Lou Dobbs misreported again tonight

ipcomUser

Registered Users (C)
I was watching Lou Dobbs tonight and was not surprised at all by the false statements made by him regarding sen Byrd's amendments (Lou Dobbs does that all the time esp. regarding immigration). He said senate is hurting american middle class by increasing H1 visa. He said only 14 Senator had guts to reject the increase and showed names of those 14.

First of all I was appalled by such misguided reporting and false statements but he is always like this, I was wondering why he does that, He once founded space.com and still on its board, does anyone have any more info. about his background as to why he blindly bashes immgration?

I have written strongly worded email to him and I would suggest more should write to him.
 
What's this nut e-mail and is it possible to find a transcript of the report? I'll join you and send him an e-mail also.

ipcomUser said:
I was watching Lou Dobbs tonight and was not surprised at all by the false statements made by him regarding sen Byrd's amendments (Lou Dobbs does that all the time esp. regarding immigration). He said senate is hurting american middle class by increasing H1 visa. He said only 14 Senator had guts to reject the increase and showed names of those 14.

First of all I was appalled by such misguided reporting and false statements but he is always like this, I was wondering why he does that, He once founded space.com and still on its board, does anyone have any more info. about his background as to why he blindly bashes immgration?

I have written strongly worded email to him and I would suggest more should write to him.
 
Here is the relevant portion

you can find the complete script here:

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0511/03/ldt.01.html

Here is the part which referred to today's voting in Senate, there was another segment which talked about how companies are exploiting H1 visa program by hiring cheap labor. You can send email thru cnn.com and "contact us" menu option.

--------
TUCKER: And today, the Senate had the chance to say no to more H-1B's, but they didn't. Senator Byrd of Virginia (sic) offered an amendment to strip out the proposed visa increase out of the budget reconciliation bill. Lou, his amendment failed by a vote of 14-to-85.

DOBBS: That is appalling, absolutely appalling. And we thought it would be interesting to you to see who those 14 senators were who had the guts to say enough on this issue. Standing up for our middle class.

Bill, tell us about these folks.

TUCKER: Well, what's interesting is, it's a bipartisan list. It tilts toward the Democrats -- three Republicans, 10 Democrats, one Independent. But only one state Lou, where both senators voted to take the bill out, and that was Louisiana, where you had Landrieu and you had Vitter, Democrat and Republican, voting to take it out and debate the issue independently of the bill.

DOBBS: Appalling, and good for those 14, perhaps their number will swell if courage becomes contagious and concern for working men and women in this country becomes at least, if not contagious, some people can awaken to the interest of the national interest there.

Thank you, Bill Tucker.
 
Bunch of Idiots

I dont understand how these A**H**** became senators and tv talk show hosts if they cant read english and understand english. The bill says not new H1 Visa's but unused Visa's and that these are visa's already approved by the congress. They are just giving them back like a second chance and these guys are making a big fuss out of it. They dont even understand the diff between h1b visa and green card visa.. I couldn't stop laughing when I read Byrd argument from the 2nd.

If they have a point regarding illegal immigrants they ask them add that as a addendum but not take out what legal immigrants are entitled. They want our taxes our social securities our medicare but to increase the visa they crib like illiterates.
 
I used to be a fan of him. But since I sensed he is very anti-immigration, I don't watch his show any more
 
nonogc said:
I used to be a fan of him. But since I sensed he is very anti-immigration, I don't watch his show any more
This was my message:

Dear Editor CNN:

I am appalled at Lou Dobbs’ narrow-mindedness. He uses freedom of speech to make false statements and inundating the American viewers his skewed views on immigration. First he talks about legal immigration and immediately his stories trail to illegal immigration. To an average American it is hard to make the distinction.

He informs the viewers that US corporation love H1B visa holders. Can he make a single argument why would that be the case? For every single foreign national that an American corporation hires they have to pay thousands of dollars in fees for maintaining VISA, advertising costs and legal immigration fees. Why would any corporation whose main aim is to “increase shareholders wealth” do that for no unknown reason? The reason they do that is because it is difficult to hire skilled workers even in this slow economy.

History of America has re-iterated that immigrants are a very hard working race. They are the ones who are graduating from American Universities with Engineering and Science graduate degrees. Is Mr. Dobbs even aware that each of the H1B Visa and Immigrant Visa (EB) sponsored by employers requires advertising in local, national newspapers and they have to offer competitive wage? I do not disagree that there are abuses to the system, but please don’t fool yourself to think that it is the most corrupt system in this country, where the integrity of all the people who are involved in this process are being questioned.

