which state ID required for aplying US citizenship from Taxes

kkworld

New Member
Hi, i me and my wife live in Taxes and both of us have New York state ID (Driving Livence), now i wana apply for citizenship. can i apply from Taxes or i do i have to go to NY for applying my citizenship because i have NY ID, and what should be the first step i take while applying for citizenship.

Thank you so much.

Khan
 
Whatever state ID does not matter, all the USCIS needs to see at the biometrics and any other time is your green card. Make sure you follow Form M477, the N400 application checklist to ensure you have everything right before sending it in.
 
Hi, i me and my wife live in Taxes and both of us have New York state ID (Driving Livence), now i wana apply for citizenship. can i apply from Taxes or i do i have to go to NY for applying my citizenship because i have NY ID, and what should be the first step i take while applying for citizenship.

Thank you so much.

Khan

How long you had been in Texas????. You need proof for staying there for last 3 months to file N-400. Most ideally if you have just shifted to Texas, please get local DL immediately.
 
Whatever state ID does not matter, all the USCIS needs to see at the biometrics and any other time is your green card..
The state the OP applies from does matter since he must apply from the state he currently resides, and has resided for the last 3 months.
 
Hi, i me and my wife live in Taxes and both of us have New York state ID (Driving Livence), now i wana apply for citizenship. can i apply from Taxes or i do i have to go to NY for applying my citizenship because i have NY ID, and what should be the first step i take while applying for citizenship.

Thank you so much.

Khan
You must apply from the state you have resided during the last 3 months.Also, if you currently reside in Texas you must obtain a Texas DL. Driving with an out of state license (from a state you are no longer a resident from) is illegal.
 
You must apply from the state you have resided during the last 3 months.Also, if you currently reside in Texas you must obtain a Texas DL. Driving with an out of state license (from a state you are no longer a resident from) is illegal.

It does not matter what state he applies from or what state ID he has as long as that is where he lives as he has made that clear in his explanation. Whether he has changed his NY state ID to Texas state ID is none of USCIS' business. All they care to see is the green card. And all he needs to enter in the current address is the Texas address which is "the state he currently resides". Otherwise please provide where you got this three month residency requirement because there's no such thing in the instructions (scroll down to the bottom and click on Download N400 Instructions and read Part 6A (on page 3); http://www.uscis.gov/portal/site/us...nnel=40a9b2149e7df110VgnVCM1000004718190aRCRD. Stop confusing people without facts.

Just like in any other state, you have up to 90 days to exchange your NY license for a Texas license with your new address (scroll to the bottom of the following link); http://www.txdps.state.tx.us/DriverLicense/ApplyforLicense.htm, just make sure you are not caught with it if you go beyond 90 days, it should not be more than a warning or ticket anyway.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It does not matter what state he applies from or what state ID he has as long as that is where he lives as he has made that clear in his explanation. Whether he has changed his NY state ID to Texas state ID is none of USCIS' business. All they care to see is the green card. And all he needs to enter in the current address is the Texas address which is "the state he currently resides". Otherwise please provide where you got this three month residency requirement because there's no such thing in the instructions (scroll down to the bottom and click on Download N400 Instructions and read Part 6A (on page 3); http://www.uscis.gov/portal/site/us...nnel=40a9b2149e7df110VgnVCM1000004718190aRCRD
Refer to the naturalization guide. It outlines the 3 month service area residency requirement.

http://www.uscis.gov/files/article/M-476.pdf

Also, USCIS can ask for DL (among other documents) at interview to verify current address.

Finally, an applicant can mail the application from any state as long as long he/she uses the correct USCIS mailing address for the state he/she resides in.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Refer to the naturalization guide. It outlines the 3 month service area residency requirement.

http://www.uscis.gov/files/article/M-476.pdf

Also, USCIS can ask for DL (among other documents) at interview to verify current address.

Finally, an applicant can mail the application from any state as long as long he/she uses the correct USCIS mailing address for the state he/she resides in.

