Anyone with a lawsuit against USCIS or thinking about a lawsuit (Merged)

[paz1960]

hi, all:

just got an answer to my case, here are the important part of it at least i think it is:

=====
....
cause of action

11. defendants deny that plaintiff had her naturalization examination on July, 2006. plaintiff was interviewed as a component of the naturalization examination. piror to contemporary procedues, background checks were not required to be completed before a naturalization interview was conducted, plaintiff's naturalization examination is not yet complete.

...
FIRST AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE

the court should dismiss the complaint under Fed.R.Civ.P.12(b)(6) because plaintiff fail to state a claim upon relief may be granted.

SECOND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE

the court should dismiss the complaint under Fed.R.Civ.P.12(b)(1) for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.

WHEREFORE, defendants pray for relief as follows:

the judgment be entered for defendants and against plaintiff, dismissing plaintiff's petition with prejudice; that plaintiff take nothing; and that the Court grant such further relief as it deems just and proper under the circumstances.

=======

so what does this implies? good sign or bad sign, i know that i dont have to file anything to the answer since it's not a motion, but does this imply that AUSA will fight me on the court for my case?

please please give me some feedback and help. i am in north district court of california. filed in san jose, under judge RMW.

thanks,

pearl

Filing an answer to a complaint is required by the 60 day deadline, so is nothing unusual. Alternatively, AUSA could file a motion to extend or a motion to dismiss or remand. You are right; because an answer doesn't require a reply, you don't have to file anything, but you should be prepared to oppose a motion to dismiss or remand which may come any time or more likely, a hearing (preceded by an initial case management conference or something like this). If there will be a hearing, you will need to defend your claims, essentially to explain to the judge why defendants affirmative defenses are incorrect and why your claims are valid.

This scenario (i.e, heading for a hearing or some dispositive motion) will be more frequent, people will not get their case solved like before, when the expedited name check was automatically triggered by the lawsuit. But you should not be worried; the law is on your side, you just need to be well prepared and defend your case vigurously.

 

[gmlvsk]

Before 12/22/06, Was expedite name check initiated by AUSA or USCIS?
To make it more narrow - was assigned to case AUSA requirement for expedite name check?
Thanks

 

[snorlax]

Filing an answer to a complaint is required by the 60 day deadline, so is nothing unusual. Alternatively, AUSA could file a motion to extend or a motion to dismiss or remand. You are right; because an answer doesn't require a reply, you don't have to file anything, but you should be prepared to oppose a motion to dismiss or remand which may come any time or more likely, a hearing (preceded by an initial case management conference or something like this). If there will be a hearing, you will need to defend your claims, essentially to explain to the judge why defendants affirmative defenses are incorrect and why your claims are valid.

This scenario (i.e, heading for a hearing or some dispositive motion) will be more frequent, people will not get their case solved like before, when the expedited name check was automatically triggered by the lawsuit. But you should not be worried; the law is on your side, you just need to be well prepared and defend your case vigurously.

Do you guys think this new USCIS “no expedite” tactics requires some change in tactics on our side too? Would not it be more reasonable now to avoid any contacts with AUSA and, if the defendants happen to be oblivious to the existence of your lawsuit, file motion for default judgment immediately upon expiration of the 60-day deadline?

Best regards,
snorlax

 

[paz1960]

Before 12/22/06, Was expedite name check initiated by AUSA or USCIS?
To make it more narrow - was assigned to case AUSA requirement for expedite name check?
Thanks

From discussions I had with the AUSA assigned to my case, seems that DHS/USCIS Office of General Counsel initiates the expedited name check procedure, but AUSA didn't give much details, he was mostly listening what I wanted to present him.

 

[paz1960]

Do you guys think this new USCIS “no expedite” tactics requires some change in tactics on our side too? Would not it be more reasonable now to avoid any contacts with AUSA and, if the defendants happen to be oblivious to the existence of your lawsuit, file motion for default judgment immediately upon expiration of the 60-day deadline?

Best regards,
snorlax

First, it is extremly unlikely that AUSA is not filing something before the deadline. It happened in some cases, but even is such situation is unlikely that you can win by default judgement. See post #7783 and the previous post with NameCheck2.0' s experience with this.

