Alright, after a day of rest and reflection, here is our complete interview story!
Let's start at 3 am the day of the interview, my wife and I just got done buying last minute items such as index tabs for the heavy duty binder we managed to fit all our documents into. By 6 am, the index tabs were all labeled and I was about to lose it, freaking we won't get enough sleep, throwing around funky colored bags that were inappropriate to bring to the interview, and incoherently saying that I'll be deported because we don't have a solid colored bag that our binder can fit into.
Fast forward to 10:30 the next morning, it turns out I fell asleep pretty fast and we were actually pretty rested. A quick shower and we were on our way, my wife was so nice to drive so I could slowly enjoy my morning coffee in the passenger seat. (I'm kinda spoiled
) We stopped for lunch at a Jack in the Box (JITB) just 10 minutes from the DO, which has sentimental value for us because it's the first restaurant chain we've ever been to together, almost 7 years ago.
We arrived at the DO on time ten minutes before the interview, but I'd warn anyone that the parking situation at the San Antonio DO is quite confusing. It caused us to circle the whole area once and I had to run in to ask where we could park without being towed. Consequently, we came in 5 minutes late, but had to wait over an hour anyway until my name was called so it didn't matter, in fact the IO later apologized to us several times for the wait. Turns out we carried our binder and photo albums without a bag, and everyone else there seemed to do the same thing; at least it shows the IO right away what you have.
After calling me, the IO escorted us to the elevator and up to another floor where his office was located. He introduced himself in the elevator and we had some small talk. He proceeded to swear us in and told us which chair to sit in. He was very courteous, professional, and analytical.
He started out by firing a couple of background questions at my wife. After about a minute, he raised his voice and asked why she lives in another city than the address she had provided. (I think at this point he may have only had my address in front of him - because we had been very careful distinguishing our separate addresses in the application - but she explained and I think he then saw it in the file.)
I had thought that our separate addresses would be an issue, but I didn't think that this would consume the entire interview. He explained that living together is an important requirement to prove a bona fide marriage. He asked us about our past, our present, and our future plans in great detail. I was glad to have spent until 6 am to assemble our binder, because I offered him multiple bank accounts, certificates, bonds, credit cards, different insurances as proof. In fact during the entire interview I kept offering him more stuff from my binder (such as a chat transcript from the first time my wife and I met in real life) but must of it he didn't want to look at. He didn't look at our photo albums at all. We had submitted printouts of two wedding photos with the original application, one of them showing pretty much all our combined close families - and he asked me to tell him who they all are, that was enough pictoral proof for him.
I had thought we're explaining our case to him well, when suddenly about halfway into the interview he said, "do you know there will be a second interview" and for a moment we both thought he's requiring us to go to a Stokes interview. Turns out, he was leading into the removal of condition. He explained to us the 90 day before 2 year requirement and said "there will be another interview." Now, my understanding from reading this forum is that usually the removal of condition interview is waived; but perhaps in our case he thought from experience (or maybe noted in the file?) that there shall be an interview to remove the condition, maybe because we had indicated there may be a chance that we'll only be able to start living together right around the same time that we have to remove the condition.
At some point he stepped out briefly to get the next (last for the day?) interviewing couple who had to wait until our interview was completed, because the lobby area was closing for the day. He seated them outside his office and I felt sorry they had to wait so long.
He asked us whether we knew that we might be living apart for a while at the time we got married, we answered yes. He asked us whether we knew it would be a problem when we applied for AOS based on marriage, we also said yes. I don't know what answer he was looking for but I just answered truthfully. Overall, I felt he asked my wife a lot more questions than me, and looked more at her. She thinks it's because she answered to the point whereas I elaborated on every question. It must have been a tiring interview for him too because at some point he said something about my wife adjusting to permanent resident status.
He earlier told us that he opened a soda in the morning and hadn't even had the chance to finish it yet.
