Consequences of DUI on Naturalization - By Rajiv S. Khanna

rick92

Volunteer Moderator
Consequences of DUI's on naturalization and green card
Posted 6th January 2009 at 08:02 PM by Rajiv S. Khanna


Quote:
Dear Mr.Khanna, I have reading all your post and found you quite informative. I will appreciate if you can let me know the possible consequences of my case.

I was in restaurant in Gaithersburg MD on Jan 29 2008 with my boss who was visiting from Atlanta. I had a beer and 2 glasses of wine with dinner came out sat in the car and started backing up. As you know it was winter and had rained earlier the windscreen at the back got fogged out. While backing up I hit a car parked. Police was in that parking lot and arrested for drunk driving. I blew .09. I was given a bunch of tickets after being 30 minutes in the precinct and was released. In the court they dismissed 2 tickets like DUI and DUI par se and convicted me DWI and Failure to control Speed to Avoid Collision. BTW DWI in MD is a lesser offence when you blow less than the state .08 BAC typically .07. And Failure to control speed to avoid collision which is maximum fine $130.00.Now the Judge gave me Supervised Probation till I finish my MADD Class. After that the Probation goes to Unsupervised for 12 Months. Now I am elligible to file citizenship. I have finished 5 years of LPR time with minimal travel aborad.

Now my questions are :

1.) Will I get deported or removed.
2.) Will I have problems while entering POE while travelling from overseas.
3.) Will my Citizenship be denied if I file after my probation gets over.

Please share your knowledge It will immensly help my stress. This one mistake of my life has really taken a toll in my life.

Your earliest reply will highly appreciated.


Response from Rajiv:

Let us look at the law for green cards and removal (deportation) first.

Remember the following GENERAL elements of the law (there is more to it).

Traffic violations that are not considered crimes under state law have no implications and create no problems for your green card.

If you have only one conviction ever and it is a misdemeanor, you are AUTOMATICALLY protected by law and forgiven under a provision of law called "petty offense exception."

If you have a conviction for a felony we have to look at the law very carefully, but not all felonies are necessarily a problem fro your green card

For naturalization, even too many traffic tickets can become an issue, if CIS wants to make it so. Generally speaking they look at only the last five years from your application for you history, but there is no law prohibiting them from going back further in time.

Any kind of crimes could become a problem for naturalization and you must get yourself a lawyer if you have a criminal history of any kind.

Both traffic tickets and crimes go to the issue of "good moral character," a prerequisite to naturalization.
 
A bill was introduced by Jeff Flake of the House to make drunk driving a deportable offense. No additional details yet.
 
A bill was introduced by Jeff Flake of the House to make drunk driving a deportable offense. No additional details yet.


It makes sense to make repeated offenders deportable. Every person,especially a noncitizen, should have enough sense not to
drink and drive if he has been already convicted for DUI once
 
It makes sense to make repeated offenders deportable. Every person,especially a noncitizen, should have enough sense not to
drink and drive if he has been already convicted for DUI once
However, if they consider DUI to be serious enough that a first-time permanent resident offender should get deported, to be consistent they should lock up citizens with a first time DUI or at least confiscate their car and license for a long time to make it difficult for them to drive again. Otherwise, this bill is really about harassing immigrants, not fighting DUI. If harsh penalties are to be implemented, it should be harsh for everybody citizen or not ... it's equally damaging to the victim whether they're hit by a citizen or a noncitizen.
 
However, if they consider DUI to be serious enough that a first-time permanent resident offender should get deported, to be consistent they should lock up citizens with a first time DUI or at least confiscate their car and license for a long time to make it difficult for them to drive again. Otherwise, this bill is really about harassing immigrants, not fighting DUI. If harsh penalties are to be implemented, it should be harsh for everybody citizen or not ... it's equally damaging to the victim whether they're hit by a citizen or a noncitizen.

