Received NOID....................what are the chances of rebuttal?

I was denied asylum by the immigration officer,then I was referred to the immigration judge because I was out of status, I was denied asylum again by the immigration judge, t appealed my case to the board of appeals, I was finally granted asylum by the board of appeals, keep fighting and never lose hope
 
  • Like
Reactions: CWH
satrianic said:
So i will be refereed to the immigration court or should i mention on my rebuttal that if in case the rebuttal is rejected please refer me to the Immigration Judge?
Click to expand...


No you shouldn't mention this. Nobody can refer you to the immigration court if you are still in status.
 
satrianic said:
Thanks for your reply, I guess i will be automatically referred to the court once i am out of status.
Click to expand...

According to my understanding, when your case is denied and you are out of status, you will be referred to the court.
If your case is denied and you are still in status, your case will be closed and you will NOT be referred to the court. When you lose your status, you will need to write to the asylum office to ask for referral.
 
satrianic said:
Hi everyone,

I am in lawful status (OPT) and had applied for political asylum in september 18th 2013. I was interviewed by AO on 29th october and received NOID on 12th november 2013. I was interviewed by this women, who had no interest in my story but was more interested on my grammatical mistakes on my deceleration and translation errors. I received Notice of intent to deny based on 4 reasons she explained , which doesn't lead to any credibility issues. Is there any one who received NOID and filled a Rebuttal and any any success with the rebuttal.
PLEASE HELP!!!
Click to expand...

Are there any updates from your case? We'd love to hear how is everything going with your case? Thanks and Best Luck!
 
I believe we can make better documentary than "Well founded fear" the stories I read here are unique and so depressing for those who come to the country which should have democratic system and encounters asylum officers who simply don't care that they are handling someone's life. Asylum officer must find inconsistencies but using spelling error as inconsistency and because applicant couldn't allow lawyer and you are attacking him is unacceptable for the country we were told.

If critical documentary is done about all these frustrations I believe policymakers will consider next time.

For example it is unacceptable and outrageous when someone comes to USA from war zone where he/she still has family members and he waits for interview or decision for years and during this time his family member is killed. This is not better than what Hitler or Stalin did. If system sucks as it is now post this information on USCIS website, post in asylum section that asylum interview for 80% of applicants takes from 4 weeks to forever and then people will know that by coming here they would face uncertainty. USCIS website misleads people and doesn't mention those delays. Asylum seeker must make real good research to make decision where to go, but usually asylum seekers doesn't have time and visas to choose. Personally my ticket was booked on 16th date and i left country 1 day before to third country and then went to USA because 1 day would be crucial for me.
 
Journalist7 said:
I believe we can make better documentary than "Well founded fear" the stories I read here are unique and so depressing for those who come to the country which should have democratic system and encounters asylum officers who simply don't care that they are handling someone's life. Asylum officer must find inconsistencies but using spelling error as inconsistency and because applicant couldn't allow lawyer and you are attacking him is unacceptable for the country we were told.

If critical documentary is done about all these frustrations I believe policymakers will consider next time.

For example it is unacceptable and outrageous when someone comes to USA from war zone where he/she still has family members and he waits for interview or decision for years and during this time his family member is killed. This is not better than what Hitler or Stalin did. If system sucks as it is now post this information on USCIS website, post in asylum section that asylum interview for 80% of applicants takes from 4 weeks to forever and then people will know that by coming here they would face uncertainty. USCIS website misleads people and doesn't mention those delays. Asylum seeker must make real good research to make decision where to go, but usually asylum seekers doesn't have time and visas to choose. Personally my ticket was booked on 16th date and i left country 1 day before to third country and then went to USA because 1 day would be crucial for me.
Click to expand...

Part of the problem is asylum fraud. I know of several people in my community, from my country, who fabricated stories just to get legal status through asylum. At one time a journalist was covering the supposed horror stories of these guys from my country; the lies were so blatantly ridiculous that it would be funny if it wasn't so depressing. It got so bad that one time the FBI busted a group that provided fraudulent asylum applications to dozens of people. These people make life harder for legitimate asylees / refugees.
 
This is true. Probably 50% of cases are fake, but Fake case applicants are those ones whose interest is their interview notice to be delayed years to work as longer as they can. So, making application processing more efficient they will also eliminate many fake applicants.
 
Hexa said:
Part of the problem is asylum fraud. I know of several people in my community, from my country, who fabricated stories just to get legal status through asylum. At one time a journalist was covering the supposed horror stories of these guys from my country; the lies were so blatantly ridiculous that it would be funny if it wasn't so depressing. It got so bad that one time the FBI busted a group that provided fraudulent asylum applications to dozens of people. These people make life harder for legitimate asylees / refugees.
Click to expand...

I can't agree more. I saw in other forums ppl even openly talked about how they went to church for seminars about basic religious knowledge. Obviously they knew nothing about Christianity, however, they applied for religious persecution and got approved.
 
I am going for rebuttal. After interview, one prominent incident happened to back in my country to my family. If I add that with newspaper evidence, how much chance do i have? I was denied only on one point of Mogharrabhi - inclination to harm seemed speculative though the case and testimony is credible.
Please help me. I am hopeless and depressed!
 
herdaibasyo said:
I am going for rebuttal. After interview, one prominent incident happened to back in my country to my family. If I add that with newspaper evidence, how much chance do i have? I was denied only on one point of Mogharrabhi - inclination to harm seemed speculative though the case and testimony is credible.
Please help me. I am hopeless and depressed!
Click to expand...

Did you hire a attorney yet? You need to handle this case with an experienced attorney.
 
herdaibasyo said:
I didn't hire but one of the lawyer from catholic immigration is helping me - without his representation.
Click to expand...

You'd better consult your attorney to see if he is willing to represent your case in front of the judge. He is professionally trained to handle those cases. I'm not saying you will not be able to answer those questions in the hearing, but your attorney could provide you more appropriate answers to the governmental prosecutor and the judge's questions in the hearing. You will have to answer their questions, defend your case and convince them that you are qualified for the asylum benefits. Good luck my friend. Pray and trust!
 
you need a lawyer, you already tried once by yourself and lost, this is your last chance, get a lawyer to represent you
 
John Smith 1 said:
you need a lawyer, you already tried once by yourself and lost, this is your last chance, get a lawyer to represent you
Click to expand...

Thanks guys for the support.....I finally made the lawyer to represent me and it's almost pro bono - cost me $50. I gonna fight till the end no matter even if I need to fall out of status.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CWH
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top