NEW PETITION DRAFT - pl. post your opinion.

ayansgp

Registered Users (C)
Subject: Petition requesting your support to help reduce excessive Green Card (I-485) processing delays by the United States Immigration and Citizenship Services (USCIS).

Dear Sir/Madam,
We are a community of immigrants and immigration benefit applicants congregating at http://www.immigrationportal.com Currently, we number over 67,000 registered members and approximately five times as many unregistered participants. Accordingly, we are the largest U.S. immigration community in the world.

We would like to make you aware of the excessive delays in processing Adjustment of Status (Greencard) applications by the USCIS (US Citizenship and Immigration Services) and the huge problems that these delays cause. The bleak ever increasing backlog situation is portrayed at the USCIS website at http://uscis.gov/graphics/shared/aboutus/statistics/msrnov03/BENEFIT.HTM. Currently it takes up to six years in certain regions in the United States to get a Greencard. I-485 approval takes roughly half of the total time (about 33 months), which is the last step for Greencard approval process.

Members of this forum have created several petitions signed by thousands of applicants. A recent such petition can be found at http://www.immigration.com/common/rsk/petition_I485.html. A quick look at the comments section would give you a window into the disturbing problems faced by us because of these excessive delays. Petitions like these have been conveyed to the immigration officers and elected lawmakers. So far no effort has been made by either the USCIS or the elected officials to address the brutal backlog situation.

Effects these delays cause in our lives:
This relentless processing delay has and is affecting our lives enormously. Important aspects of our lives such as marriage, home ownership, education of our children, meaningful contributions to the community and our well-being have been put on hold. Career advancement is at a standstill because we have to remain with the same respective employer (or) similar job in order to get our greencard approval. A good number of employers have taken advantage of these restrictions created by the severe processing delays.

During this adjustment period we also have to face problems in visiting our home countries because of the delays in getting travel permits (Advance Parole) even during emergencies (when our be-loved at our home country ones are terminally ill or have passed away). Getting a drivers license for more than a year is not a luxury that we can indulge in certain states.

These restrictions not only impact our livelihood but the business organizations we work for and the community we live in. Businesses cannot promote experienced employees like us to higher-level positions and replace them with new less experienced employees to maintain or increase the overall business. A deep frustration arising out of these never ending delays and other factors associated with these delays stifles our ability to contribute to the society and be a happy part of it.

Requests from the Immigration Benefits Applicants and supporters:
We, the immigration benefits applicants and our supporters in the American society request the legislators to pass new laws or amend existing laws to address their problems. Some of the requests are:

1.Give higher priority to employment based I-485 applications and N-400 Naturalization Applications:
It is historically obvious that when legacy INS/USCIS prioritizes any processing tasks, employment based I-485 applications. Some of these priority tasks undertaken include TPS, religious workers cases, asylum cases, etc. Prioritizing the urgent tasks are appreciated, but USCIS should not do this at the expense of EB I-485 applications and N-400 Naturalization applications. I-485 applicants have been living in this country from anywhere between 6 to more than or more than 10 years. We have been working hard, paying our share of Taxes and making intellectual as well as monetary contribution to the American society. We, the legal immigration benefits applicants feel as though we are treated as irrelevant or less important immigrant group. While several bills were introduced and passed to give benefits to illegal immigrants, the problems of legal immigrants were not addressed.

2. Extend the validity period of EAD and Advance Parole:
Currently, the Employment Authorization Document (EAD) and Advance Parole for adjustment of status applicants, are issued with a validity of 1 year. Since the actual I-485 application processing is taking more than 24 months, all the applicants are forced to renew their EAD and Advance Parole. This is not only resulting in loss of time and money for the applicants, but USCIS is getting burdened with unnecessary additional work. The immigration benefits applicants requests Congress to increase the validity period of EAD and Advance Parole to 3 years. Please note that it is taking 33 months at Texas Service Center for the adjudication of an employment based I-485 application and over seven months for the approval of travel document (Advance Parole), which is only valid for one year.

3. Remove Restrictions on EB I-485 applicants:
One of the main problems being faced by employment based I-485 applicants is the restriction on job portability. Though " The American Competitiveness in the Twenty-first Century Act (AC21)" tried to address these concerns, it failed to remove all the restrictions on job portability. The applicants requests Congress to remove all the restrictions on job portability after 6 months from the date of filing the I-485 application. The current restrictions require that an applicant can change the job provided the new job is a similar job with similar job duties. This leaves a wide scope for interpretation by USCIS.

