carrying g.card

you don't have to carry your gc in person At All Times.

Permanent Resident Card
The Permanent Resident Card, Form I-551, is issued to all Permanent Residents as evidence of alien registration and their permanent status in the US. The card must be in your possession at all times. While that does not require that you have on your person at all times, it does require that you have a currently valid card and that you know where it is and can show it to an immigration officer, if requested. The Permanent Resident Card currently is issued with a 10-year validity. You status as a Permanent Resident does not expire with the 10-year validity. Only the card expires. The card is only valid up to the expiration date and must be renewed before it expires.

instead of teh varuious discussions and tons of offtopic discussions
if you simply go to the USCIS HOMEPAGE
http://uscis.gov/graphics/howdoi/PermRes.htm

it explains what it means and what you have to do
, look at the bold line.
this is not lawyers this is not personal opinion this is directly from Their website.
 
Thanks for bringing that out in this Forum. I have seen many comments that say you have to carry it with you at all times. Just a copy for any information is fine, but as long as you can bring the original, there should not be a problem. The only time you need to actually carry the Plastic Card on your person is when you leave the US and re-enter.
 
sekkie said:
Permanent Resident Card
The Permanent Resident Card, Form I-551, is issued to all Permanent Residents as evidence of alien registration and their permanent status in the US. The card must be in your possession at all times. While that does not require that you have on your person at all times, it does require that you have a currently valid card and that you know where it is and can show it to an immigration officer, if requested. The Permanent Resident Card currently is issued with a 10-year validity. You status as a Permanent Resident does not expire with the 10-year validity. Only the card expires. The card is only valid up to the expiration date and must be renewed before it expires.

instead of teh varuious discussions and tons of offtopic discussions
if you simply go to the USCIS HOMEPAGE
http://uscis.gov/graphics/howdoi/PermRes.htm

it explains what it means and what you have to do
, look at the bold line.
this is not lawyers this is not personal opinion this is directly from Their website.

Makes sense. As long you can go home or to your locker box and produce it to the authority, you should be fine.
 
In the United States, there is a small book which contains the law of this land. It is called the Constitution. Along with Bill of Rights, this document afforts rights, priviledges and expects duties from its lawful residents. As part of this document, we have the Fourth Amendment. This Amendment says "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized".

A GC holder should have the expectation of a degree of privacy. This means, if Joe Sixpack (not related to JoeF) is sitting at Pizza Hut, eating his Sausage and Pepperoni pizza, he cannot and will not be asked to show his GC by law enforecement. However, if the same Joe Sixpack walks into Pizza Hut with a shot gun in his hand and points it at other customers, he is not protected by the Fourth Amendment. In summary, you do not have to carry the GC in person unless you think you will be doing some thing that would pierce the Fourth Amendment protection afforded to you.

JoeF, Stop misleading and scaring people. BTW, both your URLs listed in the last mail don't work. Learn to paste links from some good Software Engineer. :)

----------------------------
Vote Bush '04
 
JoeF, Still misinforming people? You must be related to the Iraq's Minister of Information who kept announcing that they are beating US army, when at the same time US army had successfully entered Baghdad.

Let me get this right, you are quoting a left-wing web site called paperplease? Very nice. That would be like pointing to Emperor Nero's violin talent in 64AD and hiding the big fact that Rome was burning. In matters wherein a law such as the INA you quote conflicts with the Constitution, it is always the Constitution that has precedence. You are pointing to a smaller INA, and hiding the bigger Constitution issue. Vintage style of flipping the truth, and flopping in your arguement. You need a dose of intelligence, JoeF the blabbering Joker.

----------------------------
Vote Bush '04
 
If JoeF the blabbering Joker were to be believed, everyone with GC will stay in US all year long, people will carry GC to every where they go, and no GC-holder would acquire permanent residence in other countries. Fortunately for us, JoeF is wrong on all those things, which is why we call him the Blabbering Joker.

Wrap yourself around Fourth Amendment, and you don't need to carry GC everywhere. Live happy, live free!



----------------------------
Vote Bush '04
 
The CIS webpage requires you to have access to your GC. Those who interpret the law strictly suggest carrying it in your wallet at all times.

I do not carry mine? Why? I do not feel there is a need most times. I also don’t want to loose it. I lost a driving license recently (a stupid move on my part; story for another day). Replacing it was no big deal. Replacing a lost GC should also be easy except it may take longer to arrive.

