CSC-I140 RFE cases

You can use your own copy of W2

Hi

Even my friends got the same words as you mentioned here.
But they simply sent their W2's. So dont worry about that. But if you want , you can always get the copy from IRS. This is just my opinion. Dont take it as legal use. Consult with your lawyer too...

dieuhi said:
Hi All,
I got an RFE last week for I-140,
The RFE says: "Tax Documents - Beneficiary: If beneficiary employed with the petitioner, submit a copy of the beneficiary's signed, dated & IRS printout federal tax returns for the started years to present. The tax returns must also include copies of the beneficiary's IRS Form W-2 (Wage and Tax Statement)."

I discussed with my lawyer; it is unclear what they mean by IRS printout. Below is the link to irs.gov for ordering copies of returns and transcripts. My lawyer said that to be safe, get both. Here is the link: http://www.irs.gov/faqs/faq-kw31.html. My question was, can I use my own copies of Tax documents or I have to order it for IRS. My problem was that 2004 Tax will be available from IRS only after August 2005.

Did anybody get the same kind of RFE? Thanks.
Click to expand...
 
susinca said:
Have just received approvals for EAD. Replied to I-140 RFE (credential evaluation) about 4/8/05. Is this a good sign as I heard that if there were RFEs they also hold EAD/AP. Is there any link or am I clutching at straws :)
Click to expand...

yes its a good sign.. my EAD was also issued after the RFE response and after 2-3 days of EAD approval my I-140 was also approved.
 
Hello All

My Lawyer responded to my RFE and CIS received the RFE response ( As per FEDEX delivery ) last week and I don't see any updates in the message and also no LUD . Is it similar to any one of you. Can you please share any of your expereinces. I am under the impression that the message online changes when they recieve the RFE response. Thank you .
 
Same Boat but on different seat :)

Hi

I am also in the same boat. RFE received on April 22. Had message change on April 26. LUD change on Apr 28. After that nothing happened. So dont worry. It happens when you need it most. Wait for couple more days, things will work out.

waitingforGC200 said:
Hello All

My Lawyer responded to my RFE and CIS received the RFE response ( As per FEDEX delivery ) last week and I don't see any updates in the message and also no LUD . Is it similar to any one of you. Can you please share any of your expereinces. I am under the impression that the message online changes when they recieve the RFE response. Thank you .
Click to expand...
 
Thanks for your help!
Did your friend get approved after response to the RFE?


noor_iqb said:
Hi

Even my friends got the same words as you mentioned here.
But they simply sent their W2's. So dont worry about that. But if you want , you can always get the copy from IRS. This is just my opinion. Dont take it as legal use. Consult with your lawyer too...
Click to expand...
 
140 approval notice & 485-Inquiry!

My 140 was approved on 05/05/05 and have not received the approval notice yet.
Meanwhile my lawyer sent an inquiry on my 485.
Below is the inquiry and the response.
Could some one tell me what it means?

********* inquiry ***********
Date: 5/17/05 4:08 PM
Company Name: xxxxxx
Beneficiary Name: xxxxxxxxx
Receipt: WAC-xx-xxx-xxxxx
Receipt date: 9/7/xxxx

Past processing time. Please adjudicate.

***** USCIS response **********
The file at question will be approved and updated in the system in the next
few days. An approval notice will be mailed out to the address of record.
Regards.
EB3 Substituted Labor Concurrent
Labor PD :10/22/2001
I-140 & I-485 RD : 08/31/2004
I-140 & I-485 ND : 09/07/2004
FP Scheduled Date : 10/13/2004
FP Receipt Date : 10/19/2004
AP AD : 10/15/2004
EAD AD : 10/18/2004
LUD on I - 485 : 11/04/2004 [Due to Inquiry]
LUD on I - 485 : 12/21/2004 [Don't know why]
LUD on I - 485 : 03/29/2005 [Don't know why]
LUD on I - 140 : 03/29/2005
RFE on I-140 [03/30/2005]
Responded for the RFE on 04/29/2005.
Received by USCIS on 05/02/2005 (LUD changed because of this on 05/03/2005)
Approved 140 on 05/05/05 but LUD changed only on 05/10/05.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I got a RFE for 140 and 485 for both me and wife.
Details for my case as under
140 and 485 RD 10/14/2004
LUD's
140 01/10/05, 04/26/05, 05/10/05
485 - 01/06/05, 01/07/05, 01/10/05, 03/24/05, 04/26/05, 05/10/05.


I don't know what RFE is about.
 
Hey gcfordesi01 ,

Congratulations for your approval . Could u tell us what was your RFE about?

