imagine how frustrating this must be for you, but I wonder what lack of sleep has produced in terms of solving your current dilemma....? Obviously, your situation is too big because you are in it, but just try to calm down and await the outcome of your appeal.
 
SEE: http://www.uscis.gov/err/B9 - Batte...ecisions_Issued_in_2006/Jun292006_01B9204.pdf

You were too old to create the required step relationship to the abuser. You said you were 18 when mom married him. The marriage had to take place BEFORE you reached 18. That is from the statute at:

INA 101

(b) As used in subchapters I and II of this chapter--

(1) The term ``child'' means an unmarried person under twenty-one
years of age who is--
*****
(B) a stepchild, whether or not born out of wedlock, provided
the child had not reached the age of eighteen years at the time the
marriage creating the status of stepchild occurred
;
*****************************************************

Mom can file an I-130 for you since she is an LPR and can upgrade it when she naturalizes. To benefit from that you will have to overcome the unlawful presence bar by going abroad for 10 years OR

if you have been in a lawful nonimmigrant status since you were a child or at least since you were 18 1/2 years old. [That is not likely.]
(C) Shall not relieve the self-petitioner of his or her burden of complying with all of the evidentiary requirements of paragraph (e)(2) of this section.


Big Joe,

I hope you caught the ball which was dropped in NYC last night, understand it arrived in the Mid-West with your name on it. I have mentioned that you are one of my favorite posters on this board, but it is possible to trim down and cut to the chase of the advise you dish out? At times, I become dizzy looking at your long posts....:(

Did I deliver? I hope so, in a nice way...:)
 
Big Joe,

I hope you caught the ball which was dropped in NYC last night, understand it arrived in the Mid-West with your name on it. I have mentioned that you are one of my favorite posters on this board, but it is possible to trim down and cut to the chase of the advise you dish out? At times, I become dizzy looking at your long posts....:(

BigJoe seems to be in a self-initiated competition to see who can post the most words per day. He doesn't realize that this isn't a courtroom where the judge expects the lawyers to submit to a 50-page brief to support their client. When a forum post has thousands of words, people's eyes just glaze over and they don't read it.
 
I would recommend a good night sleep, lack of sleeping in days won't produce any positive effects, except to destroy you. In the interim, I don't think your employer will be waiting for you on the day of EAD expiration to produce a new one, would they? I can imagine how frustrating this must be for you, but I wonder what lack of sleep has produced in terms of solving your current dilemma....? Obviously, your situation is too big because you are in it, but just try to calm down and await the outcome of your appeal.

thank you Al. It has been the rough, although I am only 24, this has taken a toll on me, somedays where i just want to pack up my bags and move back, leave all my family behind, but then again, Ive been here since I was 10, and it's pretty much all i've known. I am anxiously waiting my appeal, or a miracle. If you happen to know any other methods I can go about, please do not hesitate.
I appreciate it.
 
Pbc, you are not the only one being tormented by the current immigration laws.
Al Southner is right. Stressing over this issue to the point of experiencing insomnia will only destroy you.

Pray for a miracle, stay away from trouble, lay low, and remember that there are millions of people out there going through the same issues as you are. Hopefully, immigration policy will change soon - creating a path for AOS for people like you and me.

I was totally pissed off when my case developed complications...but after reading threads posted by people who are currently under removal proceedings, I chilled out - realized that they are far worse of than I. So, Relax, get some sleep - a few beers might help...(just remember not to get behind the wheels).

Its a cruel world out there, please don't engage in self destruction.

thanks
Stressed out AOS applicant drinking to get some sleep...
 
Remember that this forum is sponsored by a law firm. Advising someone to act illegally is not an appropriate response on any forum and certainly not on this one.
 
thank you all for such encouraging words. The insomnia has not gone away, but I have faith that things work out, and that nothing in life is easy. Nothing worthwhile that is.
I am not one to seek trouble, I finished college here, work hard, and always seeking to do what is right. I appreciate all the advice, and hope that one day, others will realize that we need this immigration policy to change.

Please keep me updated on your status manalive, and anyone, if you have any advice, please feel free to share.

THANK YOU!!!!
 
Top