Concurrent Filers (140/485) CSC-TSC: Waiting for 140 Approval

ahaly said:
I dont see the reasoning behind not handling concurrent cases... it is not like they are send approvals for 485... i bet a lot of people have PD as current and are waiting for 485 approvals... TSC can handle concurrent cases in the same way as it is handling those cases....

Guys.. hold on. Here is my analysis (rather assumptions !).
1. Most of the concurrent cases were filed before oct 1st. Folks from "other"
countries still would have applied concurrently after oct 1st. Do we have
any data on those "other" cases ?
2. On Mar 21st - First set of cases that got transferred to TSC
(Cases with ND around end oct - Jan 06).
3. Between Mar 22-27 : The old pending cases (Sep-Oct) were
transferred.
4. It is most likely thay the first round of cases that got transferred
could not file I-485 (retro countries). I did not take "Other" countries
into account.
5. Is it possible that TSC is working on FIFO only ? - Processing all cases
transferred on mar 21 now... Again we don't know the volume of those.

Anyone with a better theory ?
 
Mine is EB-2 Other countries - worldwide with current Visa numbers. It looks like they are waiting to then adjudicate I-140 and I-485 together. Problem is that takes away advantage/security of having approved I-140 when switching jobs if the processing mess takes too long. Once again USCIS tardiness is helping unscrupulous employers and lawyers. I bet they must hate it once USCIS (finally - if ever) streamlines the whole process.

nikedude said:
1. Most of the concurrent cases were filed before oct 1st. Folks from "other"
countries still would have applied concurrently after oct 1st. Do we have
any data on those "other" cases ?
 
gc_2006 said:
Mine is EB-2 Other countries - worldwide with current Visa numbers. It looks like they are waiting to then adjudicate I-140 and I-485 together. Problem is that takes away advantage/security of having approved I-140 when switching jobs if the processing mess takes too long. Once again USCIS tardiness is helping unscrupulous employers and lawyers. I bet they must hate it once USCIS (finally - if ever) streamlines the whole process.

Thats the whole problem. I am stuck with my employer. I want to change my job but I cant - because of this stinking process.

Also I am not sure what TSC is waiting for. Are they waiting for PDs to be current? I am sure there are people right now whose PDs are current and I am sure whenever they start processing these applications, there will be people whose PDs are not current.

They should atleast come up with a public statement....
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Its even worse who are about to complete 6th year.

ahaly said:
Thats the whole problem. I am stuck with my employer. I want to change my job but I cant - because of this stinking process.

Also I am not sure what TSC is waiting for. Are they waiting for PDs to be current? I am sure there are people right now whose Pds are current and I am sure whenever they start processing these applications, there will be people whose PDs are not current.

They should atleast come up with a public statement atleast..
 
TSC is simply ignoring concurrent filers

ahaly said:
Thats the whole problem. I am stuck with my employer. I want to change my job but I cant - because of this stinking process.

Also I am not sure what TSC is waiting for. Are they waiting for PDs to be current? I am sure there are people right now whose PDs are current and I am sure whenever they start processing these applications, there will be people whose PDs are not current.

They should atleast come up with a public statement....
My pD(May 2002 EB2) is already current.So i dont think they are waiting for the PD to become current.The only reason could be that there are lots of 485 pending with TSC and they want to clear out the pending 485.If they touch concurrently filed applications they are forced to process the respective 485 as well.for information i am stepping into my 8th year.
 
Many interesting assumptions...

- You guys come up with many interesting assumptions.
What about this idea then?

TSC tries to minimize further paperworks, processings evolving from
concurrent filiers such as portability thing.

For concurrent filiers, their GC will be judged within several months(or a
year?) so that TSC don't want to invite AC21 related paperwork by giving
out I140 approval to those filers.

By holding out I140 processing from concurrent filers, they can measure and
control visa number availability and manage the workload level which
they think unnecessary extra jobs. I am not sure how much more paperwork
or workload they can minimize from current situation.

Anyhow, personal freedom to change jobs all we sacrifice right now is not
their primary concern. But, what do our lawyers think about this situation if
they have to also sacrifice extra income from giving up AC21 paperwork?