I am ashamed that an anchor can be so biased and not even try to understand the whole process before making unjust and unfair statements. We legal immigrants live in this society and pay taxes. We also pay social security and medicare taxes that we forfeit if we decide to go back to our home countries. Senator Byrd, whom Mr. Dobbs praised, mentioned in the Senate that the hospitals are filled with excess capacity. We legal immigrants pay tax and healthcare and have a right to use these facilities. To make a mockery out of it does he even know, who the nurses are that take care of “Americans” in hospitals; they are nurses who are on Visas from Philippines and India.

I sincerely hope CNN will have the courage to apologize for such unjustified lame remarks that Mr. Dobbs makes about legal immigrants.

Yours truly,

A Proud Immigrant
 
Can a jounalist be sued by misleading the public or spreading rumors? Journalism freedom should not be abused.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Personal vendetta..

My feeling is that this guy has some personal vendetta against immigrants. He is so against immigration. He calls himself economist but he has zero sense of reality of world. May be he lost job to an immigrant, useless fellow.
 
Don't watch his show!!

The worst thing one can do is watch Loo's show...it boosts his ratings, causes more Ad dollars to flow in, and makes it more influential (than it really is!).

I used to watch it earlier, but soon became tired of the baseless **BS** and empty rhetoric. If he says something controversial I just look up the show transcript.

This guy is dividing the society of this great land...pitting people against each other. Sure, free speech is allowed (even the KKK does it however offensive that may be), but someone needs to get this man's facts straight.
 
agree with sobers. Stop watching his show so that his ratings go down.
He seems to be obsessed with china and immigration.
 
Stop watching Dobbs

Guys, I agree with you. I used to be a fan of his show and wattched it regularly. But I was as dimayed when he started presenting a totally one sided skewed view of immigration including legal immigration. He always invites virulant anti immigrants like Tom Tancredo and never presensts a balanced view or invites someone from the other side to debate or present a second opinion. I have actually emailed him at cnn and complained about his rhetoric, but of course he keeps on his tirade against immigrants. I would definately agree with folks here to stop watching his show. Watching it would only boost his ratings. There is no point in watching baseless immigrant bashing when you cannot respond.
 
I used to watch this show until 02. since then he started attacking h1b program. he does not show very good understanding on this issue; I stopped watching his show.
yesterday, some republican-oriented radio talk show program were furthering lou's argument; quoting him. I do not know what the position of hannity and limbaugh is.

I think knowledge is key; these hosts can mislead americans.
what is needed is campaign from immigrants to demonstrate contributions made by immigrants from india & china to the economy of this country. it seems that immigrants do not do this enough or effectively.
deba_sinh said:
Guys, I agree with you. I used to be a fan of his show and wattched it regularly. But I was as dimayed when he started presenting a totally one sided skewed view of immigration including legal immigration. He always invites virulant anti immigrants like Tom Tancredo and never presensts a balanced view or invites someone from the other side to debate or present a second opinion. I have actually emailed him at cnn and complained about his rhetoric, but of course he keeps on his tirade against immigrants. I would definately agree with folks here to stop watching his show. Watching it would only boost his ratings. There is no point in watching baseless immigrant bashing when you cannot respond.
 
I don't understand why you spend your valuable time with him. He is an idiot that purposely mis-interpret immigration related information to agitate anti-immigration crowd. He would be laughing when he sees your email.

Save you energe to talk with somebody who really wants to understand the siutation, such as your senator and congressman.


modhu said:
This was my message:

Dear Editor CNN:

I am appalled at Lou Dobbs’ narrow-mindedness. He uses freedom of speech to make false statements and inundating the American viewers his skewed views on immigration. First he talks about legal immigration and immediately his stories trail to illegal immigration. To an average American it is hard to make the distinction.

He informs the viewers that US corporation love H1B visa holders. Can he make a single argument why would that be the case? For every single foreign national that an American corporation hires they have to pay thousands of dollars in fees for maintaining VISA, advertising costs and legal immigration fees. Why would any corporation whose main aim is to “increase shareholders wealth” do that for no unknown reason? The reason they do that is because it is difficult to hire skilled workers even in this slow economy.

History of America has re-iterated that immigrants are a very hard working race. They are the ones who are graduating from American Universities with Engineering and Science graduate degrees. Is Mr. Dobbs even aware that each of the H1B Visa and Immigrant Visa (EB) sponsored by employers requires advertising in local, national newspapers and they have to offer competitive wage? I do not disagree that there are abuses to the system, but please don’t fool yourself to think that it is the most corrupt system in this country, where the integrity of all the people who are involved in this process are being questioned.

