MUMBAI Consular Processing - Interview Experience. GC denied. Asking more document.

vsshah

Registered Users (C)
My parents recently visited Mumbai for their GC interview.

Experience was not pleasant. They havn't issued the GC stamp or gave GC papers.

Here is the detail.

DESI staff (in Mumbai embassy) is rubbish. DESIs are used to be treated like a dog, and give same shit to applicants. Still, they have not come out of mental slavery to white skin. I wish, they(Desi staff) should be sent to USA and let them visit the white skin slum area. May be that will help them to understand colorless means nothing. 'chai se jyada kettle garam'.

Well, Desi staff asked for PCC. My Dad said, we already submitted original, and I have a copy. Desi staff responded, "We don't have it". My Dad said, "you might have lost it". Then, that DESI MF got real angry. Well, in interview invitation letter, it was clearly mentioned that, what originals they have received. But, my dad had to say 2-3 times sorry to fix this issue.

Another issue, my parents over stayed in their last visit of USA. Well, it was legal stay and we applied for proper extension with fee etc. But that original document was at home, not with them at interview time. They asked for it. My dad was not having that.

Note: My parents visited US embassy for visitor visa in 2009 also. At that time, such extension papers were submitted. But they denied based on overstay reason. This time, I became citizen(I delayed to be citizen for 2 years though), and applied for them. So, they(staff) were feeling useless, and not able to stop them(parents) by any reason. So, finding whatever they can do.

Well, they told my parents to say "Sorry, it was our mistake that we overstayed in past. We broke the law and commit our mistake" etc. And same time, that DESI MF was noting down all this on paper. At last, he returned all original documents back to my parents.

At last, they gave paper 'BMB-194', which says that, "we are prohibiting your visa based on following reason". Reason: Need proof of extension for overstay.

Well, my dad came back to home town. And found such extension (overstay) papers. Then, submitted to locas VFS office along with passports. VFS office said, "you will get passport stamped in 1 week and get back".

Overall experience was not pleasant. They tried their best to stop it. But, I think, it will proceed further.

Any comment?

---

Parents GC timeline - steps

I-130 for Parents of US Citizen for CP (Mumbai, India).
IR-5 category. GC for parents of US citizen.
I-130 for Parents of US Citizen for CP (Mumbai, India).

1. I-130 mailed on 31-Aug-2009 to Chicago.
2. I-130 received date/Priority date: 02-Sep-2009
3. I-130 $355 Checks cashed On: 09-Sep-2009
4. I-130 Approved on: 01-Oct-2009 (Got email on 02-Oct-2009)

5. NVC case# assigned and Choice of Agent form sent: 16-Oct-2009
6. Asked for $70 AOS fee on: 16 Oct 2009
7. Fee $70 paid on 20-OCT-2009 (electronic payment) Only once. which covers both parents.
8. Parents Assigned me as Agent on: 21-Oct-2009

9. Affidavit of support I-864 mailed on: 27-Oct-2009
10. Asked for $400 for IV fee on : 04-NOV-2009
11. Paid $400 for IV fee on : 05-NOV-2009 (electronic payment) for each parent.
12. CHECK LIST COVER letter email received on: 17-NOV-09

13. DS230 Part I and II and Original Civil documents mailed on: 20-NOV-2009
14. Case reached to NVC's system on: 01-DEC-2009 (I called and confirmed)
15. Email received FROM NVC about 'Interview scheduled' on: 11-DEc-2009

16. Medical in A'bad on: 22-DEC-2009
17. Interview in Mumbai on:

18. Visa Received ON:
19. Travel to the US ON:
20. Green Card Received ON:
 
Based on your account, you parents were poorly prepared and confrontational to US consular staff. Not smart on either account. Their experience is of their own making.

Your language in inappropriate for this forum. It is not appreciated by the ladies and gentlement of the group.
 
I'm puzzled why the visa was refused, if the overstay wasn't long enough to trigger a 3/10 year bar. How long past the I-94 expiration did they stay for?
 
I'm puzzled why the visa was refused, if the overstay wasn't long enough to trigger a 3/10 year bar. How long past the I-94 expiration did they stay for?
If you're referring to the tourist visa they applied for in 2009, a 1 week overstay will often trigger a denial of a tourist visa even though there is no statutory bar for such a short overstay. An overstay of any length is counted against the officer who approved the visa, so the next officer won't want to have you rack up another overstay on their record.
 
I would not call it a refusal, just yet. I believe the consular staff wants to confirm if there was an overstay, and if so, for how long. Thus their insistence on seeing the I-539 documents. I also agree with Concerned4us. The OP's parents could have been better prepared.

I'm puzzled why the visa was refused, if the overstay wasn't long enough to trigger a 3/10 year bar. How long past the I-94 expiration did they stay for?
 
They overstayed for 5 months.

My parents visited US in 2006 on B1/B2. They got 5 months permit at that time. Just before, 1 month of I-94 expiry, we applied for extension. They got extension. Then within that new limit, they went back.

My parents were never interested in GC headache. They are interested in 10 years multiple visa. But, during their 2009 US embassy visit, Consule office denied based on last time overstay. So, there was no other way left to call them. So, I became US Citizen and applied for their GC.

I am hopeful that, they will get stamped passport in 1 week and GC papers too. I will update this thread then.