If that's the case, then USCIS is the one confusing people because if that is relevant information it should be on the instruction since the instruction and forms are what most people have access to and go by and they are updated often (you will notice an expiry date at the very top right of the application after which it will be updated again). The way Part 6A on the application and instruction is worded is that they don't care about anything else, they need you to just list every address you've lived for the past 5 years even if its outside the US and the duration at each address. That is what I will advise here without any three month clause. The guide is not something many people see neither is it given out as they do with the civics handbook. IN any case, the handbook on that link is old anyway because it still says applicants should provide passport photographs amongst other things when they've stopped requesting such by taking your picture during the biometrics process.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If that's the case, then USCIS is the one confusing people because if that is relevant information it should be on the instruction since the instruction and forms are what most people have access to and go by and they are updated often (you will notice an expiry date at the very top right of the application after which it will be updated again). The way Part 6A on the application and instruction is worded is that they don't care about anything else, they need you to just list every address you've lived for the past 5 years even if its outside the US and the duration at each address. That is what I will advise here without any three month clause. The guide is not something many people see neither is it given out as they do with the civics handbook. IN any case, the handbook on that link is old anyway because it still says applicants should provide passport photographs amongst other things when they've stopped requesting such by taking your picture during the biometrics process.

There's no confusion here. The N-400 instructions clearly state to refer to the Naturalization Guide to determine eligibility requirements before filing out the n-400 as does the USCIS website instructions.

http://www.uscis.gov/portal/site/us...toid=480ccac09aa5d010VgnVCM10000048f3d6a1RCRD

Also, not all ASCs currently take photographs during the naturalization biometrics process.

You need to read up on more information before dishing out inaccurate advice.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The N-400 instructions clearly state to refer to the Naturalization Guide as does the USCIS website instructions:

http://www.uscis.gov/portal/site/us...toid=480ccac09aa5d010VgnVCM10000048f3d6a1RCRD

You need to read up on more information before dishing out incomplete advice.

But the instructions are newer than the handbook that still tells people to provide passport pictures at their interview when the new thing is that they take your picture during the biometrics process. So a much newer N400 application and accompanying instruction is referring applicants to a much older handbook with out of date details? That handbook has not been updated since forever, sorry but I won't advise anyone to follow it, at least I won't.
 
But the instructions are newer than the handbook that still tells people to provide passport pictures at their interview when the new thing is that they take your picture during the biometrics process. So a much newer N400 application and accompanying instruction is referring applicants to a much older handbook with out of date details? That handbook has not been updated since forever, sorry but I won't advise anyone to follow it, at least I won't.
The guide's basic eligibility requirements are not outdated. Also, not all ACS currently take photos during the biometrics process, hence the guide instructions are still valid.
You've already lost credibility with the past advice you have given on this form.
 
The guide's basic eligibility requirements are not outdated. Also, not all ACS currently take photos during the biometrics process, hence the guide instructions are still valid.
You've already lost credibility with the past advice you have given on this form.

You may have lost credibility by having people look through an outdated handbook that has not changed since before I applied for my green card ages ago and having people guess what applies or not when even attorneys don't care what the old handbook says but simply stick to the most current N400 application, its instructions, and the Form M477 checklist.
 
You may have lost credibility by having people look through an outdated handbook that has not changed since before I applied for my green card ages ago and having people guess what applies or not when even attorneys don't care what the old handbook says but simply stick to the most current N400 application, its instructions, and the Form M477 checklist.
The handbook is not outdated and is very relevant. In fact, the current revision is 02/10. Are you really trying to argue it's outdated based on the fact that some ASCs now take your picture during naturalization biometric process? Also, were do you get that attorneys don't care what the handbook says? It's clear you're providing inaccurate information and making general statements based on your own interpretations.
 
You may have lost credibility by having people look through an outdated handbook that has not changed since before I applied for my green card ages ago and having people guess what applies or not when even attorneys don't care what the old handbook says but simply stick to the most current N400 application, its instructions, and the Form M477 checklist.
The handbook is not outdated and is very relevant. In fact, the current revision is 02/10. Are you really trying to argue it's outdated based on the fact that some ASCs now take your picture during naturalization biometric process? Also, were do you get that attorneys don't care what the handbook says? It's clear you're providing inaccurate information and making general statements based on your own interpretations.
 
But the instructions are newer than the handbook that still tells people to provide passport pictures at their interview when the new thing is that they take your picture during the biometrics process. So a much newer N400 application and accompanying instruction is referring applicants to a much older handbook with out of date details? That handbook has not been updated since forever, sorry but I won't advise anyone to follow it, at least I won't.