I agree with you 100%. If a DUI is a deportable offense for immigrants, it should bear a heavy fine/imprisonment for citizens as well. If not, then he's encouraging selective (harsh) justice and is trying to (further) discriminate legal immigrants.

I'm sure he's a Republican too.
 
I agree with you 100%. If a DUI is a deportable offense for immigrants, it should bear a heavy fine/imprisonment for citizens as well. If not, then he's encouraging selective (harsh) justice and is trying to (further) discriminate legal immigrants.

I'm sure he's a Republican too.

Not only just trivial offense are deportable, which make criminal punishment
and immigration punishment not proportionate. Even some even
non-criminal activities are deportables if done by non-citizens.
In some parts of Neveda, prostitution is legal. But if non-citizens
do that, they become deportable.

The USCIS can argue deportation is not a punishment
for a deportee. it merely means the person is not welcome
any more in this country
 
Totally agree. Regardless of whether you are a citizen or an illegal alien, DUI/DWI should have the below penalties in my opinion:-

(1) 1st offense, a year in jail
(2) 2nd offense, 5 years in jail
(3) 3rd offense, bullet in the back of the head


If a DUI is a deportable offense for immigrants, it should bear a heavy fine/imprisonment for citizens as well.
 
However, if they consider DUI to be serious enough that a first-time permanent resident offender should get deported, to be consistent they should lock up citizens with a first time DUI or at least confiscate their car and license for a long time to make it difficult for them to drive again. .

I figure that some DUIs are indeed very trivials. I remember in I-485 forum
someone mentioned he was just attending a party and parked his car
as the last one on thehost's drive way. Other guest need to leave, so he needed to pull his car into the street to let others car go. It just that time
a cop was passing by so he got a DUI and was scared for its effect on adjustment of status.

If heavy punishments were imposed on citizens, it would become very unpopular. Citizens had a right to vote politican so politicians don't want
pass a law pebalizing citizens too much
 
Totally agree. Regardless of whether you are a citizen or an illegal alien, DUI/DWI should have the below penalties in my opinion:-

(1) 1st offense, a year in jail
(2) 2nd offense, 5 years in jail
(3) 3rd offense, bullet in the back of the head

Alcohol bussiness will lobby against it. Many people will stop drinking any alcoloho beverage just to be on the same side. It wil hurt business
of the liquor store (many are owned ny state governments), bars, restaurants, etc.
 
I know it is never going to happen in the US. I was just stating what I would personally like to see :)

Alcohol bussiness will lobby against it. Many people will stop drinking any alcoloho beverage just to be on the same side. It wil hurt business
of the liquor store (many are owned ny state governments), bars, restaurants, etc.
 
I know it is never going to happen in the US. I was just stating what I would personally like to see :)

That is why natualization bring many practical benefits including minimizing
consequences of some minor criminal behaviors. It does not make much differences if one is sentenced to death or life sentences. But if 3 month
jail also means deportation for PRs, then there is huge differents between
PR and citizenship.
 
I think most scaring thing is there is no such thing as statute of limitation and double jeapardy in enforcing immmigration law. If you have one small thing
that is deprtable in the past, it may haunt you for life
 
I think most scaring thing is there is no such thing as statute of limitation and double jeapardy in enforcing immmigration law. If you have one small thing
that is deprtable in the past, it may haunt you for life
Even worse, if you have anything that is an offense but is NOT deportable, they can retroactively make it deportable, like what they did with the 1996 law.
 
Even worse, if you have anything that is an offense but is NOT deportable, they can retroactively make it deportable, like what they did with the 1996 law.

I would imagine one day there will be a new law that required an alien to report his crminal offense right within certain period after court trial to
USCIS and failure to do so itself is a deortable offense.
 
There are ways around that one, like having a passenger in the shotgun seat operating the gearshift! :D

You guys sound like you need your own piece of land with a small population to do your testing. !!! Jejeje... :D
 
Top