There were a number of funny moments during the interview, like when we told him we got married on the same date that we had originally started dating, which also happens to be my wife's birthday. He commented that I'll be spending a lot on that day. Also, when he asked about whether we got the honeymoon suite, we explained we got the Jacuzzi suite and he thought that was cool and explained his own vacation experiences with his wife. I told him we usually don't spend that much but decided to spend a lot on our wedding night, and he said that he and his wife also don't like to spend a lot. Another funny moment was when we told him when we chatted we found out that we were only three blocks from one another at the same university.
He asked me three of the terrorism related questions, I don't remember which ones exactly. One of them was about drug and alcohol abuse. It was a small portion of the interview.
After he was convinced we're a bona fide married couple, he said "I am approving your application" and pointed out he's making an exception to the living-together requirement. He gave me an I-551 stamp and noted it is so I don't walk out without some form of proof and explained the card will arrive in the mail. Curiously, he didn't want to remove the I-94 and never asked for my EAD. (I guess I'll hand the I-94 to the ticket counter next time I travel internationally?)
Some time around this point he picked up his soda and I couldn't help but say "you're still not finished with that soda?" But he thought it was funny.
Then, he asked us if we have any questions. It turns out this was perhaps the most pleasant and informative part of the interview. I asked how important it will be for us to be living together when the time comes to remove the condition, and if we don't live together, what form of proof would be best to show. He proceeded to essentially explain to us his complete and well thought out reasoning for why he approved us, and the reasoning he'd go through if we were still living apart two years from now. It was related to mobilty and training requirement for our jobs. He did note that you have to make compromises in a marriage. An interesting thing he remarked was that, since I was in H-1B status, I could have gotten a GC through employment also, therefore there wouldn't have been a reason for me to try to get a GC via a fraudulent marriage anyway.
We had decided to write a letter explaining our living situation, which we submitted with the original application, and he said this was very important. He said without it, he couldn't have approved the case and would have asked us to provide an explanatory letter. He told us that if we're still in this situation in 2 years, to again explain our situation in a letter and include all the facts and reasons why we are in fact a good faith married couple.
Thus our interview concluded one hour later. He escorted us downstairs and said good bye. We were of course happy but also tired, and mostly still a little surprised that it turned out to be quite complicated. We had earlier planned to do some sightseeing in San Antonio but decided to drive back to my city, and my wife dropped me off at my class so I could at least get half of the lecture. Later, my wife and I walked around campus, visited the location where we had first met some 7 years ago, and went to "our" JITB that we had first visited together. Turns out it was completely remodeled! Then we came home and rested for the rest of the day ...
The first thing my wife said when we came out was, "so now we can go through the same line at the airport, right?"
And she's right, this is really the only thing that has changed in my situation. So attaining LPR status has been somewhat aclimactic for me at this point. Many of you can now get jobs, social security cards, drivers licenses and what not... but I simply went back to work and continued my life. (Of course I showed HR my I-551 stamp to update my employabilty status, and all my H-1B buddies thought it was pretty cool that I'm an LPR now!) Maybe it's just initally a little weird to not be on a nonimmigrant visa anymore after 12 years. I'm sure after my visa would have expired I'll start appreciating this more, since I am now a husband without an "expiration date"
D), at least for the next two years! And of course when we get to go through customs together, I'll appreciate it too! Now we just have to work on my wife being able to go through customs with me together when we enter the EU ...
To summarize, here's the advice I can give:
Anyone going to San Antonio DO, be prepared for an interesting parking situation. Don't think too hard about the signs/barriers and park in the back.
Anyone who lives at different addresses than your spouse:
- be sure to state it appropriately in your application; it will definitely come up in your interview and become a central part of your interview.
- write an explanatory letter
- explain your future plans carefully
- ask the IO for advice at the end if you're not sure what this will mean for your removal of condition
For anyone, be sure to think of questions to ask the IO after the interview. This is your time to get some valuable information.
Thank you all for the advice you have given me here. Most of all, I'd like to thank my wife for spending countless hours, days, weekends helping me prepare all the documentation. You know you are truly loved if your continued presence in a country is so important to someone and I'm only now beginning to really appreciate the meaning of this.