N-400 in process but Spouse I-539 denial on wrong grounds?

PR81502

Registered Users (C)
My spouse is a foreign medical student and requested an extension based on 9 FAM 41.1 N 10.4-1 Medical. This allows students to do their clerkship in the US(rotating in hospital without renumerartion). A cover leter was sent explaining the reason for the I-539; a letter from the medical school and the original I-94. The original I-94 was not returned, luckily we made copies.

Yet the USCIS denies the request based on the following.
1. Section 101(a)(15)(B).
2. 8 C.F.R & 103.2(b)(1) evidence and processing: the reason for your request; why your extended stay would be temporary,including what arrangements you have made to depart the US and any effect the extended stay would have on your foreign employment or residency. In this regard, the applicant has not provided a statement or other documentation showing temporary nature of the proposed stay. The records reveal that the applicant has a pending I-130.
3. The final issue to be discussed is the requirement that applicants have sufficient financial resources to support themselves for the proposed period of stay.

My issues with USCIS:
1. It seems the evidence sent to them after the on-line part of the I-539 was completed was not taken into consideration or they never got the evidence.
2. Its decision is based because there is an I-130 pending.(that was indicated when the I-539 was filled on-line).
3. Would someone be in medical school and not have money to support himself/herself?
4. If they got the initial evidence then they got rid of it or lost it.

And to add insult to injury USCIS indicates my spouse has 30 days to leave or be subject to removal proceedings without any recognition to the person's need to complete their clinical rotations.

What are our options? a motion to reopen or re-send the evidence again since they are famous for losing evidence? Is the visa now void?

I also have an N-400 pending awaiting interview letter and interview date. Is it better to complete the clinical rotations while my N-400 is in process? What are the chances USCIS will come after my spouse after the 30 days as stated in the letter(a few days ago)?


Thanks.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
My personal opinion with regards to I-539s is always solidifed by hearing stories like this. I-539 should be filed for life/death emergencies only. Extending a stay to take exams, attend a wedding or a birthday party are too flimsy. All of these can be addressed by a better timed initial entry. In my opinion your spouse should leave the US and await your CP based green card. You spouse can also ignore the notice, overstay and get a green card based on AOS. It is your call to make.

What are our options? a motion to reopen or re-send the evidence again since they are famous for losing evidence? Is the visa now void?
 
you are almost there to get your citizenship i hope.as Tripple indicated it is your call to make decision.but i think she can stay here a few more months then you can apply for AOS.
how long did it take them to process your wifes application.?
After denial how long she can stay here more.?
 
you are almost there to get your citizenship i hope.as Tripple indicated it is your call to make decision.but i think she can stay here a few more months then you can apply for AOS.
how long did it take them to process your wifes application.?
After denial how long she can stay here more.?

They took 3.5 months to process the application. They gave her 30 days after denial date, but she is well within the 180 days. She applied about 2 months before I-94 expired.
 
They took 3.5 months to process the application. They gave her 30 days after denial date, but she is well within the 180 days. She applied about 2 months before I-94 expired.

well i am in same situation you are.My father was given only 3 months of visitor visa and unfortunately we applied only 20 days before I-94 expiration date.since he didint have 6 months of i 94.
could you please explain how she can stay 180 days after denial.
She is given only 30 days to leave.
Thanks again
i am also waiting my oath letter
 
well i am in same situation you are.My father was given only 3 months of visitor visa and unfortunately we applied only 20 days before I-94 expiration date.since he didint have 6 months of i 94.
could you please explain how she can stay 180 days after denial.
She is given only 30 days to leave.
Thanks again
i am also waiting my oath letter

> 180 days overstay trigers the 3 years ban anytime the leaves the US. > 1 year trigers a 10 years ban.

Has your dad I-539 been denied or is it still pending?
 
> 180 days overstay trigers the 3 years ban anytime the leaves the US. > 1 year trigers a 10 years ban.

Has your dad I-539 been denied or is it still pending?
we sent it out recently.i havent received receipt notice yet
we hope to gain some time and may be i would get my oath in a few months.
what do you think PR81502, if he stay over for afew months.would they be after him for being out of status?
what is oyur plan for your wife?
 
we sent it out recently.i havent received receipt notice yet
we hope to gain some time and may be i would get my oath in a few months.
what do you think PR81502, if he stay over for afew months.would they be after him for being out of status?
what is oyur plan for your wife?

You really cannot say how CIS will view it since he had only 3 months initially, but based on common opinion held by most folks his overstay will be forgiven when you become a citizen.
It also depends on the reason for the extension. As long as the extension request was not frivolous then any unlawful presence will start from date of decision if it is a denial per USCIS website. If his application is approved then he should be okay.
 
You really cannot say how CIS will view it since he had only 3 months initially, but based on common opinion held by most folks his overstay will be forgiven when you become a citizen.
It also depends on the reason for the extension. As long as the extension request was not frivolous then any unlawful presence will start from date of decision if it is a denial per USCIS website. If his application is approved then he should be okay.
pr8
they have just received my farther applicationand send us receipt number
we hope they dont make decision rightaway.i guess it takes 2-3 months to make final decision
 
They took 3.5 months to process the application. They gave her 30 days after denial date, but she is well within the 180 days. She applied about 2 months before I-94 expired.

USCIS is stating that your spouse has already filed an I-130. May I ask you on what grounds?

Also since you are in the process of US citizenship, I am going to move this thread to the US Citizenship Forum, I hope you don't mind !!! :D
 
Top