Is this a judge of the work of other in the field or an allied field

J

junwang

New Member
Hello, everyone,

One othe initial evidence for EB-1 qualification on I-140 is:
"participation on a panel or individually as a judge of the work of others in the field or an allied field". I am a postdoc in biology. Last year, I used our home-developed technique to test the instruments which I was using and bought later. And found all of them were poor in accuracy. While the accuracy of the instrument is very important in our and other research fields. All same products from different company cann\'t reach the accurate degree as no one knows how to check it except me. This year, one company knows how to check it, and have improved their product this technique. Still only I and the company in USA can do this check. My question is:
Is my work on check the accuracy of the product A JUDGE OF THE WORK OF OTHERS IN THE FIELD OR ALLIED FIELD? If it is, what kind of certificate is necessary for the petition? I only have the check resutl and email betwen I and the company. Should I get some certificate from this company?

Thank.

Kancrura
 
Judge

Yes, you need documentation from the concerned parties stating that you were qualified and were responsible for doing this study. Get a letter from the company explaining them what INS is looking for. I assume that company will be helpful.

Typically, what INS is looking for is:
- Refereeing in International Conferences/Jounals
- Panel Member in Judging a Scientific/Other Awards
etc.

Hope that helps.
 
Typical role of judging others

organization committee member or session chair of professional conferences
Committee member of a PhD student
Reviewer of journals
Any panel member who reviews someone else work.

Regarding your work, you need a letter to state the significance of your accuracy check, how important of the instrument, you are the only one or two people on this planet who can do this. Do not be shy to use very strong language.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top