Second, I still believe that it is not a bad idea to establish good contact with AUSA, however, I admit, it is less likely that now this can help you a lot. But if there is a hearing in your case, it is still better to have an AUSA who maybe is sympathetic to your case than a complete stranger. But these are all speculations, we will need to wait and see, how these cases will evolve with the changed 'game rules'.

 

[gmlvsk]

But it would be nice to have good examples of opposition to motion to dismiss and other kinds of standard answers that AUSA give posted here. Does anybody have case numbers?

 

[DUDE12190]

Do you guys think this new USCIS “no expedite” tactics requires some change in tactics on our side too? Would not it be more reasonable now to avoid any contacts with AUSA and, if the defendants happen to be oblivious to the existence of your lawsuit, file motion for default judgment immediately upon expiration of the 60-day deadline?

Best regards,
snorlax

there was a very good thread that i was reading from last year. they were saying that even you file a motion for default judgment, the judge is not going to do anyting until he hears something from AUSA. Most of the time, AUSA will get back to the court because they have to do it. Hope this is helpful. I, HOWEVER, DO AGREE WITH YOU TAHT IF AUSA DO NOT GET BACK TO YOU, WE SHOULD DO SOMETHING. AS YOU KNOW, AUSA MAY HAVE A LOT OF CASES ASSINGED TO HIM/HER; THEREFORE, WE ALSO HAVE TO KEEP CONTACTING THEM TO FIND OUT IF THEY ARE WORKING ON THE CASE OR NOT. YOU CAN EXPECT ANYTHING UGLY AND/OR NASTY FROM THEM BECAUSE THEY JUST DO NOT CARE. IT IS TOO TRUE!! SO PLEASE MY DEAR, FOLLOW UP WITH YOUR CASE. BEST OF LUCK TO YOU!!! BEST REGARDS, DUDE
here is my info

N400 applied: March 2004
first fp : july 2004
interview: may 2005 (passed everything, but n400 still pending because of stupid security clearnce)
seconed fp: Oct 2005
Preparing to file 1447b in the district court very soon

Tahnk you all. Please keep up the good work

 

[paz1960]

But it would be nice to have good examples of opposition to motion to dismiss and other kinds of standard answers that AUSA give posted here. Does anybody have case numbers?

There were a lot of examples posted previously on this forum. You just need to have patience and read through the postings.

 

[junzhe]

One think you should be aware of. Since December 22, 2006 seems that USCIS is not requesting automatically an expedited name check process from FBI, when a lawsuit is filed against them. This means that most likely, you will need to go further with the whole lawsuit, probably be able to oppose a motion to dismiss or remand, or to go to a hearing in front of the judge and defend your claims. If you feel uncomfortable with this, you should consider the option of hiring an experienced immigration lawyer.

paz,
How was an expedited name check automatically trigger by the law suit before 12/22/06? I'm asking because I filed my 1447b case on 12/12 (US attorney served at the same day). It was holiday season, if AUSA did not start to work on my case until some time after 12/22 (notice of appearance was filed on 12/27), does it mean my name check will not be expedited automatically due to the new policy? I had a hard time to get hold of the AUSA. I have no idea what's the status of my case. Thanks.

 

[paz1960]

paz,
How was an expedited name check automatically trigger by the law suit before 12/22/06? I'm asking because I filed my 1447b case on 12/12 (US attorney served at the same day). It was holiday season, if AUSA did not start to work on my case until some time after 12/22 (notice of appearance was filed on 12/27), does it mean my name check will not be expedited automatically due to the new policy? I had a hard time to get hold of the AUSA. I have no idea what's the status of my case. Thanks.

Unfortunately, I don't know the answer to your question. All what I heard from AUSA assigned to my case when I had an 'in person' meeting with him, that DHS/USCIS already requested an expedited processing of my name check. I believe that when the Office of General Counsel in DHS/USCIS got the copy of the complaint and the summons and somebody actually looked to the case (probably only several days after the mail arrived) they initiated with FBI the expedite. But I'm just guessing...

At this stage I would insist to get a hold on AUSA, because most likely (s)he is the only person who can provide you some info about the status of your case.

