dwak_2000,
I have been pondering about this for the last couple of days.
I still have close to 3 months on the old EDA, so I chose to throw another 120 dollars and sent another application yesterday without mentioning old application. I will also send a request for correction without the actual card (because you don't want to lose the wrong card also) but with a photocopy. They need a proof that they made this mistake. I didn't have old application's photocopy saved. So whatever weapons you have, or you try to prove, I felt it is going to be useless dealing with NSC's mistake and more likely it will go into a sink hole. Local INS is purely a chance, so I thought, will deal with them if none of the cards shows up.