Non Compete Agreements: California

non-compete

Registered Users (C)
Hi,

Im not sure if this is the correct forum to ask my question, so apologies if i set foot in the wrong place. I know that a lot of us here who subscribe to this forum work for consuting companies with crazy rules and laws. I request you to help me out with my situation. It probably could help many others here as well. I know i cannot expect legal advice here, but pls chime in your experience/suggestions/advice/tips/stories if you have been through this or can share your experience.

I have been working for a software consulting company (Company A) in california for the last 4 years and have been deputed at their client's (Company B) site in california for the same period. Company A made me sign an agreement before I came to USA and this agreement consists of a non-compete clause as follows

"You agree that during or within a period of one year after completion of services provided under the terms of this agreement you shall not accept any offer of employment from any Company A's customer or the customer's end-user customer(in the case of a consulting or placement organization) with which you may have come in contact as a result of this agreement, whether such employment be on a part time, full time, independent contractor, or any other basis, without the written consent of Company A."

I quit Company A and have given them a notice period of 6 weeks till Nov 30, 2005 to join (Company C) a competitor of Customer B. I am quitting because there is no change to my financial condition and career for the last 4 years and things are getting worse as Company A takes away 60% of my earnings leaving me with nothing much to save. Responsbilities grow, bills creep up, cost of living increases, but salary remains same.

Company A and B have similar agreements between each other so as to not hire each other's employees. Company B has invested a lot of time and money in my training and knowledge, so they dont wish to lose me to their competitor. They also have much to lose with the project with very critical deadlines as i am a very experienced person on the team and have been on this project from the start.

So, In the interest of the success of the project and to avoid losses, Company B decided to take the risk and hire me as an independent contractor and is willing to face legal issues from Company A(not on my behalf though). Company B also countered the offer from Company C and i have accepted Company B's offer to work as an independent contractor.

I know non-compete agreements are void in california and cannot be enforceable in the court of law, so I would like to know what my exposure is and what Company A can do to prevent me from joining Company B. I also know that employers use non-compete clauses to protect their business, but this looks more like a punishment for quitting company A. Company A has many clients/customers here in the bay area who have a lot of end user customers. If they enforce the clause it means i cannot join most of the companies here in the bay area which specializes in my field of expertise thus restricting my employment oppurtunities and the right to earn a living. Pls chime in your experience if you have been thru this or if you know someone who has been through this.

If it helps to know, i have my EAD (family based) and i have a sole proprietership. Thanks for your time and appreciate your help with this and apologies for the lengthy post.
 
The agreement probably cannot be enforced but they may try to darg you to court for vioaling an agreement. It's more an ethical/moral issue that you sign an agreement and then jump ship. Legally, it may not be much to it. I vaguely remember that Microsoft initiated a lawsuit recently on this topic when a guy went from Microsoft to Google if I remember correctly. He had signed such agreement with Microsoft but left anyways. The case went to court, but the agreement was deemed not enforceable due to the fact that any employee can change employer in this free labor market.
 
Thanks for the reply. I checked with a couple of Employment and Labor attorneys and they seem to share the same opinion as you. According to the lawyers, the chances of them taking me to court are 50-50, but the chances of them winning this case are almost nil. So it would be a waste of time and money on their part to drag me to court just to prove a point or two to the other consultatnts still working for them. The lawyers also said that in the worst case, i can expect a letter from their lawyers office asking me to pay up for damages else they would take this matter to the court.

I cant seem to predict the outcome at this point as anything could happen. Either no action would be taken (except some angry calls or emails) or they could seriously go to court and waste their time and money. I guess one has to be mentally prepared in these cases to face whatever happens. I know the management at Company A is stupid, but im sure they dont pay their lawyers $500 an hour to be stupid...

Here is something interesting i stumbled upon... and this gave me hopes
http://www.murthy.com//news/UDh1suit.html
 
When in doubt, be conservative, whatever that mean to you. Should things go wrong, you have more to lose than the company.
 
Top