 

[kefira]

there was a very good thread that i was reading from last year. they were saying that even you file a motion for default judgment, the judge is not going to do anyting until he hears something from AUSA. Most of the time, AUSA will get back to the court because they have to do it. Hope this is helpful. I, HOWEVER, DO AGREE WITH YOU TAHT IF AUSA DO NOT GET BACK TO YOU, WE SHOULD DO SOMETHING. AS YOU KNOW, AUSA MAY HAVE A LOT OF CASES ASSINGED TO HIM/HER; THEREFORE, WE ALSO HAVE TO KEEP CONTACTING THEM TO FIND OUT IF THEY ARE WORKING ON THE CASE OR NOT. YOU CAN EXPECT ANYTHING UGLY AND/OR NASTY FROM THEM BECAUSE THEY JUST DO NOT CARE. IT IS TOO TRUE!! SO PLEASE MY DEAR, FOLLOW UP WITH YOUR CASE. BEST OF LUCK TO YOU!!! BEST REGARDS, DUDE
here is my info

N400 applied: March 2004
first fp : july 2004
interview: may 2005 (passed everything, but n400 still pending because of stupid security clearnce)
seconed fp: Oct 2005
Preparing to file 1447b in the district court very soon

Tahnk you all. Please keep up the good work

I am in the same situation. I filed my WOM on Oct 30, 2006 and my AUSA told me that FBI no longer expedite name checks. This is funny, since other people who filed after me, received their GC in 30 day period. AUSA replyed with the answer to dismiss my case. On Jan 18 I am going to meet with her and with Judge and I will need to say something, that I already said in my WOM. Only one additional detail, that now I am pregnant and all this stress is not favorable to me. I filed ProSe in San Francsico.

 

[wenlock]

Pacer

If you look into pacer and search lawsuit for 890 or 540 against "Chertoff" as party name you will see how many cases are open and close.

If you see right now most of the cases filled in OCT 1st and Oct 31st are getting closed. I am assuming they got resolved that is the reason for closing case. I looked at few of these cases and they all looked got resolved.

I see very few cases those got resolved During month of Nov. It looks like currently cases filled in Oct are getting attention. Cases filled in Nov are still getting processed.

This will give you some idea based on statistics when case can get resolved. It looks like the one filed in Nov will take another month or so to get attention. Similarly following months will be little late.

It looks like information posted on one lawyers website is correct based on his analysis before it use to take less time for these cases to resolve but due to increasing number of these types of cases it is taking longer and longer now.

 

[needsolution]

It was meant to be sarcastic? WHat is the reason for such questioning. Last i checked we are hear to support each other and the cause and NOT to question a mere phrase ?

I apologize, I didn't realize that you were being sarcastic and that is why I didnt understand it.

 

[needsolution]

It was meant to be sarcastic? WHat is the reason for such questioning. Last i checked we are hear to support each other and the cause and NOT to question a mere phrase ?

I apologize, I didn't realize that you were being sarcastic and that is why I didnt understand it.

 

[paz1960]

I apologize, I didn't realize that you were being sarcastic and that is why I didnt understand it.

Hi needsolution,
Can you free up some space in your INBOX in the PM section? I tried to send you a PM but bounced back because your inbox is full.

 

[paz1960]

If you look into pacer and search lawsuit for 890 or 540 against "Chertoff" as party name you will see how many cases are open and close.

If you see right now most of the cases filled in OCT 1st and Oct 31st are getting closed. I am assuming they got resolved that is the reason for closing case. I looked at few of these cases and they all looked got resolved.

I see very few cases those got resolved During month of Nov. It looks like currently cases filled in Oct are getting attention. Cases filled in Nov are still getting processed.

This will give you some idea based on statistics when case can get resolved. It looks like the one filed in Nov will take another month or so to get attention. Similarly following months will be little late.

It looks like information posted on one lawyers website is correct based on his analysis before it use to take less time for these cases to resolve but due to increasing number of these types of cases it is taking longer and longer now.

This is an interesting observation (especially for guys like me, who filed on October 24). Is this based on a particular district or valid more generally?

 

[kefira]

If you see right now most of the cases filled in OCT 1st and Oct 31st are getting closed. I am assuming they got resolved that is the reason for closing case. I looked at few of these cases and they all looked got resolved.

It looks like information posted on one lawyers website is correct based on his analysis before it use to take less time for these cases to resolve but due to increasing number of these types of cases it is taking longer and longer now.