That being said, I think carrying a GC at all times is a good idea (do as I say rule  ). This applies especially if you live in stages where CIS likes to do checks (CA, TX, AZ, NM etc.). I remember reading how some Latinos in Texas were irritated as CIS had a habit of asking for proof of residency? If asked are you a US citizen, you must then be prepared to show documentation (provided you’re not). The odds of this happening are possible to slim depending on where you live.

Whenever I travel (plane, long dives etc) I do make it a point of having my card with me. It’s your individual choice, just be prepared to accept the risk.

Rgds,
sadiq
 
sadiq said:
Whenever I travel (plane, long dives etc) I do make it a point of having my card with me. It’s your individual choice, just be prepared to accept the risk.
Whenever you travel, you must carry your GC with you as that's what "having access to your GC" means. I don't think you'd be allowed to make a trip back home just to grab your GC. ;)
 
dsfgh100

As a matter of courtesy and etiquette I make a conscious effort not to flame anyone. But this time I will make an
Exception. My apologies to anyone who is offended.

That being said, dsfgh100 remove your cranium from your rectum.

The dastardly attacks on the US changed a lot of items. Things we never expected occur on a regular basis. Did anyone think for a moment that:
1. Over a thousand (we’re approaching that number) American soldiers would be killed in a war to ferret out WMDs in Iraq (turned out to be the mother of all non-events).
2. That hundreds of foreign nationals would be detained in a military base in Guantanamo and that the US government would claim the judicial branch had no business reviewing these matters. Not on American soil therefore not in jurisdiction (maybe we should have Cuban judges presiding).
3. That most Muslims living in the US as non-immigrants would have to register like criminals with the CIS under NSEERs, and that the directive would come from the Attorney General – someone we normally look to preserve human and civil rights (remember Bobby Kennedy?).

It is NOT inconceivable that you may be asked to show proof of status. And if you do have proof, you are ok unless you’re on the government’s black list.

We’re not living in Saudi Arabia? You damned right we’re not. But let’s face it. Civil rights have been eroded in the name of fighting terrorism. The US isn’t what is used to be. A lot of people used to deliberately ignore filing an AR-11 when shifting addresses. Now we send it via certified mail and request a return receipt.

Paranoid? Maybe. But to these days, being paranoid is not such a bad idea especially if you are not a US citizen.

sadiq.

p.s. you're welcome to support Bush. I'm proud to support Kerry. Can't vote, but I'm contributing financialy.
 
sadiq said:
dsfgh100

As a matter of courtesy and etiquette I make a conscious effort not to flame anyone. But this time I will make an
Exception. My apologies to anyone who is offended.

Bring it on baby.


sadiq said:
That being said, dsfgh100 remove your cranium from your rectum.

Cheap shot. I will not bend as low as you to respond to this statement.


sadiq said:
The dastardly attacks on the US changed a lot of items. Things we never expected occur on a regular basis. Did anyone think for a moment that:
1. Over a thousand (we’re approaching that number) American soldiers would be killed in a war to ferret out WMDs in Iraq (turned out to be the mother of all non-events).

American soldiers in Iraq are fighting for a valiant cause. We did find the WMD, and it is called Saddam Hussein. Tell those 100's of thousands of Iraqis whose family members were killed by Saddam and thrown into mass graves that there was no WMD. Tell those people in Kirkuk who got gas'ed with mustard gas by Chemical Ali that WMDs don't exist. Tell those swamp land Shi'ites whose homes were desctroyed by Saddam to decorate his palaces that WMDs don't exist. No country went from dictatorship and oppression to democracy without some kind of turmoil (including US). Ten years from today, Iraq would be a great democracy and that would be direct result of the honor of brave American soldiers.


sadiq said:
2. That hundreds of foreign nationals would be detained in a military base in Guantanamo and that the US government would claim the judicial branch had no business reviewing these matters. Not on American soil therefore not in jurisdiction (maybe we should have Cuban judges presiding).

When Americans get captured by terrorists, are they presented in front of Iraqi courts? Or in front of International tribunal? Noppers! They are beheaded and tortured. In times of war, hard decisions have to be made. International rules are applicable when both parties subscribe to it. As far as I know, no terrorist organization has signed the Geneva convention. And you talk about Cuba? Tell that to the Cubans who escape the oppressive regime there to gain freedom in southern Florida.


sadiq said:
3. That most Muslims living in the US as non-immigrants would have to register like criminals with the CIS under NSEERs, and that the directive would come from the Attorney General – someone we normally look to preserve human and civil rights (remember Bobby Kennedy?).