4. Increase the funding to Service Centers:
A major reason for these processing delays is lack of enough resources to adjudicate the huge number of backlog applications. USCIS has expressed their inability to hire enough adjudicating officers because of funding problems. The immigration benefits applicants requests U.S. Congress to allocate additional funds exclusively for reducing the employment based I-485 applications and N-400 Naturalization applications. Additionally the benefit applicants are willing to pay a higher processing fee for orderly and timely processing of their I-485 applications.

5. Approve permanent resident application of dependents if the primary applicant dies:
During the Adjustment Of Status (AOS) period, if the Primary applicant dies, all their dependents are denied the permanent resident status and removal proceedings are most likely initiated against them. This is highly inequitable. To uproot families of honest, tax paying, hard working people because the primary bread earner has passed on is highly egregious. The immigration benefits applicants request you to change the existing laws so that, during the Adjustment Of Status, if the Primary applicant dies any time after six months of the date of Receipt, the dependents’ applications should not be rejected. The dependents must not be penalized for the processing delays at USCIS.

We very much appreciate your support of this petition. Please help us by endorsing this petition, so that we can show your support of this petition to Congress and USCIS officials.

Undersigned strongly support increased efficiency in adjudications of I-485 (Adjustment of Status) applications by USCIS.






Signature of Organization/Person endorsing this petition

Name:

Organization:

Address:
 
About petition

I haven't mentioned anything about the suit. Organizations may not be willing to support it. Also the attatchment has some real life stories of hardship in the appendix.
 
Try this

Appeal for Justice

We, the undersigned, urge the President of the United States and the Members of Congress to alleviate the suffering of employment based applicants for US Permanent Residence (green card). All of these applicants are law abiding taxpayers who have lived in this country for years. Many of us have been waiting as long as five or six years for receiving our green card approvals.

Our community has faced tremendous stress and hardship because of the delays in green card processing. These delays for LEGAL applicants are unconscionable. We live in continuous dread and insecurity. Loss or diminishment of our employment almost invariably means abrupt uprooting of years of life and career built in this country. In most cases, USCIS practice permits not even one day of grace period for us to arrange for passage out of USA - a state of affairs long way from the constitutional ideal of “…pursuit of happiness.”

Additionally, for labor certification based cases, which form a large majority of employment-based applications, any substantial career advancement is unwise. A promotion leads to nullification of the entire green card process, thereby necessitating starting the process all over again - resetting the six-year countdown back to zero. Thus, an employee is required to continue at the same job level year after year.

Our families have no security and we have no peace. We are all useful members of this society. We deserve your attention. Acting together, we have made several pleas for relief. So far, we see none.

We have made several concerted efforts to redress this problem through the government and the legislature. Thousands of people signed and submitted several petitions, but no action was taken. A copy of one of these petitions is attached (available online at: http://www.immigration.com/common/rsk/petition_I485.html).

Left with no viable option, we were constrained to appeal to the courts for relief. On 22 December 2003, ImmigrationPortal.Com, an online community and others have filed a lawsuit against United States Immigration and Citizenship Services (earlier known as INS) challenging the delays in processing of some applications for employment based immigrants. A copy of the Complaint is attached ((available online at: http://boards.immigration.com/attachment.php?s=&postid=651497).

Please step forward on our behalf for justice and equity. Our community can be contacted at:



Signatures and comments of applicants and our supporters:
 
My comments

Rajiv's letter was formatted well, to the point and short so that people will read it to endorse. Here are my changes

Well formatted letter addressing the community/companies to support us. I have made some minor changes

Honorable President and Members of Congress of the United States

Sub: Appeal for Justice

We, urge the President of the United States and the Members of Congress to alleviate the suffering caused by delays in approving of employment based applicants for US Permanent Residence (green card). We (employment based applicants) are legal, law-abiding taxpayers who have lived in this country for years. Many of us have been waiting as long as five or six years for receiving our green card approvals. The severity of the backlogs can be found at the USCIS (US Citizenship and Immigration Services) Website at http://uscis.gov/graphics/shared/aboutus/statistics/msrnov03/BENEFIT.HTM

We congregate at the online community immigrationportal.com. Our community has faced tremendous hardship and stress because of the delays in green card processing. We have lived as legal citizens in the US for anywhere between 5 to 13 years and have contributed to the country. These delays for LEGAL applicants are unconscionable. We live in continuous dread and insecurity. Loss or diminishment of our employment almost invariably means abrupt uprooting of years of life and career built in this country. In most cases, USCIS practice permits not even one day of grace period for us to arrange for passage out of USA - a state of affairs long way from the constitutional ideal of “…pursuit of happiness.”

Additionally, any substantial career advancement is unwise. A promotion leads to nullification of the entire green card process, thereby necessitating starting the process all over again - resetting the six-year countdown back to zero. Thus, an employee is required to continue at the same job level year after year. Our families have no security and we have no peace. We are all useful members of this society. We deserve your attention.

