Another Class-Action Suit

nyc_naturalizer

Registered Users (C)
Keep 'em coming! :)
__________________

Federal Lawsuit Seeks Decision on Citizenship Applications Delayed for Years

Luis F. Perez | South Florida Sun-Sentinel

8:16 PM EDT, June 4, 2008

The Florida Immigration Advocacy Center filed a class-action lawsuit Wednesday accusing the federal government of excessive delays in processing citizenship applications.

Federal law requires that the agency process those applications within four months of the naturalization interview, the lawsuit says.

Ten South Florida applicants have met the legal requirements of citizenship, but have been waiting from two to four years for a decision because of FBI background checks, according the lawsuit, which was filed in US district court in Miami.

The plaintiffs are asking the court to require the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Service, the agency that handles the naturalization process, to finalize their applications within 90 days.

"They followed all of this country's rules to achieve the most prized benefit of U.S. citizenship," said Cheryl Little, the center's executive director. "Yet they remain in legal limbo."

There are hundreds, if not thousands, of delayed applications in South Florida, she said. The advocacy center estimates more than 50,000 immigrants across the country are in similar circumstances.

Ana Santiago, a USCIS spokeswoman, said the agency doesn't comment on pending litigation.

"But USCIS is working after hours and on weekends long and hard to efficiently and securely process these application," she said. "We understand and recognize the need of these individuals that have applied for this immigration benefit. But we cannot compromise the security of the nation by cutting corners and taking shortcuts."

http://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/local/southflorida/sfl-0604immilawsuit,0,3284144.story
 
Haha, again with the "national security" BS!!! Just admit incompetence already!

On the other hand, I believe the NYC class action lawsuit was supposed to have the first hearing sometime this week. Any word on that?
 
Haha, again with the "national security" BS!!! Just admit incompetence already!

On the other hand, I believe the NYC class action lawsuit was supposed to have the first hearing sometime this week. Any word on that?

You'd think that they'd worry about the effect on national security of having one million frustrated immigrants in legal limbo.

Was that the suit sponsored by the Puerto Rican Legal Defense Fund? I haven't heard anything further about that.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
That's the one. Last I've heard, the USCIS was ordered to expeditiously produce documents related to the suit and a hearing was scheduled for early June. I'll check if anything has been posted on the PRLDF site.

Here's something interesting:

http://www.prldef.org/civil_rights/naturalization_delays/documents/Naturalization_Complaint.pdf

Right that's the original complaint. But no updates by the look of it.

You just used "USCIS" and "expeditiously" in the same sentence! :eek:
 
Thanks for that link, Bobsmyth!

This actually looks very good. It appears the the judge is siding with the plaintiffs.
 
It's truly a sad day in America when the only way to get the government to do its job is to sue it.
 
It's truly a sad day in America when the only way to get the government to do its job is to sue it.

Totally agree. First we pay application fees, then we pay court fees to make USCIS do its job. Not to mention that the court system and the DOJ are funded by taxpayers.
 
Totally agree. First we pay application fees, then we pay court fees to make USCIS do its job. Not to mention that the court system and the DOJ are funded by taxpayers.

In a way, we are paying twice for the lawsuit. Considering the fact that the $300-$400 filing fee doesn't even begin to cover the time of all parties involved, the rest of the money comes from our tax payments.
 
Spoke with docket clerk assigned to the class-action lawsuit filed in Philly a few weeks ago. Back then, there was no hearing scheduled yet.
 
Top