committed fraud way back 2003 and now applying Citizenship...

Thank you Huracan...i got my green card Sept 2, 2006 so that makes 3 years last Sept 2 this year and we are still married and very much inlove...we've been married for 6 years im just worried that after everything that we've been through to come back here with my husband and be together that Immigration will deny my application and worse deport me...
 
I think I see two things here. Your arrest was due to overstay of your K-visa. Isnt it ? Or was it due to immigration fraud ?

Whatever you do, do not get too emotional and volunteer any information in N400 and at interview that you did NOT previously disclose.

For example, if you were arrested for overstay of your K visa, then thats the only thing you disclose in N400 and tell IO. If you have never 'admitted' to immigration fraud in the past, then there is no need to 'admit' it now. If you never admitted something in the past but want to admit now, you better get a lawyer fast. Remember, admitted here means, you have verbally told judge or an officer and signed a document or it was written down.

Try to keep your visa overstay and first marriage for immigration benefit as two different things and think it through on what you have already told immigration services in the past and what you will tell them now. Ideally, what you told them in the past should match with what you are going to tell them now. Again, if you plan on admitting something new now, get a lawyer fast.
 
After the judge granted you voluntary leave, you left country and were petitioned by your 2nd husband and obtained a new visa after 3 years wait outside the US, correct?

When you were granted the GC, USCIS knew your past history..if they wanted to deport you again they would have done so then. You should be fine to apply for citizenship now. If your husband is in US military you can apply via military spouse route as well.
 
Also...i was reading the Guide for Naturalization and it states the effect of Removal Proceedings that says... If you have been ordered removed, you are
no longer eligible for naturalization.
To absrao...yes i admitted the fraud that i did thats why it took me 3 years to wait for my visa granted(present marriage)..
 
Also...i was reading the Guide for Naturalization and it states the effect of Removal Proceedings that says... If you have been ordered removed, you are
no longer eligible for naturalization.

That perhaps means the removal order is still in standing. If the order is canceled, then eligibility for naturealization may not be a problem unless
the removel order is originally for some crimes that establish permanent bar
to citizenship
 
When you were granted the GC, USCIS knew your past history..if they wanted to deport you again they would have done so then. You should be fine to apply for citizenship now.

In theory this is the case, USCIS does not grant a GC only in order to revoke it at a later time but in practice the people with pre-GC issues are not sure
that they were granted the GC because USCIS carefully examine their issue
and still considered they were admissible for AOS or USCIS just overlooked the issue
and granted the GC to applicants whom they shouldnot granted.

If the later is the case, USCIS may still be able to take back GC

I am not sure which is Maslouj's case. He voted before getting the GC
and dislcosed it during the interview I-485 did not ask for it)
 
I would suggest waiting until you are eligible for naturalization with the 5 year rule. Given your history, applying under the 3-year marriage rule is going to bring scrutiny and hassles up to your eyeballs.
 
I disclosed everything since the day my present husband filed petition for me...since it happened 2003 i thought it would be past 5 years and that i passed the 5 year Good Moral Character...
 
My point was that when you apply for naturalization with the 5 year rule, they generally don't care about your marriage, except that they sometimes ask for a marriage certificate (and divorce decree, if you have a previous marriage). But when you apply with the 3 year marriage rule, they scrutinize your marriage (again). They not only check whether the marriage was entered in good faith, but they have to be convinced the marriage is still healthy and viable. Given your history, it would not be a good idea to invite them to impose more scrutiny into your marriage, as their minds will be biased against you.
 
Thats a good point. Still thinking maybe if i expedite it due to my husbands military orders, it would be easy...i dunno...im seeking help from an immigration lawyer inside the military base just a consultation, we'll see what he have to say about it..
 
Thats a good point. Still thinking maybe if i expedite it due to my husbands military orders, it would be easy...i dunno...im seeking help from an immigration lawyer inside the military base just a consultation, we'll see what he have to say about it..

As far as I know you're permanently ineligible for Naturalization((
Did you accept fraud marriage?
Did you get waiver to go back to US for the second marriage?