Non-immigrants = Foreigners. Name one country in the world that allows foreigners into their country without asking for some kind of registration? As much as you would like to make this a Muslim issue, it is not. If you want to make this a Muslim issue, then give credit to American decency that not one muslim was killed inside US after it has been proved that every terrorist on 9-11 was Muslim.


sadiq said:
It is NOT inconceivable that you may be asked to show proof of status. And if you do have proof, you are ok unless you’re on the government’s black list.

Do you know examples of people who were asked to show their GC in a restaurant or park or rock concert or at the bar? If you do not know this for sure, then stop spread false and malicious information.


sadiq said:
We’re not living in Saudi Arabia? You damned right we’re not. But let’s face it. Civil rights have been eroded in the name of fighting terrorism. The US isn’t what is used to be. A lot of people used to deliberately ignore filing an AR-11 when shifting addresses. Now we send it via certified mail and request a return receipt.

The problem is not that AR-11 is enfored today. The problem is that AR-11 was not enforced all these years. In my opinion, any country needs to protect its borders and keep track of who comes in, who goes out, where they live now, etc. America is our home (atleast for us US citizens). You would not want people walking into your home whenever they want, using your kitchen and then going to the bedroom and sleeping next to your wife. Would you?


sadiq said:
Paranoid? Maybe. But to these days, being paranoid is not such a bad idea especially if you are not a US citizen.

You can be paranoid all you want. But you cannot scare others without reason.




sadiq said:
p.s. you're welcome to support Bush. I'm proud to support Kerry. Can't vote, but I'm contributing financialy.

They say to get every single vote, both Kerry and Bush spend about $1200 per voter. Hope you are contributing more than $1200 to make up for your inability to vote.



----------------------------
Vote Bush '04
 
dsfgh100 said:
Bring it on baby.

Here goes…

"American soldiers in Iraq are fighting for a valiant cause. We did find the WMD, and it is called Saddam Hussein. Tell those 100's of thousands of Iraqis whose family members were killed by Saddam and thrown into mass graves that there was no WMD. Tell those people in Kirkuk who got gas'ed with mustard gas by Chemical Ali that WMDs don't exist. Tell those swamp land Shi'ites whose homes were desctroyed by Saddam to decorate his palaces that WMDs don't exist. No country went from dictatorship and oppression to democracy without some kind of turmoil (including US). Ten years from today, Iraq would be a great democracy and that would be direct result of the honor of brave American soldiers."

Let's remember the following items:
1. Saddam Husseign was/is a monster, but he is America's Frankenstein. He was always a ruthless despt, but it was ok for him to do the following things: (a) Start a war with Iran that killed hundreds of thousands of innocent lives (b) Use Chemical weapons agains Iranians during the Iran-Iran war. (c) Kill thousands of Kurds living in Northern Iraq during the 1980s with chemical weapons not bothering to discriminate between innocent women and children.
And guess what? He was still America's ally! The only reason the US turned on Saddam Hussein was because this sadistic tyrant invaded Kuwait and threatened the supply of oil. Despite the outcry about the atrocities in Angola and Sudan, there isn't any call for the mobilization of troops. Why? Limited impact to the US economy.
2. The "Let's make Iraq free" wasn't the pre-text for the war. It was Saddam Husssein presents an imminent threat to the United States because he has and seeks to use NBCs (Nuclear, Biological, and Chemical weapons).
3. The argument that we’re in Iraq to free them is bogus. The it is a mutation of the original argument after NBCs failed to materialize.

"When Americans get captured by terrorists, are they presented in front of Iraqi courts? Or in front of International tribunal? Noppers! They are beheaded and tortured. In times of war, hard decisions have to be made. International rules are applicable when both parties subscribe to it. As far as I know, no terrorist organization has signed the Geneva convention. And you talk about Cuba? Tell that to the Cubans who escape the oppressive regime there to gain freedom in southern Florida."
I don't live in Havana and I'm not a fan of Castro. I don't live in Saudi Arabia and I don't support Al-Quaeda. I live in the United States of America. I am not talking about international rules but about what happens within the United States, country I love and is now my adopted home.

