Travelled to Canada after 2 yrs - Experience

khi_boy

Registered Users (C)
Hi All,

First of all thanks to Ray S. and Priya for their help. I picked up Vancouver Airport based on Ray. S post in the forum

Here is the experience:

Travel from Sanfrancisco to YVR (Vancouver)

- I am a Special Registrant with US
- Went to Air Canada checkin counter
- Lady said , she needs my I-94 as I am a special registrant
(surprise to me ! )
- I said I dont wana give and want to use Automatic revalidation,
Airline lady told me to go to INS office and take their advise
- I reported to INS office for EXIT registration . Officer told me to give my I-94 card to Airline before leaving so I gave my I94 to
Air canada

- I was given Custom declaration and SARS form in plane
- After landing at YVR , I went to Resident line

Following questions were asked:

- Landed Immigrant?
Yes

- Are you coming back from USA?
Yes.

- Did you go to any other country ?
No

- Did you buy anything and what are you carrying?
Nothing. Just my laptop

- Did you buy your computer from Canada?
Yes.

- He stamped my custom declaration and asked me to go
ahead

hardly one-min to get cleared. Canadian officer didn't look into passport


- I filed my application next day

While coming back to USA

- A very very big queue at US immigration
- I went to US immigration counter
- I showed him my Advance Parole , officer asked me to go to Secondary inspection to process the parole.
- I told officer , I ALSO HAVE H1B approval and since I came just one day back , I want to use automatic revalidation

- Officer replied . No , You travelled on 512 , can't use your H1

- I didn't understand what exactly he said. But I just proceeded for secondary inspection.

- I gave my AP to secondary inspector and told him , Sir ! I have a question ?

- He said , Yes?
- I showed him my H1B extension approval and requested him to use H1 and automatic revalidation and issue me a new I94 as I have surrendered old one at SFO airport.

- He said, No you have AP , you can't use your H1, we have given you AP to use it as you have a pending 485.

- Another surprise to me!!! (I knew he is incorrect).

- I told him , I am also a NSEER registrant and wanna do my Special registration , as I am obligated to do it volunteerily at every ENTRANCE/EXIT . He said , AP is exempted . I told him but I already have a FIN# and I registeretd already so I am obligated. He called the immmigration supervisor to take his advise. Supervisor came and said , we are now exempting APs and you shouldn't register. He also added , should someone enter on H1 , he should must register on both entry and exit, and only APs, GCs and citizens are exempted.

- Then officer processed my AP and gave me a I94 with one-year validity

- Then officer asked , well I am curious why you want to use your H1 and not AP?? (he was now very polite).

- I told him , Sir , my attorney told me that in case 485 is refused , H1 is always a backup for me :) .

- He said , why do I feel my 485 will be refused? He said , dont listen to your attorney , attorney wants your money and we want you people.

(Well, i was said . Officer didn't allow me to use 30 days revalidation as my H1 stamp was expired).

- Finally officer told me , if I travel to Canada again. I need to posses a Valid AP and I shouldn't give my I94 to airline or INS in USA when exiting . While going back from Canada , I can just showup my I94 to immigration officer and I need not to go through secondary inspection again.

Auto-matic revalidation didn't work for me.

hope my experience is useful for someone

thx
khi_boy
 
Good to know that you have so much knowledge about immigration matters and you could talk and discuss so much with the INS
 
Khi_boy

you mentioned..

<- He stamped my custom declaration and asked me to go
ahead
hardly one-min to get cleared. Canadian officer didn't look into passport >


Didnt they stamp your passport ?
 
sawill,

No . Canadian officer didn't stamped my passport. He only glanced at my passport 1st page with Photo and name but only stamped the Custom decleration

thx
khi_boy
 
Originally posted by khi_boy
sawill,

No . Canadian officer didn't stamped my passport. He only glanced at my passport 1st page with Photo and name but only stamped the Custom decleration

thx
khi_boy


This is quite strange. They have been stamping passports when arrived by air.

Yesterday one of my friend also returned to canada from US after about more than 2 years, with family, he is also a spcl registrant. at Toronto airport he had a little tough time and they stamped the passports and made a note in their computer.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
for sawill

Could please give the full detail and experience of your friend ?
I need to go to Toronto next time to collect my PR card
 
Khi boy,

Well right now I dont have details I just got email from him but I will try to contact and find out what exactly happened. And will post here.
 
Re: for sawill

Originally posted by khi_boy
Could please give the full detail and experience of your friend ?
I need to go to Toronto next time to collect my PR card

Khi boy,

Nothing went wrong with my friend at Toronto airport as such. Immigration officer asked him how long he was out of Canada, he told the truth (about 2 years on H1B in USA) so they made a note about it in their computer. As far stamping passport goes, that is usual when you go to Toronto by air you will get that. Donno why they dont do that in Vancouver.
If you worried about all that, next time you better fly to Buffalo and then enter canada via Rainbow bridge on foot or with rental car, to avoid extra questioning (Rainbow Bridge also included in SR entry/exit POE list). You will still be asked the same question that how long you were out , and its upto you wat you tell them.
 
Top