I140 denied. Need Help
Dear Rajiv,
Thank you for your services to the immigration community. I would really appreciate your help.
o My I140&I485 under EB2 has been denied on 4/11/2008 because of generic wording used in Job description (Part 15) of certified labor.
The actual denial reason from USCIS notice:
“U.S. Department of Labor ETA form 750 submitted with form I-140 states, in Part 14, the position requires a Bachelor's Degree in Computer Science, Engineering, or related field, in combination with five years of experience. In part 15, the phrases "XXX (my company name) will accept a combination or experience, certificates, and education as equivalent to a bachelor's degree" appears, Unlike nonimmigrant petitions for temporary workers, employment-based immigrant petitions cannot make allowances to accept work experience, a combination of work experience and formal studies, or a series of certificates granted by different institutions for formal and/or informal study, when determining a beneficiary’s educational qualifications. As the labor certification accepts experience in lieu of a Degree; the offered position is not a job that requires a professional holding an advanced degree or the equivalent or an alien of exceptional ability. For this reason, the petition is denied. “
o My lawyer applied for a new I-140 under EB3 using the same labor on 4/28/2008.
Here are more details about my situation:
o My labor was applied in 03/2005 and approved in 06/2007. I got 4 years bachelor’s degree in engineering and 7 years of experience at the time of labor application.
o I-140, I-485, EAD & AP applied in 07/2007. EAD & AP were approved. But, not used.
o My current H1-B expires on 05/08/2008. Applied for 8th year extension based on pending I-140 in 03/2008 requesting 3 year extension. Upgraded my H1 to premium process on 4/30/08. Still, H1-B extension petition is in pending status.
Questions:
1. Should I appeal the I-140 denial decision? If yes, what kind of details should be provided and what are the chances?
2. What Should I do in case my petition for H1 extension gets rejected?
3. Please suggest if I have any other options based on my situation.
Thanks,
Prasad