I am ashamed that an anchor can be so biased and not even try to understand the whole process before making unjust and unfair statements. We legal immigrants live in this society and pay taxes. We also pay social security and medicare taxes that we forfeit if we decide to go back to our home countries. Senator Byrd, whom Mr. Dobbs praised, mentioned in the Senate that the hospitals are filled with excess capacity. We legal immigrants pay tax and healthcare and have a right to use these facilities. To make a mockery out of it does he even know, who the nurses are that take care of “Americans” in hospitals; they are nurses who are on Visas from Philippines and India.

I sincerely hope CNN will have the courage to apologize for such unjustified lame remarks that Mr. Dobbs makes about legal immigrants.

Yours truly,

A Proud Immigrant
 
Still ahead, the H-1B visa program is hurting hard working Americans, and Americans who want to work in corporate America, and just about everybody in the Democratic party sitting in the United States Congress couldn't be happier. We'll have a "Special Report" for you coming up next.

And one of the world's most knowledgeable doctors joins me, one of the most knowledgeable doctors on bird flu, and he says there is no question a pandemic is coming. We'll be talking with him next.

(COMMERCIAL BREAK)

DOBBS: Many American companies just love our federal government's H-1B visa program. Under that program, corporations are able to hire foreign workers for jobs that should be going to American workers, and it just gets better for U.S. firms. A new study says 85 percent of those foreign workers who are receiving H-1 visas are paid well below what Americans would be making for the same job. It is just further evidence that the federal government is failing to protect our hard working middle class, as if we needed more evidence. Bill Tucker has the report.

(BEGIN VIDEOTAPE)

BILL TUCKER, CNN CORRESPONDENT (voice-over): H-1B workers in computer occupations were paid, on average, $13,000 less than Americans doing the same work last year.

In a soon-to-be released study by the Programmers Guild, 85 percent of H-1B workers are paid less than the median wage of an American worker. Not only that, those H-1B computer workers are at the bottom of the wage scale. Lobbyists argue that American businesses can't do without more H-1B's.

JOHN MIANO, PROGRAMMERS GUILD: We're being told that these are people that are highly skilled and that their skills are so important that the nation's economy depends upon it, yet they're being paid wages that are the bottom of the barrel.

TUCKER: The conclusion is easily drawn. H-1B's are cheap foreign labor, and Congress is ready to increase the number of H-1B's issued by another 30,000. The current cap is 65,000 new Visas a year.

However, there are exemptions, such as there are no limits to the number of visas issued to universities and research institutions. And up to 20,000 are reserved for foreign workers with graduate degrees from American colleges going to work for U.S. companies. Critics say American companies save jobs for H-1B workers and deny American workers those positions.

REP. BILL PASCRELL, (D), NEW JERSEY: I'm going to introduce legislation next week that says American workers should have the first crack at these jobs and regardless of what GE does and regardless of what Wal-Mart does and regardless of what Lucent does, give them the first opportunity at these jobs and train them.

(END VIDEOTAPE)

TUCKER: And today, the Senate had the chance to say no to more H-1B's, but they didn't. Senator Byrd of Virginia (sic) offered an amendment to strip out the proposed visa increase out of the budget reconciliation bill. Lou, his amendment failed by a vote of 14-to-85.

DOBBS: That is appalling, absolutely appalling. And we thought it would be interesting to you to see who those 14 senators were who had the guts to say enough on this issue. Standing up for our middle class.

Bill, tell us about these folks.

TUCKER: Well, what's interesting is, it's a bipartisan list. It tilts toward the Democrats -- three Republicans, 10 Democrats, one Independent. But only one state Lou, where both senators voted to take the bill out, and that was Louisiana, where you had Landrieu and you had Vitter, Democrat and Republican, voting to take it out and debate the issue independently of the bill.

DOBBS: Appalling, and good for those 14, perhaps their number will swell if courage becomes contagious and concern for working men and women in this country becomes at least, if not contagious, some people can awaken to the interest of the national interest there.

Thank you, Bill Tucker.

While U.S. companies love our government's Visa program, illegal aliens love our broken borders. As we reported, only 75 miles of our 2,000 mile long border with Mexico is protected.

That means an astonishing 96 percent of our entire southern border has no barrier. My guest, next, wanted to change all of that.

Congressman Duncan Hunter wants to build a double-layer of fences along the border. And he joins us tonight from Capitol Hill.

Congressman, good to have you here. Two-thousand miles of border you want to protect it. How much do you think it's going to cost?

