\'Why don\'t you leave this country?\'

vscaug

Registered Users (C)
\'Why don\'t you leave this country?\'

This is the artical on Rediff.com....

\'Why don\'t you leave this country?\'
Arthur J Pais

Sarfraz Ahmad still shudders in fear when he recalls that day in August 1999.

Sarfraz and his friend Mudasher Fazal were having a quiet lunch in a Burger King restaurant in suburban Pittsburgh, when two burly men walked up to them.

"Leave this country now or you will die," the bigger of the men told the two doctors. "There\'s no use for you here. They are coming for you."

The man was also upset to hear Ahmad and Fazal chat in Urdu. "Why don\'t you speak English?" he yelled. "Get out of this country! All of you will be cleared of this land! Why don\'t you leave?"

A year later, the two friends came to know more about the man, whose immigrant parents often spoke in a Baltic language in their sprawling Pittsburgh home.

Facing a jury in a Pittsburgh court on Wednesday, Ahmad recalled in a trembling voice how he and his friend reacted to the racial threats, especially after seeing a pistol on the waist of the smaller second man.

"I shouted to my friend, \'Run!\' We ran toward the front door," Ahmad testified. They hid by the side of a large departmental store for more than an hour. They did not, however, report the incident to the police, fearing that it would be ignored.

But as Ahmad looked at the man who had threatened him and his friend, the doctor could not but help think their lives were indeed in danger that August day.

The man who made the threats was Richard Scott Baumhammers, who last April went on a racial rampage, killing an Indian, two Southeast Asians, a Jew and an African-American man who was at a gym owned by an Asian. Sandeep Patel, who was also shot, is now paralysed.

Officials paraded a host of witnesses including Ahmad to challenge the defense theory that Baumhammers had suffered from delusions on the day of the murder and he should be considered insane.

The witnesses, however, portrayed Baumhammers as a racist and anti-Semitic hate monger.

Baumhammers sat all through the testimony with an impassive face and avoided eye contact with the witnesses, just the way he had done for more than a week since the trial started.

Leslie Haun, a ex-convict in jail awaiting a trial on new charges, said Baumhammers told him in jail: "When niggers started going to school with whites, it helped design the regime to pollute the minds of our children. It would poison them for years to come."

Haun also told the jury Baumhammers regarded Timothy McVeigh, the man sentenced to die for the fatal bombing of a federal building in Oklahoma City this month, and Adolf Hitler as his idols.

In other damaging testimonies, two other fellow inmates who testified yesterday asserted Baumhammers seemed to be faking his mental illness.

"He said he would like to end up in a state hospital, but he would be happy with life [in prison]," Barry L Fiumara testified.

Baumhammers said he killed minorities because "he was really fed up with immigrant people. He said they were very ignorant, selfish and argumentative," Fiumara testified.

The prosecution is asking the death penalty for 35-year-old Baumhammers.
 
No Title

It is very sad to hear this. I think when in a group where people may not understand your language. We should be speaking in English instead of speaking in Urudu/Hindi/Russian/Spanish/French/etc..
 
No Title

It seems that most racists are miserable losers in their own life. How ironic that this pathetic guy actually come from an immigrant family by himself. I can only say that his immigrant parents did a poor job to bring up a son like that, who has to face criminal charge and ends up either in prison or mental hospital for a very long time.
 
No Title

Kumar,

The European man came here and had no problem speaking his own language, enforcing his own culture. Why should two people with similar cultures not enjoy their language when it is nobody else\'s business. I speak English all the time in the US. When I went to tour Germany, I learnt German and used it as much as I could. When I went to Italy, I learnt Italian and used it wherever possible. I plan to go to south America this year, and am learning basic Spanish. But when I speak to my family, I speak in my language. When I speak to my Indian friends, I do the same. Don\'t forget what you are.

My fiancee, when she took her citizenship, was asked if she wants to change her name to a Christian one. How do you feel about that? Even my white friends thought that was rude. There is no end to ignorant jerks. Don\'t get me wrong. In my opinion India is much more racist than the US. Believe me. I lived there for 21 years of my life. But while in the US, I have learnt something about individual rights and previlages. That is the strength of this country, and giving it up is wrong.

Just my 2 cents.
 
No Title

You are correct, parental up bringing has a lot to do apart from various other environmental factors. Feeling threatened or insecure upon seeing a stranger with a language of their own may be a natural human reaction, which can be reduced to a little extent by the immigrants by mixing with the natives (instead going in groups) and speaking in english in public.

It is sad to see (fortunately not to the extent seen in the article!) even in U.S. also there are (Indian) associations based on Caste, religion (got an email from a telugu brahmin association even though I am not one of them (sure am an Indian), do not know where they got my email from!), distancing ourselves from one another. Inspite of all this, it is heartening to see people of all backgrounds coming together to help Gujarat quake victims forgetting all these divisions.

Didn\'t mean to sound like a newspaper article....just my thoughts....
 
No Title

I agree. I would also like to add that I have had many good experiances in USA and they outweigh the few bad scattered bad instances.
 
No Title

Timbuk3 ,

I agree that we should take pride in our culture. And speak the same language whenever we are to-gether / within a group. However, if you speak a language with your friend(s) and there is someone participating in the group who does not understand the language - it is considered rude anywhere - And I find that many people still speak out loudly in their native language when someone else is there who has no idea what is being said. What I am saying is that this is not going to help.
 
No Title

I\'m with you Kumar. If there is a group discussion, it is rude to rule people of the group out through language, or inside jokes. However, if someone just happens to be in a hearing range and is not part of the conversation, I don\'t see an issue. My officemate says that sometimes the person may feel that they are talking about him/her. In my opinion, that it is his/her insecurity. We cant pander to everyone\'s insecurity. Funny thing is, my fiancee and I have different mother tongues, and so our mode of conversation is purely English. But if we had a common language, I would not hesitate using it. (Don\'t you think that Americans when they work in other countries speak only English with other Americans? It is just natural and comfortable). To me, it has nothing to do with pride or patriotism. Personally, if any of us were really patriotic, we could do a lot for India that we don\'t. I think it is just a way to personalize a conversation.

As I said in my earlier posting, an extreme version is what my fiancee faced when she was asked to change to a Christian name upon swearing in as a citizen. That\'s just plain rude, ignorant, and a sign of an ultimate loser.

Cheers
 
Top