Advice please! i130 i485 denied USCIS error

dominicmurphy

New Member
Hi! I am new here and really hoping to get some advice!

Background first: My wife (US citizen) and I (UK citizen) married August 2012 while I was here on visa waiver (after a whirlwind transatlantic romance!). We soon after filed i130, i485 etc, and all was going well: biometrics appointment, EAD and AP granted and so on. On December 20, 2012 we received notice (dated December 12, 2012) to appear for interview on January 17, 2013. My wife had to go to Utah for work on that date, so I telephoned to find out if it was possible to reschedule the interview. This call was on December 20, 2012. Soon after, we received a letter, dated December 26, 2012, which stated: "We have received and granted your request to reschedule your appointment date. You will receive a notice within 3 to 6 weeks informing you of your new appointment."

Our next correspondence came the other day, with each of us receiving a denial notice (dated March 1, 2013) for the i130 and i485 respectively. The i-130 denial notice explicitly states our failure to appear for the January 17 interview as the reason for denial. As we have a letter stating that our request to reschedule the interview has been "granted", surely these denials are based on an administrative error. However, both letters also state that there is no way to appeal the decision. It is also my understanding that a motion to reopen is only appropriate when there is new evidence to consider, which is not really the case.

I am not sure how best to deal with this. Hiring a lawyer, filing a motion to reopen or completely refiling all cost money that we don't have, especially as we are in this situation through no fault of our own. But, of course, we just want to do whatever it takes to get this sorted out. What really worries me is the business of now being here illegally and possibly having to leave the country. I don't want to be away from my wife, nor my career. I don't want to overstay, no do I want to leave and risk not being allowed back in!

So far we have both telephoned USCIS, my wife managed to get them put in a Service Request, whatever that means. We have also both written, enclosing copies of the letter confirming the rescheduling. I have also made an infopass appointment for Monday. However, my initial impression is that just because they have made a mistake, doesn't mean they're going put it right.

We would both really appreciate ANY good advice on how to proceed. Thank you!
 
Yes- USCIS will correct that mistake. I had the same similar situation too where I indicated on my form I485 where I would like my interview and they sent me to another office farther away from my residence. I sent them a letter with the proof of what I indicated on my form and they granted my request and sent my file to where I initially requested. I was also told that I will get a letter within 3-6 weeks for my reschedule date but instead I got a letter from the office I was supposed initially that got reschedule that I did not show up and my application was denied.
I sent them a letter showing my recent correspondence indicating that my case was rescheduled. they responded and reopened the case.
Goodluck
 
Yes- USCIS will correct that mistake. I had the same similar situation too where I indicated on my form I485 where I would like my interview and they sent me to another office farther away from my residence. I sent them a letter with the proof of what I indicated on my form and they granted my request and sent my file to where I initially requested. I was also told that I will get a letter within 3-6 weeks for my reschedule date but instead I got a letter from the office I was supposed initially that got reschedule that I did not show up and my application was denied.
I sent them a letter showing my recent correspondence indicating that my case was rescheduled. they responded and reopened the case.
Goodluck

Thank you for posting, you have reassured me, a bit!! I'll let you know how it goes at the infopass appointment on monday. Thanks!

Also can you confirm that you just wrote to them, with a copy of the letter, but you didn't need to file a motion to reopen?

Thank you!!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
USCIS does this way too often, wrongly denying green cards for failing to appear at the interview even though a reschedule was requested. But I think yours is the first I've seen where they actually acknowledged the reschedule request in writing and then still denied the case for failing to appear on the original interview date.

Report this to the USCIS Ombudsman. Denial should not be their first course of action if somebody doesn't appear for an interview, especially if they actually requested a reschedule. If they don't reopen the case based on your interactions at Infopass, the Ombudsman may help you to get it reopened.
http://www.dhs.gov/ombudsman-case-assistance

However, both letters also state that there is no way to appeal the decision. It is also my understanding that a motion to reopen is only appropriate when there is new evidence to consider, which is not really the case.
Motion to Reopen is not only for new evidence. It can also be filed if USCIS ignored or misinterpreted the existing evidence. But the MTR costs money, so hopefully you won't need to file one after talking to them at the Infopass.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
We had our infopass appointment this morning. Although she wouldn't be drawn to give us any guarantees, the officer seemed confident our case would be reopened and we would receive a new appointment notice. I'll be glad when I actually have the letter, but am very pleased with this result.

Thank you all for your helpful responses!
 
Report it to the Ombudsman anyway. The more the Ombudsman knows about situations like this more inclined they will be to do something to prevent it from happening again.
 
I485

Hi,

I hope to get some good advise from all of you in the forum.

My background First: My spouse and I applied for I485 on 2nd Nov2003.(EB3 category). Green card was approved for my spouse on July10th2007. I did not get mine. On repeated calling USCIS, I was told about the cut off dates(as they were not current). I did wait. Last Nov, my spouse became a citizen. Yesterday, I did receive a letter that my I485 is denied as my spouse is a citizen.

Could someone advise as to what my next steps should be .

Regards,
K
 
Your spouse will need to file an I-130 for you, and you will need to file a new I-485 based on that I-130, along with the other related forms (I-693 medical, I-765, I-131, I-864, one G-325A for each of you).

Hurry up and file your new I-485, because if USCIS initiates removal proceedings before you file it, things will get very complicated.
 
Top