REP. DUNCAN HUNTER, (R), CALIFORNIA: Well Lou, we've actually built the double fence in San Diego, as you may know, and that 14 miles between the coastal hills and the Pacific Ocean were one time the nation's worst drug smuggling --

DOBBS: Smuggler's Gulch.

HUNTER: There it is, right there. It was the worst in the world. We built 12 miles of that, and nobody is able to get through that double layer with a border patrol road down the middle.

We can build this, we've had proposals from private companies for about a million bucks a mile. It may cost a little more than that in the tough geographic areas, but we think we can do it between $2 billion and $6 billion.

We're spending billions of dollars every year to handle this flow of illegals, especially the criminal aliens who are clogging up the court system. DOBBS: We can start look very specifically. You're the chairman of the very important House Armed Services Committee. What we're spending to protect this country, yet leaving our southern border and our northern border absolutely vulnerable. It is extraordinary, I think, to most people watching and listening to you, Congressman.

To find that we would not spend considerable money and effort to protect this country from what last year, three million people crossed that border illegally, to protect them from the potential of a terrorist entry.

HUNTER: Lou, you know, the world has changed. Lots of people, especially in Texas and New Mexico. When I started building the border fence in California, I asked those folks if they wanted to build fences and they said no, we want a friendly border.

The friendly border has now evolved into a border, No. 1 through which terrorists can come. We've caught North Koreans coming across, Communist Chinese.

DOBBS: In the past year?

HUNTER: Absolutely. In the past year, people from Yemen, lots of countries that sponsor terrorism, including Iran. So, it's no longer just an immigration issue. It's a national security issue, and I think we had a ton of Republicans sign onto this thing today, we're going to get this thing up and moving and I think we'll get it passed.

DOBBS: Let me ask you something, Congressman. Does the leadership of the House, the Republican leadership of the House, the Republican leadership of the Senate understand?

Do they look at same polls the rest of us do? I mean, the American people are fed up with this issue of illegal immigration. They're fed up with the fact we even have a Department of Homeland Security when we don't even protect our borders. Do they understand that?

HUNTER: Lou, the Republican leadership is on board with this thing. They pushed the legislation, as you know, behind Jim Sensenbrenner, that got Smuggler's Gulch closed. We had to hangup for six years on environmental issues and we now have a waiver for the entire border, north and south, where we can waive environmental issues, build the fences. Let's do it.

DOBBS: Quick test, Congressman. How soon can you get this legislation passed and how soon can you get it done?

HUNTER: I think we're going to get it done quickly, Lou. We got Smuggler's Gulch closed up fairly quickly. I think we'll get a -- it's got a lot of critical mass, I think we'll move it through very quickly.

DOBBS: This year?

HUNTER: I think so. That's my hope and we got the -- we got Smuggler's Gulch closed faster than I thought we would.

DOBBS: Fourteen miles down, 1,986 to go. Congressman.

HUNTER: Bring your pole vaulting team, Lou.

DOBBS: You got it. Thank you very much.

Appreciate it. Congressman Duncan Hunter.

Take a look now at some of your thoughts. Many of you writing in about the so-called diversity Visa Lottery program that our State Department uses, that of course, would allow potential terrorists to enter this country legally because it's a lottery after all.

Why would we want them to use care and judgment? Wieslaw Pogorzelski of San Francisco, California, said, the visa lottery is brilliant. I have another idea, let's elect our president by having the candidates play Russian Roulette.

Darla Howard in Tennessee Ridge, Tennessee, this so-called land of the free is a joke. Let's just give it to the illegal aliens and the terrorists. They get more help from our president and his people than the Americans do.

Jeff Gullikson in Wakonda, South Dakota, the more illegals, the cheaper the labor, the bigger the profits. The only thing about illegal immigrants that concerns the Bush White House is how to get more of them in, and the faster, the better. Security and America, be damned.

And Elisa Writesel of Columbus, Ohio. Lou, as members of the liberal middle class, by husband and I live under a darkening cloud. Thanks for always brightening our day with your no B.S. allowed broadcast.

Jim Speed of Pensacola, Florida. The rule 21 stunt dragged the Senate to a new low with the Congressional equivalent of a fraternity food fight. We have big problems and the Senate Dems are wasting time looking for a Republican, any Republican, to blame for political purposes. Senators have replaced used car salesmen as the ultimate bottom feeders.
 
Read
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lou_Dobbs

You see, he is against immigration - both legal and illegal.

Bottom Line: Stop watching his show!


I think we all have better things to do than watch and discuss about Lou on this board. Let us move on to more important things like strengthening our cause. Ignore him.
 
