SF asking Documents one cant provide

G

ginnu

Registered Users (C)
How one can give Color copy of Green Card ?it is illegal to make Color copy of Green Card. One surrenders the Green Card at time of Naturalization/Oath.
EAD and I-94 is taken away if one got approved for GC through local USCIS office.
I-130 petition is filed by Relatives through lawyer or directly and many don’t keep the copy of full I-130 petition.
One can get Domicile Certificate from Collector office if one is Indian Citizen. How one can get domicile certificate when person is US citizen?
Ration Card: May be old ration Card because once you are US citizen one is not eligible for Ration card.
Voter ID card: Many don’t have India Voter ID cards and even if they have that may have incorrect spelling of name and once the person is US citizen he cannot get Voter ID card and it is illegal.

It seems that this all is to make sure that one was Indian citizen and it is due to security reasons as Pakistani and Indians look same. It is good to have security check but the documents they ask may not be available to all and more problem for OCI.
 
But Ginnu this is being asked in point 4 in the website. Point 5 also asks for Indian passport (or affidavit etc.). How can they confuse Indian and Pakistani passport?
 
sanjoseaug20 said:
But Ginnu this is being asked in point 4 in the website. Point 5 also asks for Indian passport (or affidavit etc.).
How can they confuse Indian and Pakistani passport?
------------------ Because they are confused and don’t know what proper documents should be asked. Do you know in Mumbai about 85Lac illegal Bangladeshi are staying? Many from Bangladesh enter illegally in India then get Ration Card (by giving bribe) then on the base of Ration card get name in Voter list and get Voter ID card then Indian passport, who knows how many Pakistani have Indian passport the same way. During cricket Match in Mohali,India about 4-5 years back many from Pakistan entered on Visa and still not departed India and nobody knows where they are staying in India. Who knows those Pakistani also got the Indian passports by the same way Bangladeshi gets the documents.
Click to expand...
---------------------
 
It still does not make sense since your original I-130 (or whatever it is) will not prove anything.
The only differentiating factor I see is whether you are asylum case or not.

Let's forget my theory and any theory you might have.
Based on the list of documents they are asking - what major difference is there between a person who can provide it, and a person who can not or will not provide it?
 
Asylum angle seems to be the best explanation at this time for this bizarre requirement. An Asylum seeker will have his passport stamped when he enters US for the first time and this might be a big issue with Indian government. They might want to disqualify even those who just applied for asylum.
 
sanjoseaug20 said:
It still does not make sense since your original I-130 (or whatever it is) will not prove anything.


----- It seems that this all is to make sure that one was Indian citizen and it is due to security reasons as Pakistani and Indians look same. It is good to have security check but the documents they ask may not be available to all and more problem for OCI.
The asked I-130 petition because one has to attach the Documents of relationship with the Petitioner. If you file for your spouse then you will attach copy of marriage certificate, Spouse Birth certificate. If file for parents you have to provide evidence of relationship that include that you were born to your mother ABCD and mother gets immigrant visa from US consulate and she has to provide Police clearance from Passport office and Local Police station, copy of her Birth certificate. They asked I-130 petition because petition will have all the documents attached but they don’t know that through FOIA it takes 6 months to Year for getting copy of Petition. it may be for asylum case and at this time one does not know why they started asking the above documents. we Dont have any GR from Ministry of external affairs or Ministry of Home affairs. Any Indian Citizen should get the information through RTI Act and then only we can know why they started asking more documents
The only differentiating factor I see is whether you are asylum case or not.
--------------May be
Let's forget my theory and any theory you might have.
Based on the list of documents they are asking - what major difference is there between a person who can provide it, and a person who can not or will not provide it?

------I think those who cant provide it may not get OCI or PIO or Visa. Let us wait.
Those who are facing problems should contact Newspaper editors in India and journalist can get the information from Ministry of Home Affairs or Ministry of External Affairs.
They should also send letters to Minter of External affairs and Minister of Home Affairs and Secretaries and to under secretaries in India
Click to expand...
---------------
 
nkm-oct23 said:
Asylum angle seems to be the best explanation

-----------------------When OCI rule was made in 2005 did that rule say anything about people who got Asylum in USA or Canada that they will not get OCI or PIO? The OCI requirement is if you were Indian citizen or your parents were Indian Citizen or grandparents were Indian Citizen. Please read the OCI rule. http://www.mha.nic.in/pdfs/intro.pdf
http://www.mha.nic.in/pdfs/oci-brochure.pdf
at this time for this bizarre requirement. An Asylum seeker will have his passport stamped when he enters US for the first time and this might be a big issue with Indian government. They might want to disqualify even those who just applied for asylum
------Any good Indian lawyer can challenge them through Supreme Court of India to clear the requirements for OCI and now why they are asking for the documents that are not with applicants.

.
Click to expand...
--------------Asylum seeker does not mean he/she has shown disaffection towards constitution of India. Asylum seeker does not mean that he/she helped the enemy of India with whom India has or had war. Most of are innocent and have respect of Indian constitution and have nothing done against India they just wanted to settle in USA or Canada or UK


http://www.mha.nic.in/pdfs/1955.pdf
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top