"Non-immigrants = Foreigners. Name one country in the world that allows foreigners into their country without asking for some kind of registration? As much as you would like to make this a Muslim issue, it is not. If you want to make this a Muslim issue, then give credit to American decency that not one muslim was killed inside US after it has been proved that every terrorist on 9-11 was Muslim."
I do give decency to American culture. No other country in the world IMO has this level of diversity and tolerance (ok, maybe Canada). Nobody is questioning that. What I do question is George Bush's commitment to a tolerant America through his flunkies such as John Ashcroft.
Now let’s return to NSEERs which is what I was talking about. This is a quote from the CIS handout from November 2002:

“WHY ARE ONLY MUSLIMS AND ARABS REQUIRED TO REGISTER? Registration is based solely on nationality and citizenship, not on ethnicity and religion”
There were a total of 20 countries on the list: 19 of them were countries with Muslim majorities. North Korea was the exception (you can probably count the number of North Koreans in the US on one hand).
Do you see the pattern? There is a deliberate intent to profile and then they try to deny it. Non-Immigrants=FOREIGNERS. That would make sense if all non-immigrant citizens were subjected instead of Males aged 16-45 from these 20 nations. And then to add insult to injury, the try and deny that it’s targeting any group. Still think it’s not a Muslim issue?
A second reason NSEERs was unnecessary is that most of the people subjected to it were ALREADY registered. I485 applicants, Students, etc. It was finally recognized that this was a worthless system that did nothing to help and only alienated people. NSEERs has been scrapped. It generated a ton of data but very little intelligence.

"Do you know examples of people who were asked to show their GC in a restaurant or park or rock concert or at the bar? If you do not know this for sure, then stop spread false and malicious information."
What’s the false information? The fact that you are supposed to have your GC on you (or access to it) is not malicious information. I choose not to unless I am driving far from home (I define as overnight trip) or flying even within the US.

"The problem is not that AR-11 is enfored today. The problem is that AR-11 was not enforced all these years. In my opinion, any country needs to protect its borders and keep track of who comes in, who goes out, where they live now, etc. America is our home (atleast for us US citizens). You would not want people walking into your home whenever they want, using your kitchen and then going to the bedroom and sleeping next to your wife. Would you?"
I don’t know why Permanent Residents should be subjected to this; that is my opinion. The FBI has already checked fingerprints/backgrounds and CIS has certified that we can live/work here perpetually (subject to obeying laws). Nevertheless, rules are rules and we must comply. I’ve advised my friends to send it via certified mail and keep the return receipt. IMO this is prudence not paranoia.

You can be paranoid all you want. But you cannot scare others without reason.
The objective of this thread is to inform people that carrying your GC with you at all times is a good idea.


"They say to get every single vote, both Kerry and Bush spend about $1200 per voter. Hope you are contributing more than $1200 to make up for your inability to vote."
Ok so I only “bought” three votes. It’s the least those of us who are immigrants and are doing well can do. There are other activities we can (and do) participate in including: raising money for PACs, attending/organizing town hall meetings and inviting representatives from the political parties to attend, and convincing friends and family who are citizens, particularly those in battleground states, to register and vote. And there's joining and getting involved with civil rights organizations such as the ACLU.

I’d like to apologize to members from this forum for getting into this worthless discussion with dsfgh100. I’ll try to avoid purely political posts like this one and will also resist the urge to respond to his posts (sorry, but politics is one of my passions!).

Dsfgh100, there is something I do not understand. This website serves as a forum for immigrants to address issues they (we) are having. It’s also a type of support group. Most of the problems/challenges we encounter are shared by fellow posters. Why is someone with contempt for immigrants like yourself wasting your time here? You're obviously not getting sympathetic hearing. There are other forums where you could write about how immigrants are destroying this country and should shut up or leave. I’ve taken the trouble to find some links for you. Maybe you’ll find more right-wing kindred spirits there. Try these:

http://www.stopimmigrationnow.org/ (want to stop all immigration)
http://home.earthlink.net/~ns4us/id1.html (calls for only white immigration; don’t know if even you’ll like it)
http://www.diversityalliance.org/docs/article_2002sep04.html (calls for a 3 year moratorium).

Sadiq.



---------------------
Vote Bush '04
 
Guys,
This is not a Yahoo chat room. Please don't bring profanity to this forum. If this type of language and personal attacks continue, decent people leave this forum or indecent people make this as a hub (instead of yahoo chat). We are all well educated Green Card holders. Let's live upto that mark. Please post here the way you would have posted if every one knows you personally. I see some useful discussion being interrupted by bad attacks.
 
dsatish said:
Guys,
This is not a Yahoo chat room. Please don't bring profanity to this forum. If this type of language and personal attacks continue, decent people leave this forum or indecent people make this as a hub (instead of yahoo chat). We are all well educated Green Card holders. Let's live upto that mark. Please post here the way you would have posted if every one knows you personally. I see some useful discussion being interrupted by bad attacks.

Finally... some one who says the right thing.


----------------------------
Vote Bush '04
 
Top