Mandamus Actions: Make the Government Work for You!
(originally posted at the VSC forum by kash777)
backlog delay sued BCIS and got approved case thru marriage, good example
From newsletter
Carl Shusterman ,immigration attorney dated 10.11.2003 :
6. Mandamus Actions: Make the Government Work for You!
What are the most popular pages on our web site?
The government processing times!
This is no surprise since it takes the government over two years to process an
application for adjustment of status, and over six months to process a simple
H-1B petition.
Recently, we were retained to represent a young woman who had obtained
conditional permanent residence through her marriage to a U.S. citizen. The
marriage failed to last two years beyond the date that she adjusted her status.
She submitted an application (I-751) to remove the two-year condition on her
green card and to waive the joint petition requirement. She waited three years
for the INS to process her application. Then she moved to Los Angeles, and was
told that her application would go to the back of the line, and she would have
to wait another three years!
She did not think this was fair, and neither did I. One of our attorneys made
an inquiry on her behalf, and received the same answer: three more years.
We wrote two certified letters to the government requesting an immediate
interview for our client. Then we went to the Federal Court and asked for a
"Writ of Mandamus" to require the government to make a decision on her
application.
After filing our law suit, we received a call from the U.S. Attorneys Office.
The U.S. Attorneys represent the Department of Homeland Security and other
federal agencies in court.
The Assistant U.S. Attorney informed us that we would be hearing from the
Bureau of Citizenship and Immigration Services (CIS) shortly.
The very next day, we received an appointment letter from the CIS scheduling an
interview for our client. We appeared with her at her interview, and the I-751
was approved on the same date. Our client is delighted and so are we. We are
now applying for naturalization on her behalf.
What is a Writ of Mandamus? It compels the government to perform a duty owed
to you. If you submitted an application for an immigration benefit, if it is
beyond the normal processing time, if you have made written inquiries about
your application, and the government has not responded, requesting a Writ of
Mandamus in Federal Court will get their attention. Trust me.
Unfortunately, many immigrants are afraid that the Immigration Service will
deny their applications in retribution if they ask for a Writ of Mandamus. All
I can say that after practicing immigration law for over 25 years, both for the
INS and in private practice, I have never seen this happen.
Some attorneys are afraid to go to Federal Court and sue the Immigration
Service.
Fortunately, the American Immigration Law Foundation (AILF) has published an
excellent Practice Advisory regarding how to file a mandamus action in Federal
Court which cites the relevant statutes and case law.