Need help with RFE

ncpi

New Member
Hello friends,

My wife and I had our first interview for her AOS July 23rd, 2009 and it went fairly well in my opinion. Questions were fairly simple but the officer did not swear us in, nor did she introduce herself, etc. At the end of the interview she asked whether we had brought additional evidence, and we provided the following:

1-) Joint bank account statement
2-) Life insurance with my wife listed as the beneficiary
3-) Car title with both our names on it
4-) Car insurance
5-) Cell phone bill under my name (but had both numbers listed on it). I called the cell phone company and they told me it was not possible to add her to the account, which I find very odd but I did not feel like arguing with them at the time.
6-) Joint tax return for 2008 (They already had a copy of this), but it was not provided during the interview although I had it with me.

A little background on us...

We're living with my parents at the moment since we're planning to purchase a home next month (we're closing mid-September), so we were trying to save as much money as possible. With that said, we did not have a lease under our name nor did we have utility bills because they are under my parent's names.

At the end of the interview the officer said she was going to review the case and that we should be receiving a decision by mail within 30 days. About a week went by and we received a letter from the local office addressed to my wife, requesting that she be present this month with evidence showing a bona fide marital relationship with it. The letter is not very clear and is rather vague, but I am not letting my wife go in by herself so I am taking the day off that day to accompany her.

Does this seem odd to you? In my humble opinion I believe we provided plenty of evidence the first time around. Additionally, I also had to travel to her home country for the K-1 visa as a split interview was required - one which we passed with ease.

The officer seemed to like the fact I worked for the government(local county) while we were in the office, so I am not sure what triggered this 'request for evidence'.

Have any of you experienced something like this before? Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Note: We have plenty of evidence prior to our marriage since we've known each other for 8 years now. We have stacks of emails, plane tickets when I visited her home country, etc but I believe none of this applies since it was prior to our marriage, is this a good assumption?
 
Taking the emails and plane tickets will help somewhat.

Did you not have any photos and/or affidavits from family and friends attesting to your mattiage?
 
My bad, we did have photos of the wedding and the officer did look at them and asked questions.

As for the letters from friends, no I did not believe they were necessary as we had plenty of evidence.
 
My bad, we did have photos of the wedding and the officer did look at them and asked questions.

As for the letters from friends, no I did not believe they were necessary as we had plenty of evidence.
The USCIS apparently disagree, also the interview you travel into seems odd based on the length you know each other. Also why didn't you purchase the phone together initially?
 
Yeah they seem to disagree or they're just giving my wife hard time since she applied for a visa twice before and was denied without knowing the reason. Prior to meeting her she had already applied for a visa and she was denied. After we met I encouraged her to apply again to no avail.

The interview was definitely weird. I had a folder full of documents they had requested and none of them, except for the evidence was requested by USCIS.

Although we have known each other for about 8 years we have only been together since Nov, 2008 and married only 7 months. I got her an iphone last christmas as a gift so I opened the account under my name since she had just gotten to the country and had no social security number, nor did she have any ids but her passport, etc.

See when it comes to bills it's as easy as USCIS would like to believe. I called the cell phone company to have the bill under our names if that would make them happy and they told me it was not possible.

We have a contract of a property we were trying to buy a couple of months ago and did not go through. We also have another contract of a townhouse we're purchasing and closing next month although the latter might not be valid since they don't accept any proof established within the last (60) days.

In all honestly I am not happy with the way this has been handled. Having already gone through a split interview (each of us were interviewed individually at the foreign consulate) and having passed it, all the evidence before them, and they still give a legitimate couple a hard time? Come on now...

Anyhow, we'll see how that goes. We have no problem with the stokes interview since we already passed the split interview to start with but I wouldn't like it to get to that point, obviously.
 
Questions were fairly simple but the officer did not swear us in, nor did she introduce herself, etc.

Isn't it rather odd that the IO didn't swear you in? Would that invalidate the interview since you were not placed under oath to affirm that the evidence and testimony is truthful? No doubt, you were truthful though.
 
Does your wife happen to be from a country that has a higher than average rate of immigration fraud? What citizenship does she hold?

About a week went by and we received a letter from the local office addressed to my wife, requesting that she be present this month with evidence showing a bona fide marital relationship with it. The letter is not very clear and is rather vague, but I am not letting my wife go in by herself so I am taking the day off that day to accompany her.

Does this seem odd to you? In my humble opinion I believe we provided plenty of evidence the first time around. Additionally, I also had to travel to her home country for the K-1 visa as a split interview was required - one which we passed with ease.
 
Isn't it rather odd that the IO didn't swear you in? Would that invalidate the interview since you were not placed under oath to affirm that the evidence and testimony is truthful? No doubt, you were truthful though.

Both my wife and I were sick that day but did not want to reschedule the interview so we went in anyways. We had to wait an hour or so before being called so we got even worst. Quite frankly she might have sworn us in and I might not recollect at the moment, but either way my wife and I will be there on Tuesday with the evidence we had that day + a few things more.

The interview was definitely odd, I was expecting her to ask me if I had an updated 864, etc and she never asked.

Triple Citizen: Quite frankly I don't know what rate of immigration fraud her country has cause I don't follow immigration fraud rates at all. This is my first marriage as is hers so I don't really know what happened that day. My wife is from Peru and I have receipts from plane tickets when I went to see her a few times prior to getting married. Would this evidence be valid?
 
That evidence will surely count. I see this playing out in 2 ways. She will either receive an approval notice, or you both will be invited for a second round of interviews. Just wait it out.

Triple Citizen: Quite frankly I don't know what rate of immigration fraud her country has cause I don't follow immigration fraud rates at all. This is my first marriage as is hers so I don't really know what happened that day. My wife is from Peru and I have receipts from plane tickets when I went to see her a few times prior to getting married. Would this evidence be valid?
 
Top