Thanks
gcfordesi04 said:
Hi Gang!

I would like to share the happy news with you folks that i got my 140 approved after the RFE. I got the magic emails last night. Please see my case details on the signature.

Regards.
EB3 Substituted Labor Concurrent
Labor PD :10/22/2001
I-140 & I-485 RD : 08/31/2004
I-140 & I-485 ND : 09/07/2004
FP Scheduled Date : 10/13/2004
FP Receipt Date : 10/19/2004
AP AD : 10/15/2004
EAD AD : 10/18/2004
LUD on I - 485 : 11/04/2004 [Due to Inquiry]
LUD on I - 485 : 12/21/2004 [Don't know why]
LUD on I - 485 : 03/29/2005 [Don't know why]
LUD on I - 140 : 03/29/2005
RFE on I-140 [03/30/2005]
Responded for the RFE on 04/29/2005.
Received by USCIS on 05/02/2005 (LUD changed because of this on 05/03/2005)
Approved 140 on 05/05/05 but LUD changed only on 05/10/05.
Click to expand...
 
Hey noor ,

Any luck with your RFE ? What was your RFE about?


noor_iqb said:
Hi

I am also in the same boat. RFE received on April 22. Had message change on April 26. LUD change on Apr 28. After that nothing happened. So dont worry. It happens when you need it most. Wait for couple more days, things will work out.
Click to expand...
 
Congrats!

Congrats gcfordesi01 on your 140 approval.

My dates are very close to your dates. I am waiting to hear from USCIS
on reply to RFE on I-140.


Labor PD (own) :Jan 2002
I-140 & I-485 ND : 09/09/2004

LUD on I - 140 : 03/23/2005;03/29/2005
RFE on I-140 [03/29/2005]
Responded for the RFE on 04/29/2005.
Received by USCIS on 05/03/2005 (LUD changed because of this on 05/04/2005)
 
Hello India_USA ,

Please keep us about your RFE case..BTW what was the RFW about ?

Indian_USA said:
Congrats gcfordesi01 on your 140 approval.

My dates are very close to your dates. I am waiting to hear from USCIS
on reply to RFE on I-140.


Labor PD (own) :Jan 2002
I-140 & I-485 ND : 09/09/2004

LUD on I - 140 : 03/23/2005;03/29/2005
RFE on I-140 [03/29/2005]
Responded for the RFE on 04/29/2005.
Received by USCIS on 05/03/2005 (LUD changed because of this on 05/04/2005)
Click to expand...
 
Recently, a lot of poeple are getting RFE. I have couple of my friends who also got RFE this week on ability to pay.

When I tried to analyze, it looks to me most of the companies they work at had applied lot of EB3 cases in Dec 2004.

Few people got approved before USCIS started looking at Dec 2004 cases. When processing for Dec 2004 started and USCIS found a lot of 140 pending, USCIS did the maths and found that financial documents probably do not support that many pending 140.

Hence, more people getting RFE than those getting approved.

And I think, due to surge in EB3 Before Dec31, 2004, EB3 is probably getting more scruitinized.

What do you guys think?


csc_pawn said:
It is ability to pay.
Click to expand...
 
GC_for_fun said:
Hey gcfordesi01 ,

Congratulations for your approval . Could u tell us what was your RFE about?

Thanks
Click to expand...

Expereince letters from the previous employers should have specified the titles, duties, position, from to date(not just mm/yyyy & it should be dd/mm/yyyy) and job duties.
 
Good for you

gcfordesi04,

Finally I got someone who has the same RFE on 140. I just got RFE on 140 regarding exp. letter from previous employer/s. The message is the same as you. Could you share some details about your letter? If the exp. from abroad, does it satisfy CIS? You can send me to my private message or my e-mail at xyr888@yahoo.com for your convenience. Would you like share the format of your exp. letter?

Thanks.
xyr888



gcfordesi04 said:
Expereince letters from the previous employers should have specified the titles, duties, position, from to date(not just mm/yyyy & it should be dd/mm/yyyy) and job duties.
Click to expand...
 
Exp Rfe

gcfordesi04 said:
Expereince letters from the previous employers should have specified the titles, duties, position, from to date(not just mm/yyyy & it should be dd/mm/yyyy) and job duties.
Click to expand...

gcfordesi04:

I sent you two private messages. Please check your private message.
 
Hello CSC_PAWN.

has your LURD changed on 05/10/2005 for I140? . My LUD changed on 05/10 but no message change. How do you know that RFE is ability to pay as I dont think they mention that in the emails?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top