Originally posted by KYCP
i140limbo,
If it makes you feel better, I was quite worried/skeptical, so was my lawyer. Like agw said, I do not believe they will reject it based on lack of proof of hardship alone.
For me,
TSC delays in processing I824 (quite long), potential dealy in promotion due to change in job description , loss of some finger printing at TSC (I believe this since has been corrected/rectified) were cited as the reasons.
Mumbai consulate is quite reasonable, I know of another person who cited (coupe of years ago) just the delay in waiting for I485 (and I824 for regular CP) and got the case accepted.
I do believe these are justified reasons.
Just give it a try, if they accept it fine otherwise they will send the package back, I do not belive you got much to lose,
Good luck,
KYCP
Originally posted by agw
i140limbo,
3. I certainly would like to know the facts of approval/ rejection ratio, and I have posed this question couple of times. But as for what lawyers say, it would be rejected for the same reason that they could reject if you filed for AOS. The risk you are taking with CP is you do not have a right to appeal being in your home country. In AOS you can appeal and await decision and still work for a longer time. And everybody's case is different, and it could be pending because of requisite paperwork and if so, it could be rectified. (This is lawyers language in my words on this subject.). You have to gauge a risk reward ratio. The reward here is you get the whole thing completed in max 6 moths, either one side or the other.
4. I had exactly the same question, and my lawyer advised me that if you are afraid and if you want to play safe then, do AC140 and AOS simultaneously. Also even once you send AC140 packet and it is not accepted for some corrections, Consulate will tell you to rectify the documents and resubmit or would either not give you a case number or an interview date. Under such circumstance you can still file for AOS.
Hope this helps.
AGW
Disclamer: Talk to your lawyer on all these issues.
Originally posted by harapatra
If, for some reason, the GC is rejected can the person come to US and work as long as the H1 is valid?
No, I do not believe so.
I heard somewhere that the parallel processing of CP and AOS is not allowed but you sound as if it is quite possible. Please clarify.
Here is my understanding:
There is a limit to which you could pursue both routes. I-485 is considered withdrawn after the I-824 is approved (which takes a long time, in the order of a year or may be less)
Now,
with the I-824 receipt notice, you could start AC-140 and if you get your interview before the I-824 approval, well and good (you still may need to be on independent visa status, like F1, H1, J1, B1 or...., not on work permit based on I-485).
When your I-824 gets approved, you will be sent a letter to make a choice between continuing I-485 or change to CP route.
At this stage, If the consulate decides not to take your (AC-140) case, you could:
1. wait for case to be sent to NVC- the usual CP route, abandon I-485
or
2. Stick with I-485 and abandon CP route
hope this clarifies,
KYCP
thanks
--harapatra
Originally posted by spb999
AGW,KYCP,
Thanks for the reply. I can go to mumbai consulate as my visa was stamped at mumbai us consulate. Also want to check with you guys or anybody what are the things required for ac140 to be submitted to the us embassay thru the lawyer. Any suggestions welcome. Also do I need to pay all the fees at the same time or at mumbai.
spb999