This is NOT true. I filed Oct 30 in San Francisco, and we basically do not have any other WOM case. And AUSA told me that nobody will now expedite name check and on Jan 18 I am meeting with the judge and AUSA. If my case will be closed, then I can do nothing about it. I am stack in name check since March 2005, marriage base GC

 

[DUDE12190]

Hi Team,
Just for your info. This afternoon I sent the same reply to one of the forum member.
I recently spoke to one of my friend who filed WoM in Los Angeles area through an attorney. I asked him to find out the story behind “No More Expedite”. He said that attorney told him that, it use to be when a law suit filed CIS ask FBI to expedite name check. But now CIS is not doing this, instead waiting for the outcome of the law suit, if judge is remanding with specific instruction then they are asking FBI to expedite the check otherwise nothing. I think it make sense, if you look at the cases, very few cases were remand back to CIS with specific instruction. Also, if you look at the pattern most of the cases were resolved before going to the judge or during initial stages. So, I guess CIS learned that these bios judges would not do any harm to a government agency. I am very depressed with this entire situation because in my district judges are remanding without any specific instruction. I will file suit in very near future and suggest you to go ahead and do the same, if we will loose, we will loose only about $400.00.

Keep in touch and thank you.

acn you tell me which state are you in? I am preparing to file in new york city.best of luck to you!!!

 

[DUDE12190]

update:

My 2nd FP was done two weeks ago and was also told by infopass that name check cleared and evertyhing was in order for process. was anxious and then called the NSC this morning, but was very disappointed with the answer.
I was told it is still "in process" for both USCIS and FBI and name check was not cleared!!! The lady told me they and me (they send/forward) should get "name check cleared notice" if FBI finishes the job. this is the first time that I heard CIS would send applicants notice if name check cleared. Anybody had similar experience before?
Now I am so disappointed today since I need this D*** card to move ahead to accept my new job with better opportunity and 50% pay rise. I don't know who is telling the truth, the infopass or the NSC.

do not believe those idiots at VSC. I would wait and put another infopass inquiry or ask your congressman . best of luck!!!

 

[wenlock]

This is NOT true. I filed Oct 30 in San Francisco, and we basically do not have any other WOM case. And AUSA told me that nobody will now expedite name check and on Jan 18 I am meeting with the judge and AUSA. If my case will be closed, then I can do nothing about it. I am stack in name check since March 2005, marriage base GC

If you do not believe me here are all the cases from all Districts between Oct 1st till Oct 31st