Well, DESI staff and even American staff in Mumbai Embassy is RUDE for sure. My language might not be appropriate. But DESI staff is suffering from mental slavery for sure.

GC related each and every paper was submitted, then what the hell they will do with past legal overstay?
I have seen couple staying in USA, w/o documents for 9 years. Well, their GC case was applied back in 1994 by brother/family. But when they got their dates current. USA issued them GC with 'love' and $1000 extra. They can't do anything to those 500000 people w/o documents, openly shouting in rally.

For genuine cases, they are creating unnecessary troubles.
 
If you're referring to the tourist visa they applied for in 2009, a 1 week overstay will often trigger a denial of a tourist visa even though there is no statutory bar for such a short overstay. An overstay of any length is counted against the officer who approved the visa, so the next officer won't want to have you rack up another overstay on their record.

No, I'm curious about the denial of the immigrant visa, because unless a re-entry bar is in place, an overstay is irrelevant.
 
My parents got GC papers and passports stamped with such information.

My parents got GC papers and passports stamped with such information on saturday (Jan 30 2010).
See # 18, 19, 20 in below timeline.
--
Parents GC timeline - steps

I-130 for Parents of US Citizen for CP (Mumbai, India).
IR-5 category. GC for parents of US citizen.
I-130 for Parents of US Citizen for CP (Mumbai, India).

1. I-130 mailed on 31-Aug-2009 to Chicago.
2. I-130 received date/Priority date: 02-Sep-2009
3. I-130 $355 Checks cashed On: 09-Sep-2009
4. I-130 Approved on: 01-Oct-2009 (Got email on 02-Oct-2009)

5. NVC case# assigned and Choice of Agent form sent: 16-Oct-2009
6. Asked for $70 AOS fee on: 16 Oct 2009
7. Fee $70 paid on 20-OCT-2009 (electronic payment) Only once. which covers both parents.
8. Parents Assigned me as Agent on: 21-Oct-2009

9. Affidavit of support I-864 mailed on: 27-Oct-2009
10. Asked for $400 for IV fee on : 04-NOV-2009
11. Paid $400 for IV fee on : 05-NOV-2009 (electronic payment) for each parent.
12. CHECK LIST COVER letter email received on: 17-NOV-09

13. DS230 Part I and II and Original Civil documents mailed on: 20-NOV-2009
14. Case reached to NVC's system on: 01-DEC-2009 (I called and confirmed)
15. Email received FROM NVC about 'Interview scheduled' on: 11-DEc-2009

16. Medical in A'bad on: 22-DEC-2009
17. Interview in Mumbai on: 22-Jan-2010
18. Asked for Overstayed documents/proof during Interview: 22-Jan-2010
Returned all original documents.
19. Submitted past overstay's proof to local VFS center with passports: 25-Jan-2010

20. Visa/GC papers/Stampe passports Received at home ON: 30-Jan-2010
21. Travel to the US ON: 3-Feb-2010
22. Green Card Received ON:
 
gud 4 u, dude ur a desi urself, u dont have to say DESIs at the consulate, or what ever, u could just say the employees at the consulate .... its not about being a DESI or not a DESI or a DESI working at the consulate
u assswipe!!!
 
My parents got GC papers and passports stamped with such information on saturday (Jan 30 2010).
See # 18, 19, 20 in below timeline.
--
Parents GC timeline - steps

I-130 for Parents of US Citizen for CP (Mumbai, India).
IR-5 category. GC for parents of US citizen.
I-130 for Parents of US Citizen for CP (Mumbai, India).

1. I-130 mailed on 31-Aug-2009 to Chicago.
2. I-130 received date/Priority date: 02-Sep-2009
3. I-130 $355 Checks cashed On: 09-Sep-2009
4. I-130 Approved on: 01-Oct-2009 (Got email on 02-Oct-2009)

5. NVC case# assigned and Choice of Agent form sent: 16-Oct-2009
6. Asked for $70 AOS fee on: 16 Oct 2009
7. Fee $70 paid on 20-OCT-2009 (electronic payment) Only once. which covers both parents.
8. Parents Assigned me as Agent on: 21-Oct-2009

9. Affidavit of support I-864 mailed on: 27-Oct-2009
10. Asked for $400 for IV fee on : 04-NOV-2009
11. Paid $400 for IV fee on : 05-NOV-2009 (electronic payment) for each parent.
12. CHECK LIST COVER letter email received on: 17-NOV-09

13. DS230 Part I and II and Original Civil documents mailed on: 20-NOV-2009
14. Case reached to NVC's system on: 01-DEC-2009 (I called and confirmed)
15. Email received FROM NVC about 'Interview scheduled' on: 11-DEc-2009

16. Medical in A'bad on: 22-DEC-2009
17. Interview in Mumbai on: 22-Jan-2010
18. Asked for Overstayed documents/proof during Interview: 22-Jan-2010
Returned all original documents.
19. Submitted past overstay's proof to local VFS center with passports: 25-Jan-2010

20. Visa/GC papers/Stampe passports Received at home ON: 30-Jan-2010
21. Travel to the US ON: 3-Feb-2010
22. Green Card Received ON:

CAN YOU PLEASE PASS ON ME YOUR CONTACT NO. OR EMAIL TO saleanddiscount@gmail.com .... I would like to talk to you regarding I-130 consular processing since I would be next in my case as soon as my spouse files I-130 for me.
thanks
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Top