Any AC-21 Denials. Do they really exist?

[longuito]

Hi

I have read all kinds of questions regarding AC-21, but I have never seen a case posted where the I-485 had been denied, in cases like:

- Somebody switched jobs (laid off or voluntary) before 180 days of filing I-485. I am talking about the AC21 rule. For example, somebody gets laid off 3 months after filing I-485, and the USCIS denies the GC.
Cases where the employer widthdraws the I-140 and cases where the employer did not, are interesting to know.

- Somebody who has worked for years during the I-485 applications and laid-off a couple of months before an employment RFE? For example, Somebody gets laid off 2 years after filing I-485 are is unlucky enough to get a request for evidence when he is 2 months unemployed. You know, before he even has the chance of getting another job.

These are hypotetical cases, My personal situation is not important. I just want to know is the USCIS officers are looking for the minimal mistake to deny a case.

I don't think is fair to be living on the edge for 3 years waiting for the GC, so I want to know If we are really living on the edge or are we over stressing outselves too much.

 

[ginnu]

Hi

I have read all kinds of questions regarding AC-21, but I have never seen a case posted where the I-485 had been denied, in cases like:

- Somebody switched jobs (laid off or voluntary) before 180 days.

---- what do you mean by "before 180 days" ??? I-180 days of I-140 approved and I-485 pending more than 180 days?? you need to post your correct situation
- Somebody who has worked for years during the I-485 applications and laid-off a couple of months before an employment RFE?
----- post the details of I-140 and I-485, when filed, if I-140 approved if I-485 pending more than 180 days
I wonder if those cases really exist, Are the USCIS people slow but reasonable?