Sent an email to CNN with slight change in the above mentioned content

Dear Editor CNN:

I am appalled at Lou Dobbs’ narrow-mindedness. He uses freedom of speech to make false statements and inundating the American viewers his skewed views on immigration. First he talks about legal immigration and immediately his stories trail to illegal immigration. To an average American it is hard to make the distinction.

He informs the viewers that US corporation love H1B visa holders. Can he make a single argument why would that be the case? For every single foreign national that an American corporation hires they have to pay thousands of dollars in fees for maintaining VISA, advertising costs and legal immigration fees. Why would any corporation whose main aim is to “increase shareholders wealth” do that for no unknown reason? The reason they do that is because it is difficult to hire skilled workers even in this slow economy.

History of America has re-iterated that immigrants are a very hard working race. They are the ones who are graduating from American Universities with Engineering and Science graduate degrees. Is Mr. Dobbs even aware that each of the H1B Visa and Immigrant Visa (EB) sponsored by employers requires advertising in local, national newspapers and they have to offer competitive wage? I do not disagree that there are abuses to the system, but please don’t fool yourself to think that it is the most corrupt system in this country, where the integrity of all the people who are involved in this process are being questioned.

I am ashamed that an anchor can be so biased and not even try to understand the whole process before making unjust and unfair statements. We legal immigrants live in this society and pay taxes. We also pay social security and medicare taxes that we forfeit if we decide to go back to our home countries. Senator Byrd, whom Mr. Dobbs praised, mentioned in the Senate that the hospitals are filled with excess capacity. We legal immigrants pay tax and healthcare and have a right to use these facilities. To make a mockery out of it does he even know, who the nurses are that take care of “Americans” in hospitals; they are nurses who are on Visas from Philippines and India.

I sincerely hope CNN will have the courage to apologize for such unjustified lame remarks that Mr. Dobbs makes about legal immigrants.

In the recent "Discovery Channel Young Scientist Challenge", the winners were
Neela Thangada, Nilesh Tripuraneni. They were in first and second positions respectively. Just see the way how immigrants are contributing to the US leadership in science and technology.


Yours truly,

A Proud Immigrant
 
Very effective email! By the way, what is email address of CNN Editior or Lou Dobb? Thanks.

modhu said:
This was my message:

Dear Editor CNN:

I am appalled at Lou Dobbs’ narrow-mindedness. He uses freedom of speech to make false statements and inundating the American viewers his skewed views on immigration. First he talks about legal immigration and immediately his stories trail to illegal immigration. To an average American it is hard to make the distinction.

He informs the viewers that US corporation love H1B visa holders. Can he make a single argument why would that be the case? For every single foreign national that an American corporation hires they have to pay thousands of dollars in fees for maintaining VISA, advertising costs and legal immigration fees. Why would any corporation whose main aim is to “increase shareholders wealth” do that for no unknown reason? The reason they do that is because it is difficult to hire skilled workers even in this slow economy.

History of America has re-iterated that immigrants are a very hard working race. They are the ones who are graduating from American Universities with Engineering and Science graduate degrees. Is Mr. Dobbs even aware that each of the H1B Visa and Immigrant Visa (EB) sponsored by employers requires advertising in local, national newspapers and they have to offer competitive wage? I do not disagree that there are abuses to the system, but please don’t fool yourself to think that it is the most corrupt system in this country, where the integrity of all the people who are involved in this process are being questioned.

I am ashamed that an anchor can be so biased and not even try to understand the whole process before making unjust and unfair statements. We legal immigrants live in this society and pay taxes. We also pay social security and medicare taxes that we forfeit if we decide to go back to our home countries. Senator Byrd, whom Mr. Dobbs praised, mentioned in the Senate that the hospitals are filled with excess capacity. We legal immigrants pay tax and healthcare and have a right to use these facilities. To make a mockery out of it does he even know, who the nurses are that take care of “Americans” in hospitals; they are nurses who are on Visas from Philippines and India.

I sincerely hope CNN will have the courage to apologize for such unjustified lame remarks that Mr. Dobbs makes about legal immigrants.

Yours truly,

A Proud Immigrant
 
You guys really need to stop sending him emails...Radio/TV host measure their effectiveness by counting how much response they get, as a host, if you are flooded with positive response, you are good, if you are flooded with both negative and positive response, you are a genius. Their job is to make people to talk. Your email will only encourage him to distort the truth even more. He is not dumb. He has the information, he knows the fact. It's just that immigration is such a good attention grabber so they love to tout it. It's useless to try to convince him.

AAA_USA said:
 
I agree with atl_fp

Let's concentrate our efforts to contact Budget committee for House and Senate.
 
Top