Claiming to be citizen - N400 question

I told him to call the school and verify that he is a US citizen in their system. If he is then he needs to simply them them it was in error, he is rather a US permanent resident, they must have checked the "US citizen" box in error, and have them correct it.

Then the person(usually a student aid) behind the counter easily corrects the error(unchecks the US citizen box). then the op requests the school mails him something that say's it was updated with the proper information and corrected. Simple



This doesn't sound like a simple school error where they checked off the wrong box. The OP posted:

..."I've ever claimed to be a citizen, I have when I applied for the University"

thus indicating he knowingly claimed to be a US citizen on the application process.

Did you not read the consequences of a similar case in the link I provided above?? It can be very serious.

Read my link. Dude you must be perfect, are you??
 
I even doubt univeersty keep that record. DO they keep application form for ever? Even if they keep for ever, perhaps they send old application form
to some storage places where it is hard to access easily. It is a big issue
for the OP but not big enough for teh university to do anyone a favor,

I agree with the first part. I however don't consider this a ban for citizenship. People take this to seriously, really.
 
Guys claiming US citiznship on a school application is NOT a big deal. Look at this guy who claimed US citizenship on the almighty I-9 form for employment. He could cought, look what happened to him........

http://www.nilc.org/immsemplymnt/ircaempverif/irca058.htm

It depends. If you are neither US citizen nor a PR, you need a F-1 visa
to attend university. So claiming US citizenship in application for unievrsity
is a serious matter.

Remember someone here even got into trouble by telling her firends she was a citizen because she was tired of people asking her about where she is from
 
I agree with the first part. I however don't consider this a ban for citizenship. People take this to seriously, really.

The OP has been a PR for 5 years. So iuf he did claim US citizen ship, it is likely he did it before he got the GC. Then it would be very serious
because you got around F1 visa requirement

By the way, if he did claim to be a US citizen before he got the GC, it would be similar to the Maslouj's case. Ironically I485 did not ask whether
you ever claimed to be a US citizen or not. So even if you claimed
to be a US citizen before GC and not disclosed it during GC process, you still
obtained your GC fair and square.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Your link is for I-9 form, not university application. If you're going to make a valid point, at least compare apples with apples.

What would you consider worse?? Your school application, or work illgally claiming US citizenship on a job application??
 
Last edited by a moderator:
What would you consider worse?? You school application, or work illgally claiming US citizenship on a job application??

I think equally worse. One is trying to circumbventj F1 visa program and
the other is trying to circumvent H1B visa.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I know the consequences ..

Are you sure? You've mentioned over and over it's not a big deal, yet it can be big deal.

Even if the OP calls the University, the first thing they will check is his application and see he claimed to be a US citizen. How do you suggest he fix that? Just say it was a mistake and risk having him having him pay back any college grants he received?
 
Are you sure? You've mentioned over and over it's not a big deal, yet it can be big deal.

Even if the OP calls the University, the first thing they will check is his application and see he claimed to be a US citizen. How do you suggest he fix that? Just say it was a mistake and risk having him having him pay back any college grants he received?

Yes, he thought he was a US citizen, not a permanent resident. Most people don't even know the difference between a LPR, citizen. I didn't when I was young.

Do you really think the school is going to tell him "hey you owe us money from 15 yrs ago". Dude people look for solutions on here, you give none.
 
Yes, he thought he was a US citizen, not a permanent resident. Most people don't even know the difference between a LPR, citizen. I didn't when I was young.

Claiming ignorance isn't a defense.
Do you really think the school is going to tell him "hey you owe us money from 15 yrs ago". Dude people look for solutions on here, you give none.

My solution was to seek the advice of a lawyer since it can have serious consequences and not take bad advice based on trial and error.
 
I agree with Bobsmyth..."many people not knowing the difference" is not a defence...

In fact, many people who deal with Federal Agencies as gov subcontractors do know very well the know difference. Example, US export regulation on the certain high tech product do limit the distribution and access to USC for one category and US LPR (US residents) for the other categories

The Ignorance is not cure or healthy advice. The world is not simple, there are rules and regulation , ignoring them will not get you anywhere ..in fact, it may cost you more on long run.
 
Claiming ignorance isn't a defense.


My solution was to seek the advice of a lawyer since it can have serious consequences and not take bad advice based on trial and error.

Lawyers don't know a thing either. Just like in Maslouj's case, soem lawyers advised him to withdraw the application to save his green card others say
try out your luck.
 
Lawyers don't know a thing either. Just like in Maslouj's case, soem lawyers advised him to withdraw the application to save his green card others say
try out your luck.

Generalization based on a few examples of bad advice.
 
Top