Acting together, we have made several pleas for relief. So far, we see none. We have made several concerted efforts to redress this problem through the government and the legislature. Thousands of people signed and submitted several petitions, but no action was taken. A copy of one of these petitions is attached (available online at: http://www.immigration.com/common/rsk/petition_I485.html). In the comments section you will find common problems faced by us such as difficulty in visiting home country due to the delays even during family emergencies and other specific problems these delays cause.

Left with no viable option, we were constrained to appeal to the courts for relief. On 22 December 2003, immigrationportal.Com, our online community and others have filed a lawsuit against USCIS (earlier known as INS) challenging the delays in processing of some applications for employment based immigrants. A copy of the Complaint is attached (available online at: http://boards.immigration.com/attachment.php?s=&postid=651497).

A report that was released by the General Accounting Office on Jan 2004 details what needs to happen at the USCIS if they have to achieve the president’s goal of reducing the backlog to six months. http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d04309r.pdf

As a member of the community we request your help in supporting us in requesting the president and the congress to address the Greencard (I-485) processing backlogs. Please step forward to endorse us for justice and equity. Our community can be contacted at:

Thank you very much for your support.

We the undersigned endorse this petition and support the reduction of I-485 (Greencard) backlogs for employment based applicants.


Person’s Name
Designation
Phone #
Organization
City
State
Comments:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Let's act.

Let's immediately send this appeal to the president and the congress members, using whichever version you like, or tailoring it to your own words.
 
Confused

We already sent the 485 petition to the congressional people. There were no responses from them.

I thought this was a separate petition that will be posted in Rajiv's site so that we can get support from US companies, ethnic organizations and then send it to the president and congress with hopes that the support of american businesses to our problems will make the congress act.
 
Re: Confused

Originally posted by tr22
We already sent the 485 petition to the congressional people. There were no responses from them.

I thought this was a separate petition that will be posted in Rajiv's site so that we can get support from US companies, ethnic organizations and then send it to the president and congress with hopes that the support of american businesses to our problems will make the congress act.


Two differences

1. Now there is a lawsuit. People will pay attention.
2. This was not sent to the legislators or the Pres.

The petition was sent only to USCIS.
 
Is there a link somewhere for lazy people to click and send?

I wrote a letter to Congressman (Gephart) with lawsuit mentioned, no response yet. He is busy in Iowa today.
 
Originally posted by hidden_dragon
Is there a link somewhere for lazy people to click and send?

I wrote a letter to Congressman (Gephart) with lawsuit mentioned, no response yet. He is busy in Iowa today.


Once you folks finalize the petition, a link will be created. No problem.
 
Delay in I-485 approval

I would like to thank Mr. Rajiv Khanna for all his effort on this critical issue.

Any improvements in the area of Potability factor, AP, EAD is a definite plus. But, the main issue here is the delay in processing I-485 approval. We know INS has constraints (Lack of manpower)in quick adjudication of I-485 application. But, some cases get approved in 1 year and some cases don't in three years. Their answer to this is: each case is different, so is the difference in time. The I485 form is same, the procedure is same, everything is same except some critical info. like security clearance etc. That can make such a big difference ? If it is, then it is USCIS's working procedure, that is causing this delay. My point here is, USCIS should have a hard upper limit of 2 or 3 years at most. They should make a decision (approve or deny) before that time. Otherwise some cases will be hanging for ever. The service centers will always come up with some story all the time as they have been doing all through. This is our only chance to get something related to I-485 approval. When the system says I-485 should be approved in six months, don't you think 3 years is a lot of time to make a decision ?

I think, we should not settle for anything other than a reasonable upper hard limit. They should have some kind of pressure on them when it comes to deadline for a particular application is concerned.


Thanks
mandu.
 
Lets send this to the media

If everyone who is part of this community sends emails to the local newspapers/tv news, etc, some of them might get interested in the story and get more noise out there.

We need to make people aware of this situation and TV and Newspapers are the most effective way to do it.

1-3 emails per person will make a big difference. I already started and sent aprox. 30.

El Negro
 
Re: Lets send this to the media

Originally posted by Elnegro
If everyone who is part of this community sends emails to the local newspapers/tv news, etc, some of them might get interested in the story and get more noise out there.

We need to make people aware of this situation and TV and Newspapers are the most effective way to do it.

1-3 emails per person will make a big difference. I already started and sent aprox. 30.

El Negro

Good Job.

To have better impact try to develop contact with some journalist and mail it to them. Also target the journalists covering immigration.
 
Top