Is the review report enough to show I have judged others\' work?

[jumhu]

I reviewed a paper one year ago. I still have the review report, but the letter from the journal is lost. Can I use the review report to show I have judged others\' work? By the way, that paper is published later. Thanks,

 

[leroythelion]

Evidence

Hi Jumhu,

I dealt with the review of submitted papers in my reference letters. I did not have the stuff from the journals so I could not submit them. I can\'t see why submitting the review would hurt...the letter from the journal would have been nice, though.

Look, don\'t take this the wrong way. Most of the people who read/post to this particular message board have only (thankfully) been through this process once. What each of did is going to be different. There is no right or wrong way to put the petition together. To answer your frequent "Is it enough..." questions is really impossible to answer without having all the facts of your case. Brian.

 

[jumhu]

Thanks anyway.

Someone may have experience on this. Somebody may have got this kind of question in RFE. I feel sorry bothering you. Thanks for your help anyway.

 

[fikabir]

Why don't you ask the editor for that letter! I did for myself.