Dear Rajiv,
After 10 years of struggle finally I won complicated immigration case. I have couple questions regarding the court’s decision and interpretation by USCIS. Here is my timeline and brief background.
2007- I came to US on a B1/B2 visa.
2008- Married. Applied I 485 & I 130 with USCIS. Received conditional LPR
2009- Divorced and filled for I-751 with a waiver. Had interview in early 2010. My ex-wife complained USCIS that it was marriage fraud.
2012- My case was still pending.
2012- Remarried with current wife 3 years later the divorce from first wife.
2013- I-751 with waiver from first marriage denied based on marriage fraud and conditional LPR status is terminated. Received notice to appear (NTA) to immigration court.
2015- My current wife filled for I 130.
2016- I 130 from current wife is approved from USCIS. (USCIS didn’t had substantial evidence of marriage fraud expect testimony from my ex-wife)
2018- Applied for INA 237 a1h waiver and also I 485 based on approved I 130 at immigration court.
2018- Immigration Judge sustained marriage fraud charges. But gave me INA 237 a1 h wavier and also approved I 485 petition based on current marriage. (Adjustment of status)
2018- Took the decision to USCIS. USCIS gave my new LPR card with permanent resident since date 2018. (I was expecting they will retroactive my old card with 2008 original date since INA 237 a1h waiver was aproved)
According to the statue & case law, INA 237 a1h waiver retroactively validates permanent resident status from the original date (2008). Despite that USCIS gave me new permanent resident status from 2018. When I asked, they told me since I got both INA 237 a1h waiver & adjustment of status, the adjustment of status will trump and they will give new LPR status. (They didn’t show me any supporting documents on this)
I have couple questions for you. No one able to provide me an answer on this.
1. Is USCIS right on giving me new LPR card? OR they should gave me LPR status from initial date (2008)? If so, how do I convince USCIS to change the date?
2. Since marriage fraud charges are substantiated; am I going to have any problems while applying for N-400 in the future? (INA 237 a1h waiver is granted, i don't have any other immigration, civil or criminal convictions )