Some Permanent Residents living in US have been granted waiver because of marriage with US Citizens, but they permanently remain ineligible for Naturalization, and I was reading couple years ago about same thing.
Person's CG based on marriage to US Citizen was about to expired, and guy was trying to renew GC, at that time he was divorced, and was recommend for deportation.
I don't know how rules has changed right now, but you better talk to Immigration Attorney at your local military installation JAG office first, then and then decide what's better wait or forget it(((
Bring your military spouse as well.
Which installation are you in?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
My husband is in the Marines, yes i admitted the fraud marriage...but why did they approved my visa and got my 10 year GC thru Removal of Condition if i am ineligible in the first place? i did not kill anybody or did drug trafficking or anything like that?
 
My husband is in the Marines, yes i admitted the fraud marriage...but why did they approved my visa and got my 10 year GC thru Removal of Condition if i am ineligible in the first place? i did not kill anybody or did drug trafficking or anything like that?

Semper Fi wife!
You're eligible for Green Card, since you're married U.S Citizen.
There is certain condition for Naturalization is to be a good moral character.
Fraud marriage is a serious violation of Immigration Law.

in Part 8 of N-400 Application for Naturalization you have to indicate your previous marriage and marked as "fraud marriage".
Iin part 10 you have to answer YES almost for all questions((
It's too many YESes(((

My advice to you, I know things has change since then, and this marriage is real. But don't try to go in front of the moving train. As far as I understand you're trying to fill out application based on 3 years marriage.
Talk to the military attorney at your Local JAG office, don't try to hire lawyer, because Military attorney is free of charge and he's not gonna lie to you about your case, and give you a right advice. Lawyer on the side he's gonna give you a "little chance" for money.
 
TITLE 8 OF CODE OF FEDERAL REGULATIONS (8 CFR) \ 8 CFR PART 316 -- GENERAL REQUIREMENTS FOR NATURALIZATION

§ Sec. 316.10 Good moral character.


(a) Requirement of good moral character during the statutory period.


(1) An applicant for naturalization bears the burden of demonstrating that, during the statutorily prescribed period, he or she has been and continues to be a person of good moral character. This includes the period between the examination and the administration of the oath of allegiance.


(2) In accordance with Section 101(f) of the Act, the Service shall evaluate claims of good moral character on a case-by-case basis taking into account the elements enumerated in this section and the standards of the average citizen in the community of residence. The Service is not limited to reviewing the applicant's conduct during the five years immediately preceding the filing of the application, but may take into consideration, as a basis for its determination, the applicant's conduct and acts at any time prior to that period, if the condu ct of the applicant during the statutory period does not reflect that there has been reform of character from an earlier period or if the earlier conduct and acts appear relevant to a determination of the applicant's present moral character.


(b) Finding of a lack of good moral character.


(1) An applicant shall be found to lack good moral character, if the applicant has been:


(i) Convicted of murder at any time; or (Revised 9/24/93; 58 FR 49913)


(ii) Convicted of an aggravated felony as defined in Section 101(a)(43) of the Act on or after November 29, 1990. (Revised 9/24/93; 58 FR 49913)


(2) An applicant shall be found to lack good moral character if during the statutory period the applicant:


(i) Committed one or more crimes involving moral turpitude, other than a purely political offense, for which the applicant was convicted, except as specified in Section 212(a)(2)(A)(ii)(II) of the Act;


(ii) Committed two or more offenses for which the applicant was convicted and the aggregate sentence actually imposed was five years or more, provided that, if the offense was committed outside the United States, it was not a purely political offense;


(iii) Violated any law of the United States, any State, or any foreign country relating to a controlled substance, provided that the violation was not a single offense for simple possession of 30 grams or less of marijuana;


(iv) Admits committing any criminal act covered by paragraphs (b)(2)(i), (ii), or (iii) of this section for which there was never a formal charge, indictment, arrest, or conviction, whether committed in the United States or any other country;


(v) Is or was confined to a penal institution for an aggregate of 180 days pursuant to a conviction or convictions (provided that such confinement was not outside the United States due to a conviction outside the United States for a purely political offense);