Just my two cents totally out of my ignorance
 
waitingislife,

There is nothing like AC21 paper work. Its just the law that allows one to use
the given set of portability rules pending the adjudication of their petitions.
So its just a letter to the INS/USCIS informing the change of job. Thats it.

My only guess is that, concurrent filing and adjudication of such petitions
involves some actions back forth between 140 and 485. And thats why it
takes longer than non-concurrent/semi-concurrent cases. But the delay is
not supposed to take months together or years. So our cases are not
delayed just for that only reason, it took some amount of time in CSC-TSC /
USCIS re-shuffle, EB3 adjudications, and too many concurrent filing in and
around Sept 30th deadline for retrogressed countries so on and so forth.

If you look into the total number of pending concurrent petitions, all of them
or many of them are filed around Sept 30th. I don't think any concurrent
petition got adjudicated that are filed later than Sept-30th got approved.
Correct?




waitingislife said:
- You guys come up with many interesting assumptions.
What about this idea then?

TSC tries to minimize further paperworks, processings evolving from
concurrent filiers such as portability thing.

For concurrent filiers, their GC will be judged within several months(or a
year?) so that TSC don't want to invite AC21 related paperwork by giving
out I140 approval to those filers.

By holding out I140 processing from concurrent filers, they can measure and
control visa number availability and manage the workload level which
they think unnecessary extra jobs. I am not sure how much more paperwork
or workload they can minimize from current situation.

Anyhow, personal freedom to change jobs all we sacrifice right now is not
their primary concern. But, what do our lawyers think about this situation if
they have to also sacrifice extra income from giving up AC21 paperwork?

Just my two cents totally out of my ignorance
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Concurrent filer : got the below email today

On April 27, 2006, we responded to your request for more information concerning your case. If you have not received our response within 30 days from this date, please call customer service at 1-800-375-5283.


What does this mean ? This is for my I140 petition. Please help.
 
TSC touched your case

siddiboy said:
On April 27, 2006, we responded to your request for more information concerning your case. If you have not received our response within 30 days from this date, please call customer service at 1-800-375-5283.


What does this mean ? This is for my I140 petition. Please help.
Looks to me that they have sent RFE notice, but not 100% sure.
 
Looks like its either an inquiry from your attorney or may be an RFE.

siddiboy said:
On April 27, 2006, we responded to your request for more information concerning your case. If you have not received our response within 30 days from this date, please call customer service at 1-800-375-5283.


What does this mean ? This is for my I140 petition. Please help.
 
Please help

perm_faq said:
Looks like its either an inquiry from your attorney or may be an RFE.


Actually my attorny raised an inquiry about my I140 case on March 22 2006 to CSC. On the next day my petition was transferred to TSC. Today i got the message

On April 27, 2006, we responded to your request for more information concerning your case. If you have not received our response within 30 days from this date, please call customer service at 1-800-375-5283.

Does this mean they r letting us know that they replied for my attorny enquiry today ? also in that case also my attorny will get the letter saying that this is the response to ur enquiry..

Please advice...I saw the RFE thred ..it says RFE message will look something like "we mailed a notice requesting additional evidence or information in this case" ..

But the message i received was different..Please advice.
 
Exactly, It didn't look like RFE.

As I said, they just flagged it online saying that your inquiry was responded and complete. I think your attorney should receive response to your inquiry in the mail. They reponded on April 27th. The day before your 140 transferred, though they received inquiry but they did not do any thing on it, looks like they just logged it. CSC-TSC transfer had happend on your case as if any other case.

By the way, what was the inquiry? Was it just to check on your case or some thing else?



siddiboy said:
Actually my attorny raised an inquiry about my I140 case on March 22 2006 to CSC. On the next day my petition was transferred to TSC. Today i got the message

On April 27, 2006, we responded to your request for more information concerning your case. If you have not received our response within 30 days from this date, please call customer service at 1-800-375-5283.

Does this mean they r letting us know that they replied for my attorny enquiry today ? also in that case also my attorny will get the letter saying that this is the response to ur enquiry..

