kadavath1967
Registered Users (C)
Hi All,
I received RFE today and the major 3 points that I wanted to stress on my EB-1 EA application got request for evidence. Out of the 10 areas I used the following 3 to file my petition. My application was filed on 08/18/03 and this RFE came in on 12/14/04. The areas are as follows:
(3) Published material about the alien in professional or major trade publications or other major media relating to the alien&s work in the field for which classification is sought. Such evidence shall include the title, date, and author of the material and any necessary translation.
The petitioner asserts that his discoveries have been alluded top professional journals. However, citation of the petitioner’s work does not establish that the articles in question are “about” the petitioner or his work. An alien cannot satisfy this criterion simply by establishing that his or her name has appeared in print. Citation of the work of others is expected and routine in the scientific community. The petitioner does not establish national or international acclaim by demonstrating that his or her work has been cited in print. The very fact that the work has been cited demonstrates that other scientists have found his or her research to be useful, but a scientist does not earn widespread a claim, simply by producing useful or valid results. The impact and implications of a scientist findings must be weighed, The record in this case by and large describes rather than evaluates the petitioner’s work:
Therefore, if addressed, submit evidence to establish title significance of the published material submitted about the alien’s work; and how it demonstrates international recognition for extraordinary achievement compared to others in the field of endeavor. Indicate the publication’s name, if it has local, national, or international circulation, how often it is printed and the number of copies printed.
Can I give copies of the publications where my works are cited? Will that be sufficient. I think the office who evaluated my petition disputes on a line of "name citation" and "adaption of work", am I right? How can I address this issue, beyond giving a copy of some of the publication cited my work?
(5) Evidence of the alien’s original scientific, scholarly artistic athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance in the field.
Provide further evidence to establish how the alien’s work is considered original and how it has made a major contribution of significance in his or her field of endeavor as compared Co all others in the field.
The regulatory criteria have been designed to provide objectively quantifiable factors to establish an alien’s degree of recognition. Eligibility resides with the alien and his or her individual accomplishments in the field of endeavor rather than wholly or primarily on the accomplishments of others. The petitioner must establish that he or she is one of the top Researchers in the field and this must be accompanied by evidence that the alien has sustained national or international acclaim and that his or her achievements have been recognized in the field of expertise.
What should I do here to satify the officer?
(6) Evidence of the aliens authorship of scholarly articles in the field in professional or major trade publications or other major media
Provide further evidence to establish the significance and importance of the alien’s scholarly articles in the field. Additionally, provide further evidence to establish the significance and importance of the professional or major trade publications or other major media that have published the alien's scholarly articles, Indicate if the publication has local, national; or international circulation, how often it is printed and the number of copies printed.
I had given all information I can when filed the petition. What further information I can give?
If any of you guys faced these kind of questions, please let me know how you answered, also please let me know the INS reply to it.
I would highly appreciate your help in this regard.
Best Regards
I received RFE today and the major 3 points that I wanted to stress on my EB-1 EA application got request for evidence. Out of the 10 areas I used the following 3 to file my petition. My application was filed on 08/18/03 and this RFE came in on 12/14/04. The areas are as follows:
(3) Published material about the alien in professional or major trade publications or other major media relating to the alien&s work in the field for which classification is sought. Such evidence shall include the title, date, and author of the material and any necessary translation.
The petitioner asserts that his discoveries have been alluded top professional journals. However, citation of the petitioner’s work does not establish that the articles in question are “about” the petitioner or his work. An alien cannot satisfy this criterion simply by establishing that his or her name has appeared in print. Citation of the work of others is expected and routine in the scientific community. The petitioner does not establish national or international acclaim by demonstrating that his or her work has been cited in print. The very fact that the work has been cited demonstrates that other scientists have found his or her research to be useful, but a scientist does not earn widespread a claim, simply by producing useful or valid results. The impact and implications of a scientist findings must be weighed, The record in this case by and large describes rather than evaluates the petitioner’s work:
Therefore, if addressed, submit evidence to establish title significance of the published material submitted about the alien’s work; and how it demonstrates international recognition for extraordinary achievement compared to others in the field of endeavor. Indicate the publication’s name, if it has local, national, or international circulation, how often it is printed and the number of copies printed.
Can I give copies of the publications where my works are cited? Will that be sufficient. I think the office who evaluated my petition disputes on a line of "name citation" and "adaption of work", am I right? How can I address this issue, beyond giving a copy of some of the publication cited my work?
(5) Evidence of the alien’s original scientific, scholarly artistic athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance in the field.
Provide further evidence to establish how the alien’s work is considered original and how it has made a major contribution of significance in his or her field of endeavor as compared Co all others in the field.
The regulatory criteria have been designed to provide objectively quantifiable factors to establish an alien’s degree of recognition. Eligibility resides with the alien and his or her individual accomplishments in the field of endeavor rather than wholly or primarily on the accomplishments of others. The petitioner must establish that he or she is one of the top Researchers in the field and this must be accompanied by evidence that the alien has sustained national or international acclaim and that his or her achievements have been recognized in the field of expertise.
What should I do here to satify the officer?
(6) Evidence of the aliens authorship of scholarly articles in the field in professional or major trade publications or other major media
Provide further evidence to establish the significance and importance of the alien’s scholarly articles in the field. Additionally, provide further evidence to establish the significance and importance of the professional or major trade publications or other major media that have published the alien's scholarly articles, Indicate if the publication has local, national; or international circulation, how often it is printed and the number of copies printed.
I had given all information I can when filed the petition. What further information I can give?
If any of you guys faced these kind of questions, please let me know how you answered, also please let me know the INS reply to it.
I would highly appreciate your help in this regard.
Best Regards