Please help: Can I switch job (I-140 submitted)

jify30

Registered Users (C)
Hi,

I am working as a research scientist in one of the Universities in New York. I have filed my immigration petition (I-140 through EB1- alien of extraordinary abilities) on Dec 5, 2005 by myself and not through my university. I have not filed I-485 because of the retrogression. I am getting an opportunity to join a pharmaceutical company and get better salary and benefits. Please advise me if I can switch my job and keep the same priority date or do I have apply again my immigrant petition (form I-140). Thanks

Jify30
I-140 RD 12/05/2005
LUD 12/16/2005
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I do not think that the employee can file for the I-140 for themselves. I-140 is the form for the employer to show that if the USCIS grants the immigrant visa to the worker then the emplyer will hire the person full time and can support financially.

If your employer(your university) filed for the labor and it got cleared etc. then you have to wait till your I-140 gets approved. Once your I-140 is approved you can change the employers after 180 days of the approval date of I-140 if you can prove that you are retrogressed by the USCIS for the I-485 application and you are getting a better job in the same job title as your current occupation.

I know it is bit confusing and i took good care of explaining it. For more info on jumping employers you can go to murthy[dot]com/news/n_porret.html to get more details on this one.

Make sure you do get all the info before you decide anything. This is not straight forward process (or i can say in your case that it is not a science but an art to jump employers !)

I hope this helps, but do your homework and do not take my word.
 
Thanks puerthoughts for your comments. First of all EB1 category doesn't require Labor certification. Secondly, EB1 (alien's with extraordinary ability can file there petitions independent of employment from any university or company. Please see a clip copied from the USCIS site (I made it capitalized at the places where it quotes these two things):

Application Procedures
A USCIS Form I-140 (Petition for Alien Worker) is required. All I-140 petitions must be filed at the USCIS Regional Service Center that has jurisdiction over the place where the individual will work. The petition packet must include the required documentary evidence and should follow the specific filing guidelines of the Service Center. NO LABOR CERTIFICATION IS NEEDED FOR EB-1 PETITIONS.

WHILE THE EB-1 WORKER OF EXTRAORDINARY ABILITY MAY PETITION FOR HIMSELF OR HERSELF, the employer must file the petition for an outstanding professor or researcher and a multinational executive or manager.

puerthoughts said:
I do not think that the employee can file for the I-140 for themselves. I-140 is the form for the employer to show that if the USCIS grants the immigrant visa to the worker then the emplyer will hire the person full time and can support financially.

If your employer(your university) filed for the labor and it got cleared etc. then you have to wait till your I-140 gets approved. Once your I-140 is approved you can change the employers after 180 days of the approval date of I-140 if you can prove that you are retrogressed by the USCIS for the I-485 application and you are getting a better job in the same job title as your current occupation.

I know it is bit confusing and i took good care of explaining it. For more info on jumping employers you can go to murthy[dot]com/news/n_porret.html to get more details on this one.

Make sure you do get all the info before you decide anything. This is not straight forward process (or i can say in your case that it is not a science but an art to jump employers !)

I hope this helps, but do your homework and do not take my word.
 
Did you apply under NIW category?If your I-140 is approved and I-485 is pending for last 6 months, you are eligible to change your job within the the same field.There are lot of threads onto murthy.com which are releavant to your questions.

smbaps
 
No I didn't apply under "NIW" category, but under "aliens of extraordinary ability" category. I am pasting some information that I got from Messersmith Law Firm website:

EB1 & NIW Self-Sponsorship
There are two ways in which a foreign national can bypass the requirement of a job or job offer and labor certification/PERM and apply for US permanent residence. They are the priority worker EB-1 category for Aliens of Extraordinary Ability and the exceptional worker EB-2 National Interest Waiver (NIW) category. Although these are employment based immigrant categories, neither require actual employment or even a job offer prior to the filing of the application or the approval.

The requirements of each category are quite stringent and a casual observer may believe that a Nobel prize is required to get an EB-1 petition approved, this is not the case. Likewise, the NIW requirements can be overcome with a strong legal argument.

The benefits of the EB-1 and NIW are enormous: Speed, Cost, and Freedom.

A normal labor certification process can take years. The labor certification must be approved before the the employer can even file a sponsorship petition with the USCIS. EB-1/NIW petitions can be concluded in one year.
Labor certification requires costly advertising fees and the employer is burdened with the monetary and time expense. Employers may pass these costs on to the employee through lower wages.
While these petitions are pending the employee is tied to the employer until the process is completed. During this time, the employer wields an enormous amount of power over the employee which places the employee in a very weak position.
If in the United States, an applicant may submit both an EB-1 and an NIW petition simultaneously. At the same time, the foreign national may apply for permanent residence for him or herself and his or her spouse and children. When permanent residence application is filed the applicant and the spouse may also apply for work permits and travel documents to use while the petition is pending. The work permit allows the holder to work for any United States employer and the travel document allows to travel internationally without abandoning their petitions.

smbaps said:
Did you apply under NIW category?If your I-140 is approved and I-485 is pending for last 6 months, you are eligible to change your job within the the same field.There are lot of threads onto murthy.com which are releavant to your questions.

smbaps
 
jify30 said:
Hi,

I am working as a research scientist in one of the Universities in New York. I have filed my immigration petition (I-140 through EB1- alien of extraordinary abilities) on Dec 5, 2005 by myself and not through my university. I have not filed I-485 because of the retrogression. I am getting an opportunity to join a pharmaceutical company and get better salary and benefits. Please advise me if I can switch my job and keep the same priority date or do I have apply again my immigrant petition (form I-140). Thanks

Jify30
I-140 RD 12/05/2005
LUD 12/16/2005
jify,

Sure you can, because you are not tied to any employer. Your's is a self petition and is not linked to your University.

However, is your I 140 approved?.

I presume, you are currently working on OPT or H1 B or TN visa. Even, if your I 140 is approved, what work authorization you will carry. Most likely H1, because you cannot have an EAD as you have not yet filed I 485.

The only thing you have to ensure that the new job that you would be in has similar reserach responsibilites as you stated in EB1 petition. And since you have to get a new/tranfser H1, you can defnitely change jobs.

Also, it doesn't hurts to seek a lawyer opinion. You can write a question to immigration-law.com and hopefully get some answers.

Good luck
 
Thanks houston2005,

My I140 is not approved yet.
I am currently working on H1 (3rd yr-finishing june 30, 2006) and have already applied for extension of 3 yrs through my current employer.
The new company will give me H1.

houston2005 said:
jify,

Sure you can, because you are not tied to any employer. Your's is a self petition and is not linked to your University.

However, is your I 140 approved?.

I presume, you are currently working on OPT or H1 B or TN visa. Even, if your I 140 is approved, what work authorization you will carry. Most likely H1, because you cannot have an EAD as you have not yet filed I 485.

The only thing you have to ensure that the new job that you would be in has similar reserach responsibilites as you stated in EB1 petition. And since you have to get a new/tranfser H1, you can defnitely change jobs.

Also, it doesn't hurts to seek a lawyer opinion. You can write a question to immigration-law.com and hopefully get some answers.

Good luck
 
Top