Name Court Case No. Filed NOS Closed

CHERTOFF, MICHAEL txsdce 4:2006cv03214 10/11/2006 890 11/29/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL dcdce 1:2005cv00201 10/11/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ctdce 3:2006cv01592 10/11/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL paedce 2:2006cv04536 10/11/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05534 10/11/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06344 10/11/2006 890 11/22/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 4:2006cv06363 10/11/2006 890 11/13/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL casdce 3:2006cv02283 10/11/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wawdce 2:2006cv01474 10/11/2006 890 01/03/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wawdce 2:2006cv01478 10/11/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wawdce 2:2006cv01479 10/11/2006 890 11/07/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wawdce 2:2006cv01480 10/11/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wawdce 2:2006cv01481 10/11/2006 890 12/12/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11843 10/11/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nyedce 1:2006cv05578 10/11/2006 890 10/31/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06445 10/11/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06447 10/11/2006 890 12/28/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06450 10/11/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06451 10/11/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06452 10/11/2006 890 11/29/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06453 10/11/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06454 10/11/2006 890 11/03/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06456 10/11/2006 890 12/22/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06464 10/11/2006 890 12/01/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL pawdce 2:2006cv01351 10/10/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06342 10/10/2006 890 01/10/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06317 10/10/2006 890 12/15/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilcdce 2:2006cv02198 10/10/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05475 10/10/2006 890 12/04/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ohndce 4:2006cv02437 10/10/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ohndce 5:2006cv02438 10/10/2006 890 12/05/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06324 10/10/2006 890 12/18/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wawdce 2:2006cv01458 10/10/2006 890 12/12/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL txndce 3:2006cv01843 10/10/2006 890 12/18/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL kyedce 5:2006cv00335 10/10/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL mddce 8:2006cv02675 10/10/2006 890 12/21/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06329 10/10/2006 890 11/15/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL casdce 3:2006cv02268 10/10/2006 890 12/01/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wiedce 1:2006cv01055 10/10/2006 890 12/21/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05468 10/10/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL njdce 2:2006cv04856 10/10/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wawdce 2:2006cv01470 10/10/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 5:2006cv01112 10/10/2006 890 11/14/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06417 10/10/2006 890 11/20/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06330 10/10/2006 890 11/30/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06353 10/11/2006 890 11/29/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06835 10/26/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06842 10/26/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05698 10/20/2006 890 01/09/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05712 10/20/2006 890 12/07/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nyedce 1:2006cv05714 10/20/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL njdce 2:2006cv05052 10/20/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05711 10/20/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06574 10/20/2006 890 01/09/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06688 10/20/2006 890 12/11/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06689 10/20/2006 890 12/08/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wiwdc 3:2006cv00605 10/20/2006 890 01/05/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 4:2006cv40225 10/23/2006 890 12/14/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06600 10/23/2006 890 12/21/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL txndce 4:2006cv00746 10/23/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11932 10/23/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL njdce 2:2006cv05076 10/23/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL paedce 2:2006cv04740 10/23/2006 890 11/24/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06589 10/23/2006 890 12/01/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05742 10/23/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wawdce 2:2006cv01522 10/23/2006 890 01/09/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11926 10/23/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11927 10/23/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06723 10/23/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ncwdce 3:2006cv00440 10/24/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL paedce 2:2006cv04599 10/16/2006 890 01/04/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL mddce 1:2006cv02713 10/16/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06428 10/16/2006 890 12/05/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL txsdce 4:2006cv03269 10/16/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11876 10/16/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06461 10/16/2006 890 12/18/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06431 10/16/2006 890 11/20/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL miedce 2:2006cv14525 10/16/2006 890 01/09/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06463 10/16/2006 890 12/08/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06462 10/16/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 4:2006cv06426 10/16/2006 890 11/16/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL paedce 2:2006cv04631 10/17/2006 890 12/11/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL caedce 1:2006cv01450 10/17/2006 890 12/20/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nvdce 2:2006cv01301 10/17/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL okwdce 5:2006cv01139 10/17/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL dcdce 1:2006cv01776 10/17/2006 890 12/27/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL caedce 1:2006cv01451 10/17/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL caedce 1:2006cv01452 10/17/2006 890 11/13/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL caedce 1:2006cv01461 10/17/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ctdce 3:2006cv01634 10/17/2006 890 11/08/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL casdce 3:2006cv02310 10/17/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05626 10/17/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL tnmdce 3:2006cv01004 10/17/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ordce 3:2006cv01458 10/17/2006 890 01/10/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL mddce 1:2006cv02756 10/19/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ohndce 5:2006cv02525 10/19/2006 890 12/14/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL okwdce 5:2006cv01153 10/19/2006 890 12/18/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nyedce 1:2006cv05659 10/19/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nyedce 2:2006cv05667 10/19/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11909 10/19/2006 890 11/01/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nysdce 1:2006cv09937 