Hi friends,
This is the content of RFE I recieved for my EB1-OR petition. I request others to please help me in responding to this.
1) USCIS acknowledges the evidence provided to establish that the beneficiary was the recipient of major prizes or awards for outstanding academic achievements; however, please note that scholarships, fellowships and awards that are open only to students generally do not qualify. Therefore, if the beneficiary has been the recipient of any prize or award other than those listed above, please submit documentary evidence of this award and also, evidence from the entity establishing the criteria for the award and scope and nature of the competition.
2) It is acknowledged that the petitioner submitted evidence to establish that the beneficiary had participated, either individually or on a panel, as a judge of the work of others in the same or an allied academic field. Please submit documentary evidence to establish that it is outstanding relative to others who participate in the peer-review process.
3) The petitioner claims that the beneficiary has made original scientific or scholarly research contributions to the academic field; however the evidence submitted with the petition is insufficient to establish that the research of the beneficiary has had an impact in the field. For example, it appears that the beneficiary may have developed a complex model and an automated ***** system; however there is no documentary evidence to support this development. Therefore please submit documentary evidence to show that the beneficiary’s original scientific or scholarly research have contributed to the field.
4) In support of the petition, the petitioner also included evidence of that the beneficiary has membership in associations with the field of the study; however, please submit the constitution or bylaws of the organization that enumerate the specific criteria for membership.
I am totally confused about collecting extra evidences to support my petition. Please guide me what shall I do??
This is the content of RFE I recieved for my EB1-OR petition. I request others to please help me in responding to this.
1) USCIS acknowledges the evidence provided to establish that the beneficiary was the recipient of major prizes or awards for outstanding academic achievements; however, please note that scholarships, fellowships and awards that are open only to students generally do not qualify. Therefore, if the beneficiary has been the recipient of any prize or award other than those listed above, please submit documentary evidence of this award and also, evidence from the entity establishing the criteria for the award and scope and nature of the competition.
2) It is acknowledged that the petitioner submitted evidence to establish that the beneficiary had participated, either individually or on a panel, as a judge of the work of others in the same or an allied academic field. Please submit documentary evidence to establish that it is outstanding relative to others who participate in the peer-review process.
3) The petitioner claims that the beneficiary has made original scientific or scholarly research contributions to the academic field; however the evidence submitted with the petition is insufficient to establish that the research of the beneficiary has had an impact in the field. For example, it appears that the beneficiary may have developed a complex model and an automated ***** system; however there is no documentary evidence to support this development. Therefore please submit documentary evidence to show that the beneficiary’s original scientific or scholarly research have contributed to the field.
4) In support of the petition, the petitioner also included evidence of that the beneficiary has membership in associations with the field of the study; however, please submit the constitution or bylaws of the organization that enumerate the specific criteria for membership.
I am totally confused about collecting extra evidences to support my petition. Please guide me what shall I do??