I140 & 485 Approved after RFE on 140

vrmanda

Registered Users (C)
Hi Guys,

Finally I got mail from USCIS saying 140 & 485 has been approved.So March'04 Guys hang on there yours will be the next .....Below are my case details.

EB2
I140&485 Concurrent
140&485 RD 03/19/2004
RFE on 140 12/27/04(Education Evaluation)
RFE responded on 01/25/05
No LUD Changes
140&485 03/04/05 approved

Goodluck Guys.
 
congrats!

It is encouraging to see some approval after RFE. although 5 weeks is a little bit too long. Anyway, enjoy your freedom!
 
HI Vrmanda,

Congratulations!. I am also waiting for my I-140 RFE response.

EB-3.
I-140, 485 RD 1/30/04 (Concurent)
I-140 RFE(Ability to pay) 11/17/04 replied on 2/1/05 and received 2/4/05 LUD 2/10/05
After that no response, I don't know what happened after that.
 
Similar pattern in my case...

I140, 485 RD 7/9/04 (Pure Concurrent)
I140 RFE submitted on 1/18/05, LUDs on 1/26/05 and 2/01/05.
No response or LUD changes till now...


Naga1 said:
HI Vrmanda,

Congratulations!. I am also waiting for my I-140 RFE response.

EB-3.
I-140, 485 RD 1/30/04 (Concurent)
I-140 RFE(Ability to pay) 11/17/04 replied on 2/1/05 and received 2/4/05 LUD 2/10/05
After that no response, I don't know what happened after that.
 
Naga1 said:
HI Vrmanda,

Congratulations!. I am also waiting for my I-140 RFE response.

EB-3.
I-140, 485 RD 1/30/04 (Concurent)
I-140 RFE(Ability to pay) 11/17/04 replied on 2/1/05 and received 2/4/05 LUD 2/10/05
After that no response, I don't know what happened after that.


Just some guessing why it takes so long. For Ability to pay, like my RFE, they requested 2003 tax return of my employer with all tables and schedules attached. Does a immigration officer have any ability to assess those documents? I guess not. They have to assign this to sb who knows finance. then it takes 2 weeks to transfer, 3 weeks of review, another 2 weeks to transfer back. that is probably why it takes so long. that is why I strongly recommend the controller of my company to make a statement as an alternative for submitting tax return, but I don't know he is willing to do it.
 
Who knows how it works?

Congrats on getting it done in 5 weeks. I am going into my 11th week since they received my RFE response and no action.

They wanted evidence of 10 years higher education (on top of my PhD transcript) and evidence of ability to pay (from a major state university). Given I sent the required evidence it would seem a pretty simple case to clear.

I've just applied for new EADs for my wife and I. Any chance of getting the $350 back if the case is approved before the current EAD expires? :)


EB-2 Semi-concurrent
I-140 1/8/04
I-485 RD 3/17/04 ND 3/19/04 LUD 12/10/04
EAD/AP ND 3/19/04 Approved 5/2/04
FP 5/4/04
RFE (I-140) 11/9/04
RFE RD 12/21/04 LUD 12/22/04
 
stevphel said:
I've just applied for new EADs for my wife and I. Any chance of getting the $350 back if the case is approved before the current EAD expires? :)

Even if they approve your 485 before renewing your EADs, I don't think they would refund you that money (unless you are extremely lucky :) :) )
Who knows...if that happens with you, you have written history ;)

Good Luck.
 
Hi steve

Mine is around 9 weeks after sending the RFE. No response.
140/485- 25th march 04
rfe on oct18
sent on jan 1st and no lud since then
 
1 140 Rfe

Hello Guru's

I got an RFE on 140 of ability to pay. Can you please tell me how this can be answered and what did u do when you go the RFE. Any suggestions are highly appreciated. Thank you.
 
How I responded

The relevant section of the I-140 form is quoted below. I didn't initially submit this evidence because I was already working for the employer and thought my petition was not connected to a job offer - they were already paying me for crying out loud! Isn't that enough evidence of ability to pay?

I work at a major state university with more than 100 employees. Consequently, our HR person requested a letter from our CFO which said basically:

1. We have over 100 employees at this place
2. We could afford to pay this guy the wage stated in the labor cert application at the time the application was made and can still afford to pay.

If you have less than 100 people then you need the financial statements etc. I can't help you there.


Hope this helps

Stevphel.

"Ability to pay wage. Petitions which require job offers must
be accompanied by evidence that the prospective U.S.
employer has the ability to pay the proffered wage. Such
evidence shall be in the form of copies of annual reports,
federal tax returns, or audited financial statements.

In a case where the prospective U.S. employer employs 100 or
more workers, a statement from a financial officer of the
organization which establishes ability to pay the wage may be
submitted. In appropriate cases, additional evidence, such as
profit/loss statements, bank account records, or personnel
records, may be submitted."
 
Hello_Me

Hello_Me,

Sounds like you are in the same situation as me. Perhaps we can make this whole silly process more interesting by seeing who gets approved first :)

What was the basis of your RFE?
 
Hi Julyuser,

You and me are in the same boat. I am worried about my I-140 because my company reduced my salary in 2003 and even they filed taxes in loses. Year 2001,2002and 2004 are fine and only problem with 2003. One of my co-employee responded RFE on 2/9/05 and got it approved with in a week.

I don't know why they are taking much time in my case.
 
steve

I think mine was regarding my own W2 and company tax papers and education evaluation. It was a sub labour. That's what my lawer told me and i didn't do anything. My lawayer submitted everything. Let's see how ot goes.
 
Hi,

I got RFE email today. Message says RFE issued 3/4/05.
I am waiting RFE letter and will post details.

Let's keep post 140 RFE experiences.

I140/I485: RD 6/4/05

Thanks,
 
Dear curiousGeorge,

please do not trush a nice line of useful information with
out of place "congrets" massages.
 
140 Approved after RFE....

Hi all,

My I-140 approved after long long wait. Thank god and thanks for all the members of this forum. I wish good luck to all waiting for I-140.

----------------------------
EB-3
I-140/485 RD 1/30/04
I-140 RFE on 11/17/04
RFE RD 2/4/05
I-140 Approved on 3/7/05
EAD extension Approved on 3/9/05.
 
Top