10/19/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nysdce 1:2006cv10164 10/19/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06668 10/19/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL casdce 3:2006cv02332 10/19/2006 890 11/27/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL casdce 3:2006cv02333 10/19/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 4:2006cv06547 10/19/2006 890 11/22/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nyedce 1:2006cv05687 10/20/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL njdce 3:2006cv05034 10/20/2006 890 01/03/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL caedce 1:2006cv01470 10/20/2006 890 12/20/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL azdce 4:2006cv00536 10/20/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wawdce 2:2006cv01518 10/20/2006 890 12/12/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL gamdce 1:2006cv00139 10/20/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11919 10/20/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL lamdce 3:2006cv00821 10/20/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL casdce 3:2006cv02341 10/20/2006 890 12/18/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05713 10/20/2006 890 01/09/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05714 10/20/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05628 10/17/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05640 10/17/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11906 10/17/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 5:2006cv01146 10/17/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06498 10/17/2006 890 11/20/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL flsdce 1:2006cv22558 10/17/2006 890 01/10/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06504 10/18/2006 890 11/13/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL inndce 1:2006cv00346 10/18/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ohndce 3:2006cv02523 10/18/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ohsdce 1:2006cv00692 10/18/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL tnwdce 2:2006cv02694 10/18/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ncmdce 1:2006cv00910 10/18/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ordce 3:2006cv01469 10/18/2006 890 01/12/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ordce 3:2006cv01470 10/18/2006 890 11/30/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL vaedce 1:2006cv01172 10/18/2006 890 12/21/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL flmdce 8:2006cv02033 11/01/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ohndce 1:2006cv02646 11/01/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL mddce 8:2006cv02879 11/01/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL caedce 2:2006cv02428 11/01/2006 890 01/08/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05935 11/01/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05937 11/01/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv12000 11/01/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL casdce 3:2006cv02413 11/01/2006 890 12/15/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL casdce 3:2006cv02418 11/01/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ordce 3:2006cv01556 11/01/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 4:2006cv06802 11/01/2006 890 01/03/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06967 11/01/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06977 11/01/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06983 11/01/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL mddce 8:2006cv02833 10/27/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL mddce 8:2006cv02841 10/27/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHEAL njdce 2:2006cv05173 10/27/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL casdce 3:2006cv02381 10/27/2006 890 01/05/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06686 10/27/2006 890 01/11/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06711 10/27/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06723 10/27/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06721 10/27/2006 890 12/13/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL txedce 4:2006cv00407 10/03/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL txedce 4:2006cv00410 10/03/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11793 10/03/2006 890 12/06/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06300 10/03/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06309 10/03/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06307 10/03/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL flsdce 1:2006cv22497 10/03/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06252 10/04/2006 890 12/06/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ctdce 3:2006cv01558 10/04/2006 890 11/03/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06249 10/04/2006 890 12/18/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ohndce 1:2006cv02397 10/04/2006 890 11/21/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL casdce 3:2006cv02220 10/05/2006 890 12/08/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05358 10/05/2006 890 01/04/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL mddce 8:2006cv02621 10/05/2006 890 11/28/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05414 10/05/2006 890 12/05/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ctdce 3:2006cv01695 10/25/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL miedce 2:2006cv14816 10/25/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL miedce 2:2006cv14827 10/25/2006 890 01/08/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL caedce 1:2006cv01501 10/25/2006 890 12/04/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06635 10/25/2006 890 12/07/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL txsdce 4:2006cv03371 10/25/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wawdce 2:2006cv01534 10/25/2006 890 12/20/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nysdce 1:2006cv11365 10/25/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL casdce 3:2006cv02366 10/25/2006 890 01/04/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ordce 6:2006cv06250 10/12/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06391 10/12/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nyedce 2:2006cv05526 10/12/2006 890 11/07/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nyedce 1:2006cv05534 10/12/2006 890 12/28/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL tnedce 1:2006cv00219 10/12/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06494 10/12/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06497 10/12/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL flsdce 1:2006cv22532 10/12/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL paedce 2:2006cv04574 10/13/2006 890 11/21/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ohsdce 2:2006cv00866 10/13/2006 890 12/13/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL txndce 4:2006cv00719 10/13/2006 890 11/14/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL txndce 3:2006cv01877 10/13/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL okwdce 5:2006cv01126 10/13/2006 890 12/08/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wawdce 2:2006cv01491 10/13/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 4:2006cv06394 10/13/2006 890 11/28/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06528 10/13/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06534 10/13/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06555 10/13/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL flmdce 6:2006cv01684 10/30/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL vawdce 7:2006cv00650 10/30/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06742 10/30/2006 890 11/16/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06743 10/30/2006 890 12/12/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06922 10/30/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL kywdce 1:2006cv00174 10/31/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ncedce 