Is I551 stamping really necessary?

[rpranesh]

Hypothetically,
After 485 approval can one just remain legal without getting I551 stamping or applying for I89 and apply for Citizenship after 5 years?

Is I551 stamping and GC Card only required for travel & changing work & getting an unrestricted SSN.

How long can one remain with I485 approved and not get 551 stamping or applying I89.

 

[wik]

Hypothetically,
After 485 approval can one just remain legal without getting I551 stamping or applying for I89 and apply for Citizenship after 5 years?

Is I551 stamping and GC Card only required for travel & changing work & getting an unrestricted SSN.

How long can one remain with I485 approved and not get 551 stamping or applying I89.

I think the issue is that the USCIS 'requires' you to carry evidence of your permanent residence on you at all times. That is what it states on it's Web site, but others have disputed this and some people simply carry photocopies of their GCs in their wallet because replacing a lost or stolen card is a hassle. If you are ever asked by the authorities for evidence of your permanent residence status, and you don't have a passport/stamp or a CG, then what would you show them? Having the GC migh also be a pre-requisite for applying for citizenship, though perhaps others here can shed light on that.

 

[usinsuser99]

I 551 stamping is must on PP, If in the case of kids (<14 years) not cumpulsory.
kids may get cards without I 551 stamping.

 

[MydreamUSA.]

at least, under the current rules, i-551 is essential to complete the GC process. That is the exactly what an approval notice says . Plus i would want to have it if event it was not required. It is an additional evidence of the status, and it is nice to have it in passport.