Please advice...I saw the RFE thred ..it says RFE message will look something like "we mailed a notice requesting additional evidence or information in this case" ..

But the message i received was different..Please advice.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Inquiry

perm_faq said:
Exactly, It didn't look like RFE.

As I said, they just flagged it online saying that your inquiry was responded and complete. I think your attorney should receive response to your inquiry in the mail.

By the way, what was the inquiry? Was it just to check on your case or some thing else?


I hope u remember some time around march 20th the Uscis processing time for CSC reported that the processing date was oct 31st. My case is filed on 09/29. So i asked my attorny to raise a inquiry since the processing date was showing oct 31st and mine was filed on 09/29.

Now today i got this message. I asked the attorny. The para legal folks told it looks like RFE.

But after posting in the forum and researching about the RFE messages and also taking my attorny inquiry into account it looks like it is a message from UScis letting know that they have respondded for my attorny inquiry.

Paralegal person is not even thinking about this possibility. I got good input from the forum..

I pray it not to be RFE still ..
 
siddiboy said:
I hope u remember some time around march 20th the Uscis processing time for CSC reported that the processing date was oct 31st. My case is filed on 09/29. So i asked my attorny to raise a inquiry since the processing date was showing oct 31st and mine was filed on 09/29.

Now today i got this message. I asked the attorny. The para legal folks told it looks like RFE.

But after posting in the forum and researching about the RFE messages and also taking my attorny inquiry into account it looks like it is a message from UScis letting know that they have respondded for my attorny inquiry.

Paralegal person is not even thinking about this possibility. I got good input from the forum..

I pray it not to be RFE still ..
relax siddiboy... its just a reply to the inquiry which you initiated in march and probably not an rfe.

infact right now to me rfe looks better than reply to inquiry
 
Yes, I know that. I think that was the last report from CSC. After that it had stopped publishing 140,485 dates. But, the interesting thing is, how come your attorney/para legal forgot that they were suppose to expect reply to their enquiry, correct? When I read your message, it just looks like an inquiry.




siddiboy said:
I hope u remember some time around march 20th the Uscis processing time for CSC reported that the processing date was oct 31st. My case is filed on 09/29. So i asked my attorny to raise a inquiry since the processing date was showing oct 31st and mine was filed on 09/29.

Now today i got this message. I asked the attorny. The para legal folks told it looks like RFE.

But after posting in the forum and researching about the RFE messages and also taking my attorny inquiry into account it looks like it is a message from UScis letting know that they have respondded for my attorny inquiry.

Paralegal person is not even thinking about this possibility. I got good input from the forum..

I pray it not to be RFE still ..
 
Last edited by a moderator:
We got our I140 approved on monday.

CA EB2 PD 2000-08 (substitute labor)
Filed 140 & 485 concurrently March 16th 2006
140 RD 2006-03
140 Transfer CA--TX 2006-03-22
485 - Last LUD - Transfer texas - 04-01

EAD & AP has been approved too.

Waiting for fingerprint notice. Good luck to all!
 
Congrats!

Looks like we have to wait ... not sure how long, but its already 8th month. Its not clear whats the creteria TSC is following currently? But there are
tons of cases filed in Sept 05 are still pending....

after140 said:
We got our I140 approved on monday.

CA EB2 PD 2000-08 (substitute labor)
Filed 140 & 485 concurrently March 16th 2006
140 RD 2006-03
140 Transfer CA--TX 2006-03-22
485 - Last LUD - Transfer texas - 04-01

EAD & AP has been approved too.

Waiting for fingerprint notice. Good luck to all!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
congrats

after140 said:
We got our I140 approved on monday.

CA EB2 PD 2000-08 (substitute labor)
Filed 140 & 485 concurrently March 16th 2006
140 RD 2006-03
140 Transfer CA--TX 2006-03-22
485 - Last LUD - Transfer texas - 04-01

EAD & AP has been approved too.

Waiting for fingerprint notice. Good luck to all!
Your approval even though shows USCIS in poorlight is a much needed shot in arm for us.Good Luck with your rest of the process.
 
Top