5:2006cv00398 10/05/2006 890 11/07/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL caedce 1:2006cv01386 10/05/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL moedce 4:2006cv01462 10/05/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11806 10/05/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL njdce 2:2006cv04792 10/05/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL casdce 3:2006cv02190 10/05/2006 890 12/19/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nyedce 1:2006cv05428 10/05/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHEAL njdce 2:2006cv04789 10/05/2006 890 01/03/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wiwdc 3:2006cv00569 10/05/2006 890 12/12/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11814 10/06/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11813 10/06/2006 890 12/20/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL vaedce 1:2006cv01131 10/06/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06302 10/06/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ohndce 1:2006cv02420 10/06/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL vaedce 1:2006cv01130 10/06/2006 890 12/18/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nysdce 1:2006cv08188 10/06/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05436 10/06/2006 890 12/08/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05434 10/06/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL txwdce 1:2006cv00816 10/06/2006 890 11/21/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL azdce 4:2006cv00517 10/06/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nyedce 1:2006cv05447 10/06/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06370 10/06/2006 890 11/29/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ctdce 3:2006cv01699 10/26/2006 890 12/06/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ohndce 1:2006cv02599 10/26/2006 890 11/28/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL mddce 8:2006cv02576 10/02/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL okwdce 5:2006cv01074 10/02/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL okwdce 5:2006cv01077 10/02/2006 890 10/23/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL paedce 2:2006cv04383 10/02/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05330 10/02/2006 890 12/04/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL txwdce 1:2006cv00793 10/02/2006 890 01/10/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wiedce 2:2006cv01029 10/02/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05345 10/02/2006 890 12/19/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05331 10/02/2006 890 12/19/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06155 10/02/2006 890 12/11/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL flndce 1:2006cv00197 10/02/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11783 10/02/2006 890 11/14/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06286 10/02/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06287 10/02/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL flsdce 1:2006cv22470 10/02/2006 890 11/13/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHEAL njdce 2:2006cv04781 10/03/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL txsdce 4:2006cv03094 10/03/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL utdce 2:2006cv00841 10/03/2006 890 11/09/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wawdce 2:2006cv01432 10/03/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL mtdce 9:2006cv00156 10/03/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06229 10/03/2006 890 11/21/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 4:2006cv06228 10/03/2006 890 11/13/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL casdce 3:2006cv02346 10/24/2006 890 12/21/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL mndce 0:2006cv04271 10/24/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05806 10/25/2006 890 01/09/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nysdce 1:2006cv11385 10/25/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL caedce 2:2006cv02395 10/31/2006 890 12/11/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06749 10/31/2006 890 01/11/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL azdce 4:2006cv00548 10/31/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11994 10/31/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL gandce 1:2006cv02641 10/31/2006 890 12/28/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL casdce 3:2006cv02402 10/31/2006 890 11/17/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06751 10/31/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06941 10/31/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06938 10/31/2006 890 01/03/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06942 10/31/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06944 10/31/2006 890 01/08/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL vawdce 3:2006cv00059 10/26/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06657 10/26/2006 890 12/07/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilcdce 1:2006cv01270 10/26/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL txsdce 3:2006cv00668 10/26/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05828 10/26/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05827 10/26/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05816 10/26/2006 890 01/09/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ctdce 3:2006cv01698 10/26/2006 890 11/16/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL gandce 1:2006cv02597 10/26/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 5:2006cv06666 10/26/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL okwdce 5:2006cv01191 10/26/2006 890 12/13/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL moedce 4:2006cv01568 10/26/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL moedce 4:2006cv01569 10/26/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06474 10/11/2006 890 12/08/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL flsdce 1:2006cv22515 10/11/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05549 10/12/2006 890 11/15/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05550 10/12/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nyedce 1:2006cv05531 10/12/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL nyedce 1:2006cv05541 10/12/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL mddce 1:2006cv02698 10/12/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL wawdce 2:2006cv01553 10/27/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL gandce 1:2006cv02612 10/27/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL vaedce 1:2006cv01211 10/27/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL vaedce 1:2006cv01216 10/27/2006 890 12/22/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL vaedce 1:2006cv01214 10/27/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05846 10/27/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06859 10/27/2006 890 12/05/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06861 10/27/2006 890 12/19/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06882 10/27/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11976 10/30/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ohndce 1:2006cv02619 10/30/2006 890 11/30/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL candce 3:2006cv06724 10/30/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL codce 1:2006cv02123 10/24/2006 890 11/30/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL insdce 1:2006cv01555 10/24/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05768 10/24/2006 890 12/28/2006
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL madce 1:2006cv11939 10/24/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL ilndce 1:2006cv05782 10/24/2006 890 01/08/2007
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL miwdce 5:2006cv00167 10/24/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06774 10/24/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06772 10/24/2006 890
CHERTOFF, MICHAEL cacdce 2:2006cv06764 10/24/2006 890 12/08/2006