(vi) Has given false testimony to obtain any benefit from the Act, if the testimony was made under oath or affirmation and with an intent to obtain an immigration benefit; this prohibition applies regardless of whether the information provided in the false testimony was material, in the sense that if given truthfully it would have rendered ineligible for benefits either the applicant or the person on whose behalf the applicant sought the benefit;


(vii) Is or was involved in prostitution or commercialized vice as described in Section 212(a)(2)(D) of the Act;


(viii) Is or was involved in the smuggling of a person or persons into the United States as described in Section 212(a)(6)(E) of the Act;


(ix) Has practiced or is practicing polygamy;


(x) Committed two or more gambling offenses for which the applicant was convicted;


(xi) Earns his or her income principally from illegal gambling activities; or


(xii) Is or was a habitual drunkard.


(3) Unless the applicant establishes extenuating circumstances, the applicant shall be found to lack good moral character if, during the statutory period, the applicant:


(i) Willfully failed or refused to support dependents;


(ii) Had an extramarital affair which tended to destroy an existing marriage; or


(iii) Committed unlawful acts that adversely reflect upon the applicant's moral character, or was convicted or imprisoned for such acts, although the acts do not fall within the purview of Sec.316.10(b)(1) or (2).


(c) Proof of good moral character in certain cases


(1) Effect of probation or parole. An applicant who has been on probation, parole, or suspended sentence during all or part of the statutory period is not thereby precluded from establishing good moral character, but such probation, parole, or suspended sentence may be considered by the Service in determining good moral character. An application will not be approved until after the probation, parole, or suspended sentence has been completed.


(2) Full and unconditional executive pardon.


(i) Before the statutory period. An applicant who has received a full and unconditional executive pardon prior to the beginning of the statutory period is not precluded by Sec.316.10(b)(1) from establishing good moral character provided the applicant demonstrates that reformation and rehabilitation occurred prior to the beginning of the statutory period.


(ii) During the statutory period. An applicant who receives a full and unconditional executive pardon during the statutory period is not precluded by Sec.316.10(b)(2)(i) and (ii) from establishing good moral character, provided the applicant can demonstrate that extenuating and/or exonerating circumstances exist that would establish his or her good moral character.


(3) Record expungement.


(i) Drug offenses. Where an applicant has had his or her record expunged relating to one of the narcotics offenses under Section 212(a)(2)(A)(i)(II) and Section 241(a)(2) (B) of the Act, that applicant shall be considered as having been "convicted" within the meaning of Sec. 316.10(b)(2)(ii), or, if confined, as having been confined as a result of "conviction" for purposes of Sec. 316.10(b)(2)(iv).


(ii) Moral turpitude. An applicant who has committed or admits the commission of two or more crimes involving moral turpitude during the statutory period is precluded from establishing good moral character, even though the conviction record of one such offense has been expunged.
 
I am not a lawyer, and do not understand the marriage based naturalization as well, and you should definitely talk to a lawyer. However, I want to break down your situation into 2 parts, which must both be independently resolved:

#1. Can your past be forgiven? I do not know, others have given good advice, and a lawyer will be the best helper.

#2. Is your present clean? I do not want to poke on this topic publicly, but you should examine and see how clean your current marriage is so as not to raise any flags. Since your first marriage was known to be fraudulent, (assuming they forgive your past), they will still seriously scrutinize your current marriage. Some things I can think of
a) How long you have lived together? You admitted you were not in US for the first 3 years, and your husband is in marines - so was he away most of the other 3 years
b) presence of children together
c) presence of household together
d) are you filing taxes jointly, or individually with different addresses
e) do you have joint bank accounts

While you can not fix your past (but a lawyer may tell you how to put the best face on this), you can definitely examine your present and see if needs further correction before you apply for naturalization. Make a list of all warning flags you get, and see if you can correct them or not.

Check previous threads about the scrutiny which happens for marriage based naturalization, and expect to be questioned on every single aspect. They may not ask anything, but best to be prepared.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thank you...those are very informative replies...i will see what the lawyer will say and ill keep you guys posted...
 
Top