JAYOA

If you are unsure about things then don't give bad advice, You have to be a Resident of a District for 90 Days to apply N-400 in that district and that is the case from a long time.
Bob is a Moderator and have vast knowledge on these issues and have 9500 Plus posts and counting. Don't take it personal but refrain from giving advice on issues that you don't know about.
I however agree with you on the driver license part that at FP appointment they will accept that as identification, but if the IO on the Natz interview see the NY state licenses he/ she can suspect them to be filing in a wrong district.
I personally know a case where a person filed N-400 in Raleigh DO using his sons address in Raleigh when he was living in Saint Louis because in Raleigh the whole thing gets done in 4 Months and Saint Louis was taking about a year, the IO in Raleigh got suspicious with the MO license on the interview and called the employer listed on the N-400 and they verified that he was employed in MO.
He then asked the person to withdraw his N-400 rather than him rejecting the N-400 for lack of jurisdiction. The guy lost his filing fee and withdrew his N-400 and filed with his address in MO.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Good points, namecheckvictim.

Most states require new residents to switch their driver's license within 30 days of taking up residency. As Bob stated, driving in your state of residency with an out-of-state license, beyond the grace period, is flat out illegal.

Like many people, I received a YL asking me to bring my state-issued driver's license to the interview. Since an N-400 applicant is required to have resided in the filing state for 90 days, taking an out-of-state driver's license to a naturalization interview would amount to offering evidence that you have no respect for state laws. If the original poster lives in Texas, he and his wife should just go into the Texas driver's license bureau (or whatever it's called in that state) and do whatever it takes to get their NY DLs exchanged for Texas ones. It's a no-brainer.
 
Hey guys, as I always like to do with issues that I know, I post the actual links to the law that states so. And I did so for the Texas driver license DMV information that says a new resident has up to 90 days to change to a Texas license, the same applies in my state and many states that I know of. If you noticed, the discussion specifically surrounds someone that has "moved", not someone that simply wants to fraudulently take advantage of some other jurisdiction's seemingly short processing time like the story you have up there. If he "moved" from NY to Texas (as he said they "live" in TX now) then it will be unreasonable to go to NY where they no longer have a residence address to file. It is up to him to decide to consult an attorney about the the relevance of the three month wait or not to file in his new state or to get his new Texas license within a day or up to 90 days after he moved there. I am sure the IO knows that he has up to 90 days for a new resident to change to a TX license so as long as he is within that period thee should be no problem. I know enough to speak what I know because I worked with my attorney to file both my green card and now my N400; nobody cares about the handbook because N400, its the instruction, and checklist bares everything that EVERY SINGLE APPLICANT needs to know and do, no special rule applies to anyone else. And you are not required to bring a picture but the handbook still states the old rule of bring your own picture, and my attorney says NOBODY needs to bring pictures anymore and that that is an old rule. Even the handbook says if you reside far out of the reach of an ASC they will come to you with a biometrics van to get your fingerprints and picture but he says some places require applicants to bring pictures, I wonder which separate set of instructions are prepared for such people. Obviously he is just making stuff up and getting "points".
Because someone has a million posts mean nothing, anyone can post crap all day and get more than that, none of us is an attorney and should not throw a feat because someone seems to challenge whatever authority he/she feels they have.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I know enough to speak what I know because I worked with my attorney to file both my green card and now my N400; nobody cares about the handbook because N400,
Yet again another generalization. Geez, some people really don't know when to stop.

Even the handbook says if you reside far out of the reach of an ASC they will come to you with a biometrics van to get your fingerprints and picture but he says some places require applicants to bring pictures, I wonder which separate set of instructions are prepared for such people. Obviously he is just making stuff up and getting "points".
The guide clearly states that van accommodations may be made for remote residents of Alaska and Hawaii. Also, not all ASC currently take photos for biometrics process. From your previous posts and advice, it's obvious you're unable/unwilling to follow instructions.

Because someone has a million posts mean nothing, anyone can post crap all day and get more than that, none of us is an attorney and should not throw a feat because someone seems to challenge whatever authority he/she feels they have.
I suggest you invest some time on researching and reading immigration matters instead of belching out your inaccurate information and generalizations.
 
The burden of proof having resided at Texas for 3 months rests with OP - Khan. IO normally accept DL / State ID as a clinching evidence of having stayed in the state for 3 months and eligible to be interviewed there. Secondary proofs may or may not be accepted by IO. Why risk ????. After all one does not know what type of IO one would get. Any how Khans have to change their DL in one or 3 months, so why not now ?
 
Top