No to Depress Anybody

Any comments ?

If H1-B were created only to allow people work for 6 years and then go back to their country, why is their SSN contribution not returned upon their return or start withholding after GC is approved ?

Thoughts ?


Kmandy
 
Last edited by a moderator:
That is a gap between the tax laws and the INS policies! But, if a non-citizen decides to go back to his country, he can get his social security contribution back subject to the "40 quarter rule". Basically, if you are in this country for 10 years and have paid Social Security and if you decide to go back you can take the money with you.


This is what I have heard and remember reading something about the 40 quarter rule somewhere. Anyone with more details could elaborate.
 
Again !

Even if person is allowed to take SSN money with him/her after 10 years, what does it do good to H1-B person who is supposed to stay only for 6 years and then go back ?


KMANDY
 
As I mentioned in my previous post, this is a GAP!! I don't know what happens in the case of a person who is here for 6 years, leaves the country for a year and then comes back on H-1B for another 6 years!! Whether the 40 quarter rule stipulates a contiguous 40 quarters or there could be a break in it is something I don't know.

But, in any case, if a person stays only for 6 years and goes back for good, then tough luck for him/her. I think (again not so sure) if India has a comparable Social Security program (not that US's is any good) and it has some sort of a treaty with US then a person could get the contribution transferred back to India.

I haven't researched this thoroughly but this is how much I know/heard of.
 
Originally posted by Bombaywalla
This is the problem with so called immigration community who made America rich !

They get some education.....now they are educated degree holder smart people so they will not do anything else other than sitting infront of computer and argue over this relentleselly.

If asians were so smart why in the world they couldn't create the same system back home ? If the Asians were so smart they won't be logging here every half and hour to check the status of their GC ?

Asians are gold diggers , everyone wants to do easy stuff.....like getting bookie education etc etc instead of doing some extraordinary things like ordinary Americans do.

Basing on your username, it seems you're also an asian. Therefore, you're also a golddigger and all the shit you accuse asians of.

Asians are one of the hardest working ppl, the only problem is there are a few that don't understand why we are here, we contribute a lot to the success and prosperity of this nation.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It's ok ranniedv. Bombaywalla has had (and still does) some serious issues in life! That's why he behaves this way; please forgive him.
 
Top